Civil Rights Act walks the justice talk - Albuquerque Journal

Civil Rights Act walks the justice talk

The Journal Editorial Board and Albuquerque Mayor Tim Keller have come out against New Mexico’s proposed civil rights bill. The bill would make timely justice available, in state courts, to victims of police misconduct. The bill would remove the city’s ability to delay justice through the use of a qualified immunity defense. The Journal and Mayor Keller say compensating victims of incompetent police work is just too expensive. They provide no evidence to support their claim that the bill will add any cost to taxpayers. In fact, passage of the bill would encourage early settlement of most litigation and save municipalities millions of dollars in defense attorney fees and expert fees.

But there are critical human rights issues at stake here as well. In another time and place Keller said this: “We stand in solidarity with the African American community who are grieving the recurring violence against their community.” This civil rights bill is a small step toward combatting recurring violence against the African American community and against all marginalized people in our state. Keller should be the first to support passage of the bill.

On Nov. 8, 2019, Gisell Estrada, an innocent high schooler, turned herself in to Albuquerque police. An Albuquerque detective had obtained a warrant for Gisell’s arrest for murder. The city and the Journal both agree that the charges were false. The detective’s investigation was woefully inadequate. In fact, the Journal endorsed the ACLU’s description of Gisell’s experience as a “Kafkaesque nightmare born of the incompetence of those who have sworn to protect and serve her.” Gisell spent a week in jail. She was subjected to humiliating strip searches and suffered isolation and removal from a loving family and a supportive school environment. Gisell will suffer life-long trauma, loss of educational opportunities and diminishment of income. She needs therapy and educational help. Despite the incredible harm the detective inflicted upon Gisell, he will suffer no criminal prosecution. Keller will not be forced to spend a week in jail and be subjected to strip searches. The only justice available to Gisell is an award of money as compensation for the injuries the city visited upon her. At a critical point in Gisell Estrada’s life, she will learn whether America is true to its promises of freedom and liberty for all or is that just too expensive for herself and others like her.

When Gisell’s lawyers file the federal civil rights lawsuit against the detective, the city will raise qualified immunity. If the city chooses, it can move to stay all discovery. A federal court, in turn, will stay all discovery if the city requests. Gisell and her family will wait a year for a decision from the trial court. If the city loses that motion, it can appeal to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. The attorneys will file briefs, the court will hear arguments and, in about two years, the city will lose its appeal. The city will have paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in defense attorney fees and will have done nothing for Gisell and her family. While Gisell’s claim winds through federal court, the police officer will go on with his career; Keller will be making vacuous speeches about civil rights in some other political post; and a family will try to cope with a daughter’s trauma. The New Mexico Civil Rights Act will remove the litigation strategy and tragedy of delay.

At this critical point in our nation’s history, we should stand with restoring the rights and honor of young children deprived of freedoms, dignities and a fair future rather than with incompetent police work. For one who says he wants to counter police violence against people of color, there is no other choice than to be in favor of a bill that gives the abused access to justice.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Interactive, educational 'Jurassic Quest' comes to Expo New Mexico
'Jurassic Quest' features more than 100 ... 'Jurassic Quest' features more than 100 life-like dinosaurs, dinosaur-themed rides, live dinosaur shows, interactive science and art activities, a 'Triceratots' soft play area for ...
Prep basketball: La Cueva gets past Sandia
Boys' Basketball
The last of Gabe Trujillo's season ... The last of Gabe Trujillo's season high in points were his most important.And his most ...
Best way to honor downwinders? Extend, expand RECA
From the newspaper
Lujan, Leger Fernandez have bills that ... Lujan, Leger Fernandez have bills that will compensate those who were exposed to nuclear radiation without their consent
Clean fuel standard reduces emissions, builds economy
From the newspaper
Bill estimated to earn $470 million, ... Bill estimated to earn $470 million, create 4,000 jobs
Editorial: San Felipe scholar to lead Smithsonian into future
Congratulations to San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia ... Congratulations to San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia Chavez Lamar on becoming the newest director of ...
Editorial: Archdiocese bankruptcy shouldn't be kept in secret
It's time for something to give ... It's time for something to give on the legal logjam holding up payouts from the Archdiocese of ...
Bill expands procurement preference for NM businesses
From the newspaper
Companies owned by veterans, Native Americans ... Companies owned by veterans, Native Americans would benefit
Wild and Scenic River designation honors, protects Apache heritage
From the newspaper
Legislation focuses on Gila and San ... Legislation focuses on Gila and San Francisco rivers and tributaries
'Euphoria' is a crackling live wire of a series
Sam Levinson's brilliant adaptation of the ... Sam Levinson's brilliant adaptation of the Israeli TV series of the same name, season two of 'Euphoria' is the polar opposite of a comfort-viewing ...