Report: NM health reform could cost thousands of jobs - Albuquerque Journal

Report: NM health reform could cost thousands of jobs

A much-debated effort to secure near-universal health care for New Mexicans could come with a hefty financial toll, according to a recent analysis conducted by Ernst & Young.

The study examines the macroeconomic implications of the New Mexico Health Security Plan, which was considered by state legislators in 2019 and reintroduced this year via House Bill 203.

The analysis, prepared on behalf of Partnership for America’s Health Care Future, which opposes single-payer health care, concludes that the HSP could lead to as much as a $5.8 billion shortfall over five years after implementation, and would require a payroll tax increase to offset that shortfall.

The high-end payroll tax estimate could cost the state as much as 27,000 job equivalents, a metric that factors in wage and hour reductions, according to study author Brandon Pizzola.

However, Mary Feldblum, executive director of the Health Security for New Mexicans Campaign, criticized the study as misleading and limited in scope.

“It’s not a serious study. It really isn’t,” Feldblum said.

The new study builds on a report commissioned by the Legislative Finance Committee in 2019 that considered the cost of the proposal. The LFC-commissioned report included four scenarios, which Ernst & Young ran through a standard macroeconomic model to get results, according to Pizzola.

According to the study, New Mexico ends up with a budget shortfall over the first five years after the program is implemented in three of the four scenarios. The report notes that the final scenario results in the program being approximately budget-neutral over that period.

Pizzola said the report assumes a broad-based payroll tax implemented by the state to cover that shortfall. Estimated taxes range from 2.3% to 0.3%.

Under the scenario where New Mexico faces a hypothetical $5.8 billion shortfall, the report concludes that a 2.3% payroll tax would result in a $290 million annual decline in gross state product.

Ashley Wagner, director of public policy and communications for the New Mexico Chamber of Commerce, said she’s concerned the bill could hurt economic growth in New Mexico just as the state is looking to recover from the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“This is going to be an added tax,” Wagner said. “… It just seems would be counterproductive to getting us back on the path for economic recovery.”

However, Feldblum argued that the report makes assumptions that may be inaccurate. The report uses data from 2019, which Feldblum argues is likely insufficient for projecting the cost of a program slated to begin in 2024, given the seismic economic changes in 2020.

Feldblum added that the report’s narrow focus doesn’t take into account the overall rising cost of health care, and the ways that expanded health care coverage can reduce costs in the long run.

“When you have a large number of people who are uninsured, you have to factor in that they’re going to cost extra money,” Feldblum said.

Feldblum said she doesn’t expect HB204 to pass in the session’s final days, but said she’s hopeful the groundwork has been laid for future efforts.

Home » Business » Health Care » Report: NM health reform could cost thousands of jobs


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Ronchetti trades barbs with rivals in TV debate
2022 election
GOP gubernatorial candidates discuss border, abortion, ... GOP gubernatorial candidates discuss border, abortion, Trump loyalty
2
Families of 39,500 NM students to get food credits
ABQnews Seeker
$2.3M in federal money to help ... $2.3M in federal money to help cover missed free meals
3
Cow milk can briefly substitute for baby formula
ABQnews Seeker
Pediatrician says it can be used ... Pediatrician says it can be used for babies older than 6 months
4
Dogs show their stuff on catwalk
ABQnews Seeker
Sunday's Mutt Strutt gives canines chance ... Sunday's Mutt Strutt gives canines chance to win prizes, get vaccines and microchips
5
ABQ'S speed cameras go live Wednesday; here's the 411
ABQnews Seeker
No more warnings, $100 fines No more warnings, $100 fines
6
Scandinavia's leading airline adopts Albuquerque firm's software
ABQnews Seeker
Ultramain will deploy its 'electronic logbook' ... Ultramain will deploy its 'electronic logbook' on all Scandinavian Airlines System ai
7
APD: Day-drinking preceded man firing at police
ABQnews Seeker
Suspect charged with assault on peace ... Suspect charged with assault on peace officer
8
Governor meets with federal officials
ABQnews Seeker
Wildfires, wedding on the agenda while ... Wildfires, wedding on the agenda while in Washington, D.C
9
Ex-guard in Grants charged with rape
ABQnews Seeker
Suspect told police that he also ... Suspect told police that he also snuck in contraband for inmate, her cellmates