House passes aid-in-dying legislation - Albuquerque Journal

House passes aid-in-dying legislation

Rep. Deborah Armstrong, D-Albuquerque, presents a bill she is co-sponsoring to allow medical aid in dying. She participated through a video link as part of new rules intended to limit the transmission of COVID-19. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

SANTA FE — For a few hours Friday night, New Mexico legislators shared stories about watching their loved ones die.

In a debate on the House floor, Democratic Rep. Deborah Armstrong of Albuquerque walked her colleagues through the final days of life of her father in law and, later, a close friend.

Her daughter, Erin, now faces an inoperable brain tumor.

“This is difficult,” Armstrong said of the debate. But “it’s far more difficult to live it than it is to hear about it or talk about it.”

The tearful debate culminated in 39-27 vote to endorse a proposal that would allow terminally ill patients to seek a doctor’s help to end their life — the first time a medical aid-in-dying bill has passed a chamber of the state Legislature. The legislation, House Bill 47, now heads to the Senate.

Opponents raised a variety of objections, such as whether terminally ill patients might feel pressure from their family to take the lethal drugs.

Rep. Ryan Lane, R-Aztec, warned about the possibility of a “life-ending mistake,” especially if a child discovered the medicine.

“I think the government has an interest in seeing its citizens survive,” Lane said. “I think there are a lot of practical concerns with this particular bill.”

Rep. James Strickler, R-Farmington, suggested no one should give up their life. He choked up as he spoke about praying as a teenager for his dad to survive an illness.

He made a miraculous recovery.

“It was a selfish prayer,” Strickler said, “but it worked.”


The proposed End-of-Life Options Act outlines a host of steps before health care providers could prescribe aid-in-dying medication to a patient.

They would have to determine the person had the mental capacity to make the decision, an incurable condition expected to kill them within six months and the ability to self-administer the medicine.

The patient would have to put the request in writing, with the signing witnessed by two people, at least one of whom was unrelated to the patient.

A 48-hour wait would be required before the prescription is filled. For many patients, Armstrong said, they never take the medicine, but having it on hand is a comfort.

The legislation would prohibit criminal or civil liability, professional sanctions or disciplinary action if a health care provider participates or refuses to participate.

A practitioner who doesn’t want to participate, however, would have to refer the individual to someone else.

The bill will now head to the New Mexico Senate, which narrowly rejected a medical aid-in-dying bill four years ago. But the composition of the Senate has changed substantially since then, with 11 of the 42 senators new to the body this year.

Nine states have similar laws.

Emotional stories

In a three-hour debate Friday, supporters and opponents alike shared personal stories about death.

Rep. Dayan Hochman-Vigil, D-Albuquerque, spoke about leaving college to take care of her mother in her final months. Through tears, Hochman-Vigil explained how her mom, at one point, had asked for help ending her life.

“It was a request I couldn’t honor,” Hochman-Vigil said, “for obvious reasons.”

Medical aid in dying, she said, is “about autonomy and compassion and the ability to live one’s life and end one’s life the way they choose.”

Armstrong and Hochman-Vigil are co-sponsors of House Bill 47.

It passed largely along party lines, with Democrats in support and Republicans opposed. Seven Democrats crossed party lines and voted “no,” while one Republican, Kelly Fajardo of Los Lunas, voted in favor.

The proposed law would be named after Elizabeth Whitefield, who testified four years ago in favor of similar legislation. Stricken by cancer and her voice barely a whisper, she had urged lawmakers to give her an option to avoid her family having “to watch me slowly die.”

Whitefield, a retired judge, died 18 months after her testimony.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


TOP OF MIND: Should faith leaders be allowed to ...
ABQnews Seeker
This week's question: Should faith leaders ... This week's question: Should faith leaders be allowed to endorse candidates from the pulpit and retain their institutions' tax-exempt status? Want to participate in ...
Federal medical team leader touts positive experience in New ...
ABQnews Seeker
Disaster assistance group was deployed to ... Disaster assistance group was deployed to San Juan County
Preserving the beauty of the past for the future
ABQnews Seeker
Conservation work starts at historic Córdova ... Conservation work starts at historic Córdova church
Roundhouse bracing for debate on redistricting
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico established a citizen committee ... New Mexico established a citizen committee to hold hearings and develop recommendations
SF Archdiocese set to hold web auction for 427 ...
ABQnews Seeker
First sale in September generated winning ... First sale in September generated winning bids of almost $1.4M
Home of pioneer African American educator gains historic status
ABQnews Seeker
Las Cruces teacher, the current homeowner, ... Las Cruces teacher, the current homeowner, made it her mission to honor Clara Belle Williams
Catalytic converter thefts up across New Mexico
ABQnews Seeker
While thieves fetch as little as ... While thieves fetch as little as $50, replacements costs owners $2,000 to $3,000
Moscow native helped ABQ look beyond borders
ABQnews Seeker
AIA founder exposed city to 'international ... AIA founder exposed city to 'international spark and sizzle'
Prep cross country: Kuykendall's time at elite meet thought ...
ABQnews Seeker
  Hope Christian junior Rendon Kuykendall ...   Hope Christian junior Rendon Kuykendall on Saturday placed 14th in the gold division of the Garmin RunningLane Cross Country Championships in Huntsville, Alabama. ...