Supreme Court makes a massive mistake on abortion - Albuquerque Journal

Supreme Court makes a massive mistake on abortion

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) has made a grievous blunder in its decision to deny injunctive relief to plaintiffs in Whole Woman’s Health et Al v. Austin Reeve, Judge, et Al. This grievous mistake will erode any and all subsequent SCOTUS decisions, especially with regard to abortion.

SB 8 is clearly unconstitutional because it bans most abortions in Texas. Chief among SCOTUS’ reasons for the denial to plaintiffs of injunctive relief is that plaintiffs have not met their burden of making a strong showing they are likely to succeed on the merits. The right of a woman to have an abortion is still the law of the land; SB 8 is contrary to that established in Roe v. Wade. Therefore, even a cursory look would alert even the most unsophisicated observer – let alone the learned justices of SCOTUS – that, yes, plaintiffs have met their burden.

SCOTUS’ other reasons for the denial of injunctive relief are completely absurd. For example, SCOTUS stated another reason is that “The sole private-citizen respondent before us has filed an affidavit stating that he has no present intention to enforce the law.” Having no present intention does not negate a future intention.

Morever, what about the intentions of literally countless other private citizens to enforce the law? Surely, at least one among them would admit to having a present intention to enforce the law? This is an absurd reason, but again, plaintiffs have met their burden. Having done so, SCOTUS should clearly have granted plaintiffs injunctive relief and acted to protect the law as it stands now. Doing so would give legitimacy to SCOTUS’ decision to overturn Roe v. Wade at a later date.

My point is simply this: If SCOTUS is to have its rulings held legitimate and respected throughout this great nation of ours, it should act to protect and enforce the law. The law regarding abortion as it stands currently is that a woman has the right to an abortion. SB 8 is contrary to that right; therefore SCOTUS should have granted plaintiffs injunctive relief instead of inventing “novel” reasons for denying plaintiffs relief. Doing so, upholding and protecting the law now would legitimize SCOTUS’ decision to overturn Roe v. Wade at a later date when that happens. Anyone who keeps an eye on SCOTUS will affirm that is where SCOTUS is going.

For that key reason, SCOTUS showed no wisdom at all and severely blundered in denying plaintifs’ injuctive relief. Granting plaintiffs injunctive relief may, at the moment, benefit pro-abortion supporters. However, in the long run, it would actually benefit the contrarian view because it would show to the whole nation and, indeed, world that SCOTUS acted swiftly and justly to protect the law, even when it was not palatable to the majority of the justices to do so. Thus, when SCOTUS overturns Roe v. Wade, that action would be legitimate.

Alexander Vang is an assistant city attorney for Albuquerque. His statements here are his own private thoughts and do not represent the views of the city of Albuquerque.

https://www.abqjournal.com/?p=2430154&preview=true


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Farm & Table, La Parada hosting Dia de los ...
Arts
Farm & Table restaurant and its ... Farm & Table restaurant and its adjacent store La Parada are hosting a free community celebratio ...
2
Man's death in custody of APD ruled a homicide
ABQnews Seeker
Officers found to have violated policy ... Officers found to have violated policy in use-of-force procedures
3
Fishing Line for Oct. 21, 2021
Fishing Line
CATCHES OF THE WEEK Brandon Marshall ... CATCHES OF THE WEEK Brandon Marshall of Las Cruces caught a 9-pound catfish at Bill Evans Lake using a nightcrawler worm Oct. 8. Joaquin ...
4
Navajo group claims uranium mining violates its human rights
ABQnews Seeker
Community resistance to mine license dates ... Community resistance to mine license dates back to mid-1990s
5
Lovebirds flock to reopened county building for licenses
ABQnews Seeker
Some marriages delayed after closure of ... Some marriages delayed after closure of headquarters due to vandalism incidents
6
Police shooting in homicide probe is detailed
ABQnews Seeker
Suspected carjacking by person of interest Suspected carjacking by person of interest
7
Spice world: 'Dune' a mind-boggling, jaw-dropping futuristic feast for ...
Entertainment
The jaw-dropping visuals and pulse-pounding sound ... The jaw-dropping visuals and pulse-pounding sound editing in Denis Villeneuve's stunningly gorgeous ...
8
'We give it our all': Canadian rap duo Snotty ...
Entertainment
For Darren Metz and Quinton Nyce, ... For Darren Metz and Quinton Nyce, there's a lot to pack into their album "Life After." ...
9
'Getting it done': Pandemic gave musician David Climaco Garcia ...
Entertainment
Getting to the release of "Between ... Getting to the release of "Between the Devil and Me" has been a long haul for David Climaco Garcia.< ...