Editorial: Judge sends 47-year message on abuse, duty of guardianships - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Judge sends 47-year message on abuse, duty of guardianships

U.S. District Judge Martha Vázquez sent a powerful, 47-year message to the guardianship/conservatorship industry in New Mexico last week. That’s the length of the prison term she imposed on Susan Harris, founder and former president of Ayudando Guardians Inc. of Albuquerque, during a sentencing hearing in Santa Fe.

For Harris, 74, it is in effect a life sentence – one that is more than justified.

It’s also one that others who are given court authority to oversee the lives and finances of vulnerable people incapable of making their own decisions would do well to heed when it comes to exploiting those they are entrusted to safeguard.

The criminal enterprise that operated out of the firm pilfered more than $11 million from client accounts over a decade. Yes, hard as it is to believe, the courts, a state guardianship agency, the Social Security Administration and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs never figured out Ayudando’s principals – Susan Harris and chief financial officer Sharon Moore – were systematically stealing government benefits and other money from their clients to finance a lavish lifestyle for themselves and their families. Illegal perks included Hawaii vacations, Caribbean cruises, cars, RVs and a private box at University of New Mexico basketball games with nightly catering tabs in excess of $3,000.

The criminal case is over, with Moore, William Harris (Susan’s husband and Ayudando guardian representative) and his stepson, Craig Young (Ayudando caseworker) also sentenced to prison.

How could this have happened in an industry overseen in many cases by the courts and, depending on the client, by other state and federal agencies?

In part it’s because we have had a history of ignoring those who need this kind of help and their families when they have complained. In the case of Ayudando, clients who said they weren’t receiving the appropriate money from their accounts simply were disregarded. It took the courage of company employees to come forward as whistleblowers in 2016 and spur a federal investigation that finally brought down this horrific scheme, fueled by what Vázquez characterized as “unbelievable greed.”

There has been plenty of this kind of abuse in the industry, and on occasion it has been prosecuted in New Mexico.

In February of 2019 Paul Donisthorpe was sentenced to 12 years in federal prison after his decade-long scheme to steal roughly $6.8 million from 70 clients of his nonprofit trust company. Desert State Life Management, a state-regulated guardianship and financial firm, was brought down by state regulators who conducted an overdue audit and noticed irregularities. Desert State acted as conservator and fiduciary for developmentally or physically disabled and elderly individuals.

“The victims,” U.S. District Judge James Browning said in passing sentence, “will have to suffer for the rest of their lives so he (Donisthorpe) could live a high-end lifestyle.”

Sound familiar?

Vázquez correctly noted the Ayudando case inflicted damage beyond that suffered by vulnerable clients, including military veterans who relied on Ayudando to manage their government benefits.

“The scope of the defendants’ fraud and their success fooling state and federal agencies for years,” Vázquez said at sentencing, “has done significant damage to the public’s confidence in New Mexico system of guardianship as well as confidence more generally in the government’s ability to protect its most vulnerable citizens and veterans to whom it owes its highest duty of care.”

Following publication of a series of Albuquerque Journal stories beginning in November 2016, the New Mexico Supreme Court and Legislature have taken important steps to improve accountability in the system of guardianships and conservatorships. There is now more transparency. Families have more recourse to intervene on behalf of loved ones, and the state auditor and the Administrative Office of the Courts will provide additional oversight thanks to legislative reforms enacted just this year.

The system is better. But to make a real difference it will require meaningful oversight, actually listening to vulnerable clients and their families and zero tolerance for exploitation – a message delivered loud and clear by Judge Vázquez.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Judge sends 47-year message on abuse, duty of guardianships

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

Editorial: Feds responsible for long-term water upgrades in Las ...
If you break it, you buy ... If you break it, you buy it.    The Pottery Barn rule applies to more than earthenwar ...
Editorial: Status quo at Coronado Park is unacceptable
Some homeless advocates are asking the ... Some homeless advocates are asking the city to delay closing Coronado Park because there is no real ...
Editorial: Packing pepper spray a sad commentary on Downtown ...
Predators better not get aggressive with ... Predators better not get aggressive with Bernalillo County workers on their way to and from work. Be ...
Editorial: Vo-tech, welfare reform can fix our dismal worker ...
New Mexico is in an economic ... New Mexico is in an economic rut.    It's not due to a shortage of jobs. More t ...
Editorial: PED’s ‘restorative’ discipline should not forget victims
The New Mexico Public Education Department's ... The New Mexico Public Education Department's heart is in the right place with a new discipline ...
Editorial: Recreational pot's greener pastures still elusive for some
"New Mexico's cannabis legalization policy must ... "New Mexico's cannabis legalization policy must ensure equity and diversity, while reinv ...
Editorial: IPRA brush-off by Corrections Department is inexcusable
When a state agency blows off ... When a state agency blows off a state senator's request for public documents, something is ter ...
Editorial: Defendant's GPS data is a real public safety ...
District Attorney Raul Torrez says that, ... District Attorney Raul Torrez says that, if he had been told he'd have to file a lawsuit against ...
Editorial: Know something? Say something to solve Muslim killings
Someone knows something. And we need ... Someone knows something. And we need them to speak up before another person is added to the recent s ...