Pass RECA changes and apologize to our peoples - Albuquerque Journal

Pass RECA changes and apologize to our peoples

I am writing in response to professor James Rice’s “Do the ends justify the means?” column and his lack of solidarity with the Tularosa Basin Downwinder’s Consortium (TBDC).

TBDC and other impacted communities like mine have worked tirelessly as front-line peoples living daily with impacts from nuclear colonialism and militarization of our state. Our entire state deserves compensation and free health care, and for the proposed amendments to the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act to pass and be inclusive of all communities suffering intergenerational harm from past and present nuclear impacts.

We live with the cancers, illness, miscarriages, birth defects, deaths, environmental violence, lack of access to our cultural and ancestral sites due to contamination or land theft, and many other examples of physical, spiritual, mental and cultural harm. To reduce these past and present experiences to being valid only with a peer-reviewed scientific journal and process is one of many examples of scientific racism.

In 1945, no studies were being prioritized for Indigenous, land-based and Peoples of Color communities adjacent to the Trinity site. Communities were still practicing home births, and not all birth outcomes could have been recorded. We were (and are) citizens treated as collateral damage for military activities, including the Trinity test. Nuclear exposure regulations back then and today are based on effects on an adult, white male, not an Indigenous or land-based pregnant person.

That there is currently any scientific process from the federal government that exists to support communities harmed has not been my experience. This is especially true for land-based communities in the past. If there was equity for Indigenous and other impacted communities’ ways of knowing, we would not need exhaustive resources or to be dependent on outside “expertise” to come in and speak on our behalf. Our voices should be heard and valued as equal to those of scientists. We do not need them to speak for us, but we do need their support and advocacy. We have our own ways of knowing that are just as valid.

It is the dismissive, patronizing and perceived superiority of professor Rice’s tone as a member of the social scientific community that is really “troubling.”

Our way of life is not considered in exposure regulations and cleanup standards. There have never been studies to determine the cumulative and multiple exposures to a variety of toxins, including radionuclides, among the Indigenous and land-based peoples of New Mexico over long periods of time, much less on our reproductive health.

The burden of proof still falls on us and other frontline advocates, such as the TBDC, to demonstrate the harm we see happening all around us. This is injustice. Pass the RECA amendments, grant our peoples an apology, and let us get to work restoring health and wellness to our state.

Editor’s note: Proposed RECA amendments supported by members of New Mexico’s congressional delegation would expand geographic downwinder eligibility; expand eligibility for certain individuals who have worked in uranium mines, mills or transporting uranium ore; increase compensation amounts; extend RECA for another 19 years beyond a 2022 sunset; and provide compensation for additional forms of cancer.

Beata Tsosie is from Santa Clara Pueblo.

 


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Sunport has second-busiest stretch in 20 months
ABQnews Seeker
65,000 holiday travelers reported over 5-day ... 65,000 holiday travelers reported over 5-day period
2
New trial begins for Rio Arriba sheriff
ABQnews Seeker
James Lujan is charged with helping ... James Lujan is charged with helping a friend avoid arrest in 2017
3
Elk poached at Bandelier National Monument
ABQnews Seeker
Park rangers are seeking the public's ... Park rangers are seeking the public's help in finding those responsible for that killing, as well as the death of a mule deer
4
NMSU has nutty idea for citations
ABQnews Seeker
Donations of peanut butter will be ... Donations of peanut butter will be accepted in lieu of some parking fines
5
1 killed in fight south of UNM
ABQnews Seeker
Homicide detectives are investigating after a ... Homicide detectives are investigating after a man died in a fight in an alley near the University of New Mexico Monday night. Officer Daren ...
6
Police say driver in fatal DWI crash traveling at ...
ABQnews Seeker
19-year-old was arrested four days earlier ... 19-year-old was arrested four days earlier in Roswell drunken-driving wreck
7
NM weighs use of federal money for broadband
ABQnews Seeker
Stimulus, infrastructure bills offer chance, legislators ... Stimulus, infrastructure bills offer chance, legislators told
8
NM has no omicron cases, but struggles with delta ...
ABQnews Seeker
Signs show virus surge could be ... Signs show virus surge could be slowing in state
9
DA removed from homicide case
ABQnews Seeker
FARMINGTON – A New ... FARMINGTON – A New Mexico judge has ruled that a district attorney's office must be replaced ...