Writer's water proposals just don't hold H20 - Albuquerque Journal

Writer’s water proposals just don’t hold H20

When I read the letter to the editor in Sunday’s (March 21) Journal, “Water, water everywhere, except farms” … I was surprised by (the) obvious lack of knowledge on the topic, as well as naivety present. I assume (the author’s) attention is directed specifically at the U.S. Southwest rather than the entire world.

… Around 2.5% of all water (in the world) is considered drinkable and less than one-third of that can actually be made available for use – where the water is, how to actually get that water to where it is needed, in addition (to) having the legal right to that water … are serious issues. A good book that describes in some detail the water and/or lack of it in the West is the book “Cadillac Desert” by Marc Reisner, published in 1986; (it) is a valuable tool to understand water source and water needs in the Southwest. It is dated, but the issues are more relevant than when the book was written. (It is also helpful) to read about the impending water crisis on the Lower Colorado River and possible water restrictions being considered by as early as 2022 for water users.

Most of (the) list of possible actions to be taken have been explored by others in the past, and some continue into the present. Several of the proposed actions have not been considered because they are not possible or not in the realm of reality. These are as follows:

• Moving floodwaters from state to state would be not possible as the ability to capture, store and transmit would be not only cost-prohibitive, but also face numerous legal impediments.

• Transferring water from Canada to the United States is equally impossible. In the United States, we can’t even transfer water from state to state. Water is sadly seen by most people as something that can’t be shared.

• (The) discussion of flying pieces of glaciers to our lakes is more than a giant leap of faith. Evaluations of floating icebergs in the Pacific Ocean from Alaska to places like Santa Barbara have been performed to some extent in the past, as have thoughts of constructing a pipeline between those locations. I have never heard of “flying” pieces of glaciers anywhere to lakes as a source of water for farming or irrigation. At 8.34 pounds per gallon of water, the cost associated with transporting by air would be prohibitive.

One of the more sound ideas for the Colorado River issue is to construct sufficient desalination plants for the Colorado River water users along the coast, the cost of construction and energy to be provided by those not along the coast – Nevada and Arizona, for example – and let those along the coast use that water while letting Nevada and Arizona use the Lower Colorado water. The energy costs would be enormous using current power technology and would be blocked by environmentalists for any number of reasons.

The simplest solution is simply to not allow development or farming where there is no sustainable water supply. What a novel thought. Tell that to the folks in Las Vegas and Phoenix, along with Imperial Valley farmers.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Writer’s water proposals just don’t hold H20


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Fishing Line for May 19, 2022
Fishing Line
CATCHES OF THE WEEK ... CATCHES OF THE WEEK ...
2
Check out these plants!
From the newspaper
ABQ-BernCo Seed Library offers card holders ... ABQ-BernCo Seed Library offers card holders a unique gardening opportunity.
3
The Small Glories coming to NM for concerts, workshops
Entertainment
The Canadian duo will play in ... The Canadian duo will play in Albuquerque and Santa Fe.
4
What's happening in ABQ May 20-26: Blue corn pancakes, ...
Coming This Week
Raindrop Albuquerque is hosting a fundraising ... Raindrop Albuquerque is hosting a fundraising event to assist the wildfire relief efforts through a brunch. What's happening in ABQ May 20-26
5
Editorial: Journal backs Garcia Holmes and Vasquez in CD1 ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements for contested primary races for the U.S. House of Repr ...
6
NM still suffering fallout of guv's COVID-19 response
From the newspaper
Lujan Grisham's heavy-handed approach should negate ... Lujan Grisham's heavy-handed approach should negate second term
7
Biden vows full support for NM fire recovery
ABQnews Seeker
Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire surpasses 300,000 ... Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire surpasses 300,000 acres
8
11-year-old joins fight to help the homeless
ABQnews Seeker
'I didn't know kids at my ... 'I didn't know kids at my school could be homeless,' Russell explains
9
BernCo Commission race attracts three Republicans
2022 election
Each is running for the first ... Each is running for the first time due to concern for their community