Proposed updates to state curriculum ridiculed - Albuquerque Journal

Proposed updates to state curriculum ridiculed

SANTA FE – New Mexico officials have been inundated with critical letters on proposed K-12 social studies standards over the inclusion of racial identity and social justice themes in a state with a Hispanic plurality where Indigenous tribes have persevered through war, famine, internment camps and boarding schools aimed at stamping out their cultures.

If approved, the standards would require students starting in kindergarten to “identify some of their group identities” and “take group or individual action to help address local, regional, and/or global problems.”

By high school, students would examine “factors which resulted in unequal power relations among identity groups.”

Roman Catholic Pastor Vincent Paul Chavez, right, of the Saint Therese school and parish in Albuquerque, protests proposed science standards on behalf of the Santa Fe Archdiocese outside a public hearing in Santa Fe on Oct. 16, 2017.(Morgan Lee/Associated Press)

Critics, including some Hispanics, say the standards promote victimhood, while supporters have praised the standards as “more just and anti-racist.”

The proposed New Mexico standards represent a new frontier in the clash over “critical race theory” – an academic concept increasingly used by conservative activists as a catchall term for the study of systemic racism, historical oppression or progressive social activism.

Political organizing centered on the term has been credited for swaying voters in some states to elect Republican governors, with mixed results in other local elections across the country on Nov. 1.

New Mexico teachers already face a challenge explaining the region’s history and its evolving social structures. The state is a patchwork of 23 federally recognized Native American nations, tribes and pueblos.

Nearly half of the state is Latino, and about 10% of New Mexico’s students are Native American – with many tracing their heritage to pre-Columbian and 16th century Spanish conquistadors.

Tensions over that history erupted last year when a group of mostly white activists destroyed a historical marker memorializing Union soldiers who fought against Confederate soldiers and Indigenous people. The obelisk sat on the reference point for land appropriated by Spanish settlers.

The New Mexico Public Education Department’s proposed standards are aimed at making civics, history and geography more inclusive of the state’s diverse population so that students feel at home in the curriculum and are prepared for a state in which the majority of the population consists of minorities. They add requirements for students to learn more details about Indigenous life, including more of the distinct Native cultures.

Meteorologist David Craft, right foreground, of Albuquerque criticizes proposed state science standards outside a public hearing in Santa Fe on Oct. 16, 2017. The proposed standards for New Mexico public schools came under intense criticism for omitting or deleting references to global warming, evolution and the age of the Earth. (Morgan Lee/Associated Press)

Some studies have found that ethnic studies programs at the high school level can increase school attendance and graduation rates. And a New Mexico lawsuit seeks to pressure the state Public Education Department to embrace teaching that students find relevant to their cultures and languages.

The department also wants to update the history portion of the social studies curriculum, which hasn’t been changed in three decades. Proposed learning sections include the Sept. 11 attacks and the LGBTQ rights movement.

But many educators are concerned about the size and scope of the proposed updates.

They have said that updated school science standards in 2017 were based on an existing curriculum used in other states for years. Teachers and administrators also say they have been swamped with work returning to school amid the pandemic.

“It feels like it’s being rushed, and I don’t know why,” said Kevin Summers, superintendent of the Aztec Municipal School District in northwestern New Mexico. “Can we back off? Can we just get six more months?”

State Republican officials have tried to tap into the national controversy over education. But a Republican effort last spring to recruit school board members on a critical race platform didn’t take off.

State education officials originally planned a Nov. 12 in-person public forum for supporters and opponents to share their opinions about the proposed standards. But the venue was changed to Zoom.

That will deprive Republicans of a physical space to rally around. State GOP Chairman Steve Pearce said a “rash, political decision to kill the public comment period is as dangerous as the proposal itself.”

The education department in response said that all the public comment on proposed rule changes has been virtual since the pandemic began and extended the length of the Zoom session by several hours.

“We are in a pandemic, so crowding in an indoor setting could be dangerous,” education department spokeswoman Judy Robinson said.

The proposed changes represent the biggest curriculum controversy the education department has faced since its effort to update science standards in 2017, during Republican Gov. Susana Martinez’s administration.

A packed public hearing is held in Santa Fe on a proposed overhaul of New Mexico’s state science standards for public schools on Oct. 16, 2017. New Mexico officials are getting a flood of critical letters on proposed social studies standards in K-12 schools over the inclusion of racial identity and social justice themes in a state with a Hispanic plurality where two dozen Indigenous tribes have persevered through war, famine, internment camps and boarding schools meant to stamp out their cultures.

What New Mexico children learn in school is often determined less by legislation and more by the administrative rule-making process by education officials, which includes public comments, responses and possible incorporation of feedback.

It’s one of the strongest powers the agency has, according to the education secretary who spearheaded the 2017 science standards.

Christopher Ruszkowski, education secretary under Martinez, said public education changes don’t usually happen under legislation but are put into place by the education department, and “90% of policymaking is done at the rule level.”

Public comment led to major changes in the science standards the agency proposed, he said, which had watered down scientific facts to placate anti-science constituents after early feedback sessions.

The education department removed the real age of the Earth and human evolution, which contradict some interpretations of the Bible, and struck explicit references to climate change unpopular in southeastern New Mexico’s oil-producing regions.

Ruszkowski said he authorized the changes to a draft proposal, even though he did not support them personally.

That generated a backlash from scientists in letters, newspapers ads and a packed hall for the public comment forum.

In the end, the agency implemented the original science standards in full.

During the process of developing the science standards before they were drafted, sessions were held with members of the public to gather input. But the education department did not do that this time, instead inviting 64 people – mostly teachers and administrators – to draft the standards in private over the summer.

The draft was released on Sept. 28, and the education department wants students to learn using the new curriculum next school year.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Two-vehicle crash in Northeast Albuquerque leaves 1 seriously injured
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Police Department officers were dispatched ... Albuquerque Police Department officers were dispatched to a two-vehicle crash that left one person in critical condition late Saturday, according to a news release. ...
Shooting in Southwest Albuquerque leaves 1 in critical condition
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque police say one person is ... Albuquerque police say one person is in the hospital in critical condition after a shooting near Central and Coors early Sunday morning. Albuquerque Police ...
College athlete deals risk tax-free scholarships
ABQnews Seeker
The college football bowl season is ... The college football bowl season is over.
Emptying the Notebook: Lobo Allen-Tovar steps up at Wyoming
ABQnews Seeker
Some extra notes, stats, quotes and ... Some extra notes, stats, quotes and whatever else I could to empty out of the old notebook after UNM's close loss at Wyoming
Finding redemption in prison
ABQnews Seeker
Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope ... Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope to peers
Investigation into officer's death a 'slap in the face,' ...
ABQnews Seeker
NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted ... NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted suspect during traffic stop on Feb. 4
'Honest' Martínez rises in ranks to House leadership
ABQnews Seeker
Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, ... Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, cannabis and tax rates
New approach to teaching race in school divides NM
ABQnews Seeker
Students would learn about social identity ... Students would learn about social identity under new plan
Lawsuit says Belen firefighter fired for reporting COVID-19 case
ABQnews Seeker
Man believes he was terminated for ... Man believes he was terminated for notifying human resources of sick co-worker