Did you know police officers can legally lie to you in most states? - Albuquerque Journal

Did you know police officers can legally lie to you in most states?

How many times have you seen these scenarios play out on a TV crime drama? The savvy detective tells a scared kid in the interrogation room that if he will just confess, the cops can promise leniency. Or the investigator tells the juvenile that his buddy in the other room has spilled his guts. To save himself, the suspect is told, he needs to start talking and confess to his crime. Except the kid in the other room hasn’t actually said anything yet.

Now, two states – Illinois and Oregon – have passed laws forbidding police from using deception when dealing with suspects under the age of 18. Other states – Washington, Connecticut, Delaware and New York – are considering similar legislation. The latter proposal extends beyond just minors and would also prohibit police from lying to anyone being interrogated.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1969 it was okay for police to be deceitful while questioning suspects. And, for decades, police have employed what’s known as the Reid technique of interrogation. It has three main approaches: Isolate the suspect; confront the suspect assuming they are guilty and present them with “incriminating evidence that may or may not be genuine;” and provide the suspect with face-saving excuses for their crime, such as, “it was an accident or that the victim deserved it.”

While this tactic has likely resulted in countless solid confessions, studies have shown that minors, the developmentally disabled and some adults are particularly susceptible to coercive ploys, especially if the interrogations are lengthy. Frightened and immature young people are prone to falsely confessing, and have done so in nearly 30% of the cases that were later overturned on the strength of DNA evidence. And once jurors hear about a confession, a verdict of guilty usually follows. The system has relegated so many to live life as a convicted felon when the only thing they are guilty of is using poor judgment to get out of an interrogation room.

False confessions are hard for the public to understand, but they are a fact of life. In the effort to create more quality interrogations, about 30 states currently require police to videotape their interviews with suspects and that, like police body cameras, can go a long way to help root out either coercive cops or flip-flopping defendants who later claim they did not confess. Federal investigators at the FBI, DEA, ATF and other agencies are also instructed to record all interrogations.

The guilt-presumptive Reid technique is still being taught, but, in recent years, it has begun to fall out of favor with a few police departments and at least one major interrogation consulting firm that also trains officers in the art of questioning suspects. One of the big complaints about the Reid method is that it can lead to long, aggressive sessions during which detectives can inadvertently feed an innocent person specific details about a case, which can then be regurgitated by the defendant during a false confession.

So, perhaps there is another way to get at the truth?

In the United Kingdom, officers are not allowed to lie to a suspect. They employ the so-called PEACE method of interrogation. The acronym stands for Preparation and Planning, Engage and Explain, Account, Closure and Evaluate. It’s a less confrontational tactic designed to build rapport with the suspect by allowing them to tell their story without interruption before the interrogation begins. This gently locks in the suspect to a certain narrative and allows detectives to then confront them with inconsistencies.

Jonathan Davison, who trains U.K. investigators, says the main objective of a PEACE interview is to get complete and reliable information about a crime, rather than a confession-based approach.

“The ethos behind PEACE,” Davison said, “is that we’re treating everybody, no matter who they are, the way we’d like to be treated ourselves.”

Real-life policing is mostly not like what we see on television. And suspects are frequently more dangerous and calculating than any Hollywood writer can imagine. But maybe there is something to this PEACE technique – a calmer, more psychological approach of getting to the truth and delivering justice. You know, more the determined, low-key and successful style of Columbo, as opposed to the unethical, civil-rights abusing Dirty Harry.

Home » Opinion » Columnists » Did you know police officers can legally lie to you in most states?


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Personal to me, Jose Armas' death felt across NM
Columnists
One of the blessings about returning ... One of the blessings about returning to New Mexico was that it put me back in touch with Jose Armas. ...
2
Thieves take so much more than your cash
Columnists
Being victimized can cause trauma, and ... Being victimized can cause trauma, and has nothing to do with your 'intelligence or common sense'
3
Tips for keeping you and your energy bills cool ...
Columnists
It is hot outside. According to ... It is hot outside. According to PNM, demand for electricity is highest during the summer cooling sea ...
4
A new community hub for the South Valley
Columnists
Social Enterprise Center brings new approach ... Social Enterprise Center brings new approach to economic development
5
Navajo nurses took different paths to making big differences ...
Columnists
Looking back on long nursing careers, ... Looking back on long nursing careers, Erma Marbut and Lavenia Diswood are most proud of the ways the ...
6
Anniversaries of grief bring lessons, opportunities to help
ABQnews Seeker
You will not 'get over' the ... You will not 'get over' the loss of a loved one; you'll learn to live with it
7
Journal reader engagement focusing on underrepresented communities
Columnists
I moved to Albuquerque from Colorado ... I moved to Albuquerque from Colorado last November, marking the third time in my 53 years that IR ...
8
NM voters should get say on healthy environment
Columnists
What is the Green Amendment and ... What is the Green Amendment and what would it do? Democrats in the New Mexico House and Senate have ...
9
Newspaper memo from the past rings just as true ...
Columnists
Editorial page writer Sharon Hendrix rarely ... Editorial page writer Sharon Hendrix rarely throws anything out. So before retiring last month after ...