Court transparency key to justice - Albuquerque Journal

Court transparency key to justice

Transparency issues often focus on elected bodies and whether they follow law governing public meetings, or executive agencies and whether they comply with statutes like N.M.’s Inspection of Public Records Act.

Important questions, to be sure. But a judicial system that is open and accessible to the public is every bit as important, or perhaps more so, when we consider its role in a functioning democracy. It is the courts, after all, that arbitrate disputes on access issues involving other branches of government. It is the courts and jury system that resolve civil disputes and ultimately decide whether criminal conduct merits the deprivation of liberty.

Chief Justice Michael Vigil of the N.M. Supreme Court shared his thoughts on this: “New Mexico courts recognize the critical importance of allowing the public to see and hear for themselves how our justice system fairly and impartially resolves legal disputes. Without that transparency and access, we risk an erosion of public confidence in the rule of law and trust in our independent judicial branch of government. Our democracy depends on maintaining that public confidence and trust.”

Given the openness of N.M.’s court system, which as far back as the 1980s had the foresight to allow photography and televising of court proceedings, it would be easy to take for granted the judicial system has always operated in this fashion. And that would be wrong.

“Star chamber” remains part of our current day lexicon and refers pejoratively to any secret or closed meeting by a judicial or executive body. Rooted in English history, the Star Chamber was well-intended but came to abuse its powers, using torture to obtain confessions and meting out sentences that included whipping, pillory, prison and mutilation, according to the First Amendment Encyclopedia. Jurors were sometimes punished for finding verdicts against the Crown, and King Charles I used the Star Chamber to crush opposition to his policies.

It’s not beyond the pale to image some politicians, if given free rein, would find this a useful tool.

The Star Chamber was abolished by Parliament in 1641, and historically many court proceedings in this country were open. But it wasn’t until 1980 in a case called Richmond Newspapers Inc. v. Virginia that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the First Amendment generally prohibits closing criminal trial proceedings to the public. The underlying case was a high-profile murder prosecution, and the court’s plurality opinion noted, correctly, that secrecy… “limits the stock of information from which members of the public may draw.”

The right for the public to attend isn’t absolute, but to close a criminal case courts must exhaust all reasonable alternatives and make specific findings why closure is necessary. We just witnessed how the justice system works with the Derek Chauvin prosecution in Minneapolis. Imagine how damaging it would have been to the system had this been done in secret. The U.S. Supreme Court would be well-served to adopt the same procedures in the federal system to allow photography and broadcasting.

This guest column is part of FOG’s Transparency: Key to Democracy Project. Accountability ensures government is held responsible to the citizenry; transparency gives the public the right to access government information and requires decisions and actions made by the government to be open to public scrutiny and occur in the light.

 


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Prep volleyball: No. 1 Hope Christian beats defending state ...
Featured Sports
As the state tournament draws ever ... As the state tournament draws ever nearer, it's becoming more likely that the team everyone will be ...
2
In local Korn Ferry qualifier, stress falls upon middle ...
Featured Sports
When it comes to the qualifying ... When it comes to the qualifying school of the Korn Ferry Tour for professional golfers, Scott Harrin ...
3
Gonzales: It's time for Lobo offense to step up
College
During the past two weeks, the ... During the past two weeks, the University of New Mexico (2-5, 0-3 Mountain West) has scored two touc ...
4
Longtime APS athletic director Barreras steps aside
Featured Sports
Albuquerque Public Schools will be searching ... Albuquerque Public Schools will be searching for a new athletic director.Kenny Barrera ...
5
United's playoff push to go on without Sandoval
Featured Sports
It's not the type of finish ... It's not the type of finish Devon Sandoval envisioned. Sandoval, an Albuquerque native and the recognized face of New Mexico United's franchise, took to ...
6
Playing future in doubt for United's Sandoval
Featured Sports
It's not the type of finish ... It's not the type of finish Devon Sandoval envisioned.Sandoval, an Albuquerque native ...
7
Farm & Table, La Parada hosting Dia de los ...
Arts
Farm & Table restaurant and its ... Farm & Table restaurant and its adjacent store La Parada are hosting a free community celebratio ...
8
Man's death in custody of APD ruled a homicide
ABQnews Seeker
Officers found to have violated policy ... Officers found to have violated policy in use-of-force procedures
9
Fishing Line for Oct. 21, 2021
Fishing Line
CATCHES OF THE WEEK Brandon Marshall ... CATCHES OF THE WEEK Brandon Marshall of Las Cruces caught a 9-pound catfish at Bill Evans Lake using a nightcrawler worm Oct. 8. Joaquin ...