Justices say 24/7 video surveillance violated man’s rights

DENVER — The Colorado Supreme Court ruled Monday that police officers violated a man’s constitutional rights when they installed a video camera on a utility pole near his home and spied on him for months without getting a search warrant.

The justices said the 24-hour-a-day, 3-month-long surveillance of the Colorado Springs man’s front yard, house, driveway and part of his backyard violated his Fourth Amendment protections against unreasonable searches and seizures, The Denver Post reported. His conviction and 15-year-prison sentence for drug trafficking were overturned.

The unanimous decision differentiates between police officers personally watching suspects and officers using technology to record a person’s every move for extended periods of time.

The man had a reasonable expectation of privacy in his yard, even though parts of the area were visible to the public, the court found. And the Colorado Springs Police Department should have received a search warrant before setting up the camera, which could pan and zoom to see over the man’s 6-foot-tall (1.8-meter-tall) fence.

The justices also rejected the state’s argument that the surveillance wasn’t as intrusive as GPS tracking or the use of cellphone data, noting that constant surveillance “shares many of the troubling attributes of GPS tracking.”

Share Your Story

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango


taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Texas announces audit of 2020 votes after Trump urges ...
Around the Region
Texas election officials said Thursday night ... Texas election officials said Thursday night they were auditing the 2020 results in four large counties hours after former President Donald Trump, continuing to ...
2
Scottsdale workers to be trained how to identify trafficking
Around the Region
Over 2,400 municipal employees of Scottsdale, ... Over 2,400 municipal employees of Scottsdale, a Phoenix suburb with a tourism industry serving large numbers of visitors, are to undergo training in how ...
3
Police arrest 6 in catalytic converter thefts in Mesa
Around the Region
Police in Mesa have arrested six ... Police in Mesa have arrested six people who allegedly were stealing catalytic converters from the undersides of cars and vans, authorities said. The arrests ...
4
Sheriff: Man snatches woman's purse before running her over
Around the Region
A Houston-area woman was run over ... A Houston-area woman was run over and killed Thursday as a man was making his getaway after snatching her purse, Harris County Sheriff Ed ...
5
Buckle up: Arizona Republicans to show 2020 recount results
Around the Region
Donald Trump supporters hired by Arizona ... Donald Trump supporters hired by Arizona Senate Republicans to review the 2020 vote count are preparing to deliver their findings on Friday, the climax ...
6
Final version of Colorado congressional maps released
Around the Region
Colorado's Independent Redistricting Commission released its ... Colorado's Independent Redistricting Commission released its final congressional map on Thursday, sketching out a possible future in which solidly Democratic Colorado has an evenly-divided ...
7
Colorado woman charged with killing stepson will stand trial
Around the Region
A Colorado woman charged with killing ... A Colorado woman charged with killing her 11-year-old stepson will stand trial, a judge ruled Thursday after reviewing evidence in the case. Authorities allege ...
8
Pet resort caught on fire, city asks fire code ...
Around the Region
The city of Georgetown is recommending ... The city of Georgetown is recommending updates to the city's fire code after a pet boarding facility caught fire, killing all 75 dogs that ...
9
Ex-Tempe police detective dies after getting West Nile virus
Around the Region
A former Tempe police detective has ... A former Tempe police detective has died after contracting West Nile virus, authorities said Thursday. Police officials said Nathan Ryberg had been in a ...