Young offenders need 2nd chance, pathway to parole - Albuquerque Journal

Young offenders need 2nd chance, pathway to parole

Former President George W. Bush famously said, “When I was young and irresponsible, I was young and irresponsible.” Few children grow up to be president, but many kids violate the law. While minor incidents like underage drinking are much more common, a small number of youths commit serious crimes landing them in adult prison. Even in such cases, precisely because kids are so amenable to change, the Land of Enchantment must also be the Land of Second Chances.

One step in that direction would be abolishing life without parole as a sentencing option for New Mexicans who are 18 or younger, a proposal that could be considered if the governor adds it to the agenda for the upcoming legislative session. Under this proposal, youths sentenced for the most serious crimes would also receive a parole hearing after 15 years behind bars.

A commitment to the possibility of redemption unites every religious tradition, as well as nonbelievers, and spans the political spectrum. It is not just liberals but conservatives like Newt Gingrich who have called for ending juvenile life without parole. New Mexico’s veritably conservative neighbor Texas abolished juvenile life without parole back in 2009. More recently, in January 2021, Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine signed bipartisan legislation replacing juvenile life without parole with a second-look review process that begins after 18 years of incarceration.

Why is there so much support for change? First, not even a fortuneteller has a crystal ball that illuminates who a 15-year-old will be by the time they are 30. This “second-look” legislation creates the opportunity for the parole board to determine whether a person who was sentenced as a child has invested in rehabilitation, poses no threat to public safety and is prepared to make positive contributions to society.

Most importantly, the broadly shared and instinctive appeal of second chances is backed by solid reasoning and evidence. Research on adolescent brain development indicates children are more susceptible to peer pressure than adults, are more deeply affected by trauma, are less capable of appreciating the consequences of their conduct and more likely to make decisions based on passion or momentary excitement.

However, because these deficits are developmental, children also have vast potential for rehabilitation and positive transformation. The data bears this out. Although no policy can guarantee that someone released from prison will refrain from crime any more than those who were never incarcerated will offend, a study of juvenile lifers released in Pennsylvania found a mere 1% recidivism rate.

Indeed, the Supreme Court has held that fundamental differences between children and adults must be taken into account when sentencing a child who has caused harm.

This proposal does not guarantee release to anyone. It merely creates an opportunity for parole review. Not every candidate will be able to demonstrate that they have been rehabilitated and deserve a second chance. But a second look provides a powerful incentive for good behavior and for participation in rehabilitative programming, making prisons and the communities people return to safer. Also, some of the savings from unnecessary incarceration can be reallocated to other public safety initiatives.

In a nation roiled by political polarization, evidence-based criminal justice reform remains one of the few true areas of bipartisanship. That is because it appeals to our shared values and delivers results. New Mexico leaders should bring the state in alignment with the growing national consensus that recognizes everyone has the potential to overcome their worst acts as a child.

Marc Levin, Esq., is founding director of the Right on Crime initiative. He can be reached at and on Twitter at @marcalevin.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Young offenders need 2nd chance, pathway to parole

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Ready for Rihanna? A look at five songs that ...
ABQnews Seeker
Journal Staff WriterI am not sure ... Journal Staff WriterI am not sure if you have heard, but there is a football game this ...
New Mexico basketball: Five Alford and Nevada takeaways from ...
New Mexico fell to Nevada in ... New Mexico fell to Nevada in a 77-76 men's basketball heartbreaker on Tuesday night, thanks to last-second heroics from Kenan Blackshear.  With the win, ...
Alford, Nevada break Lobo hearts yet again
ABQnews Seeker
Kenan Blackshear's final-second shot pushed Nevada ... Kenan Blackshear's final-second shot pushed Nevada past the UNM Lobos and continued Steve Alford's dominance over his former team.
From piñon to petrichor: 4 aromas that define Albuquerque ...
ABQnews Seeker
A group of Las Cruces fifth ... A group of Las Cruces fifth graders recently pitched a bill that would name the scent of roasting green chile the official state smell. ...
Editorial: With 3 strikes already, will new PRC work?
From the Editorial Board: Latest sign ... From the Editorial Board: Latest sign of dysfunction is commissioner's recusal from PNM-Avangrid merger, should it resurface.
Editorial: State ordered workers back, but forgot offices
From the Editorial Board: Why the ... From the Editorial Board: Why the urgency to send state workers back to unready offices?
To Lobo basketball fans, Alford remains a provocative figure
After a hearty chorus of boos, ... After a hearty chorus of boos, cheers and whatever comes in between, the crowd finally hushed in anticipation of 'The Star-Spangled Banner.' A voice ...
Boys prep basketball: Holland leads as Los Lunas wins ...
Boys' Basketball
Travis Julian had done the math. ... Travis Julian had done the math. The short-term math, sure, but far more pressing on his mind was a specific long-term calculation. 'I haven't ...
Complaint lodged against energy advocacy group
ABQnews Seeker
The conservative advocacy organization Better Together ... The conservative advocacy organization Better Together New Mexico accused environmental group New Energy Economy of potentially illegal fundraising activity.