The facts about Christus St. Vincent, malpractice fund - Albuquerque Journal

The facts about Christus St. Vincent, malpractice fund

The opinion column written by Dr. Barbara McAneny in the Albuquerque Journal (Feb. 19) misrepresents the facts about Christus St. Vincent Regional Medical Center’s (CSVRMC) participation in New Mexico’s Patient Compensation Fund (PCF). As the only hospital named in her opinion, we feel the need to respond to correct the record on behalf of our providers and the patients we are privileged to serve.

• CSVRMC applied for participation in the fund in 2009 because in 1976 the New Mexico Malpractice Act Section 41-5-3 was written to allow hospitals to be covered as participants in the PCF.

• CSVRMC underwent underwriting, providing required data to the actuaries of the Office of the Superintendent of Insurance (OSI). From this data, they based their recommendation of a significant surcharge for participation in the PCF and qualified CSVRMC as a provider. This standard process was neither secret nor a special deal. This is the same process that other New Mexico hospitals have undergone to participate in the PCF. As part of its participation in the PCF, CSVRMC has paid yearly surcharges for the past 12 years.

• As a result of participation, CSVRMC and other hospitals are excluded from the three-occurrence limit per the statute. This has allowed physicians a high degree of confidence that hospitals are better positioned to work alongside them in protecting the delivery of health care across New Mexico because hospitals share in the malpractice risk.

A fully functioning PCF that includes hospitals and physicians is vital to providing the malpractice coverage that health care providers need to stay in the state. Hospital participation in the fund has strengthened the fund and allowed for a cohesive and fair adjudication of disputes on a playing field that the New Mexico Legislature has supported since its passage 45 years ago.

House Bill 75 is making its way through the Legislature. It would remove hospitals from the PCF and would eliminate a hospital’s ability to obtain reasonable insurance coverage. In addition, HB 75 will inhibit the ability to recruit and retain providers to the state. N.M. hospitals employ a high percentage of the state’s doctors who are counting on the PCF to keep malpractice insurance costs fair. Reasonable malpractice costs are key to attracting and retaining health care professionals. The rural parts of our state already struggle with inadequate access to care, and this proposed legislation will only exacerbate this situation as physicians and specialists will leave the state for other locations where they can purchase the insurance coverage they need and can reasonably afford.

There is a similar bill making its way through this legislative session which is far more favorable. Senate Bill 239 seeks to protect patients and clinicians by preserving hospital participation in the PCF, and ensuring that funds are available to adequately compensate patients who have been injured in the rare event of medical malpractice. To reinforce the viability of the PCF for the long term, SB 239 was drafted in large part from analysis completed by the OSI.

SB 239 is supported by the New Mexico Clinician Coalition. This bill reflects the urgency that clinicians across our state – including the overwhelming majority of physicians, nurses and hospitals – feel to develop a comprehensive fix to the Medical Malpractice Act. Any legislation should be structured to keep the PCF as strong as possible, for as long as possible.

I’m proud that Christus St. Vincent is a not-for-profit entity, that zero funds have left New Mexico from its operations and that its funds are 100% re-invested to provide excellent health care delivery in Santa Fe and Northern New Mexico. Avenues such as the PCF allow them and other hospitals to maximize their investments in delivering high-quality care to our community.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » The facts about Christus St. Vincent, malpractice fund


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Singer-songwriter Jimmy Climbs is bringing 'neon pop' to Albuquerque's ...
Entertainment
Singer-songwriter to drop debut album next ... Singer-songwriter to drop debut album next week; release party is Saturday, Oct. 1 at Insideout
2
James McMurtry bringing tour to the Lobo Theater
Entertainment
James McMurtry will bring his latest ... James McMurtry will bring his latest tour to Albuquerque at 7:30 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 6, at the Lobo Theater in Nob Hill.
3
Albuquerque Grecian Festival offers a taste of culture
Entertainment
Event runs Sept. 30 through Oct. ... Event runs Sept. 30 through Oct. 2 at the Saint George Greek Orthodox Church
4
Shinedown brings honesty, revelation with 'Planet Zero' when society ...
Entertainment
Group to perform at Isleta Pavilion ... Group to perform at Isleta Pavilion on Oct. 5
5
Songwriter gigi finds a place for comfort with music, ...
Entertainment
Gigi finds herself in the opening ... Gigi finds herself in the opening slot for Cyrus' tour, which makes a stop in Albuquerque at the El Rey Theater at 8 p.m. ...
6
It's lights out at the San Juan Generating Station
ABQnews Seeker
Coal-fired operation shuts down after five ... Coal-fired operation shuts down after five decades, marking the end of an era
7
Lobo basketball team hopes size solves problems
ABQnews Seeker
The Lobos proved they could score ... The Lobos proved they could score some points in fast-paced games last season. But to take the next step, they added size and strength.
8
NM economy won't thrive until we educate our workforce
From the newspaper
Leadership needed to make this a ... Leadership needed to make this a land of opportunity
9
Editorial: NM GOP needs to explain doctored mailer
Editorials
An altered stock image of darkened ... An altered stock image of darkened hands cutting a white child's hair sure does appear to play ...