Energy transition needs collaboration not disinformation - Albuquerque Journal

Energy transition needs collaboration not disinformation

The dual opinion pieces in the Nov. 23 Journal, one by Steve Pearce, head of the New Mexico Republican Party, and the other by Paul Gessing of the Rio Grande Foundation, are the latest salvo in a campaign to discredit the energy transition.

They argue that Europe is experiencing an energy crisis. The United States and New Mexico will face that same crisis unless they bow down to the oil and gas industry, which Pearce describes as “a golden goose that cannot be slain.”

Europe’s energy crisis has many causes, only one of which is too-rapid shuttering of fossil fuel power plants. Around the world, the pandemic led to lower oil and gas production, and slower deployment of renewable energy facilities. The rapid economic rebound once vaccines were deployed caught the global economy by surprise, and every sector has been trying to catch up. Russia has slowed gas supplies to the European Union and Norway’s gas supply has maintenance issues. Limited supplies in a global market are driving up prices everywhere.

The governor and the president are hardly to blame. The president called for a pause on leases on federal land – not on permits, as Gessing states. But the industry has 23 million acres of unused public lands leases and thousands of unused permits. The administration has issued permits at a faster pace than the Trump administration, and the State Land Office has also been issuing permits at a rapid clip.

The problem lies largely with industry. Oil companies are using the high prices to pay shareholders and investors, not to increase production. One reason: according to a Deloitte study, fracking operations had a net negative free cash flow of $300 billion, impaired investment capital of $450 billion and nearly 200 bankruptcies since 2010. On the gas side, the industry has shifted significant natural gas production to exports. While industry profits now exceed pre-pandemic levels, their actions are a direct cause of domestic supply crunches and higher prices. However, blaming the governor and the president has clear political value heading into the 2022 elections.

Industry disregard for U.S. consumers and business has forced the government to step in. The president’s call for domestic and foreign producers to increase production is a necessary measure. However, we are in a global energy market; it was Russian and Saudi Arabian squabbling that led to the astonishing negative spot price in spring 2020. Combined with the pandemic, this led to the rapid collapse of New Mexico revenues and an industry-wide write-down of over $150 billion, 10% of combined market capitalization. This was hardly the fault of the Biden administration, which took office a year later.

The president is not alone. China, India, Japan, the U.K. and others are all tapping into their strategic reserves to dampen the market, and are providing emergency subsidies and other support to consumers and businesses. The impacts of industry instability and profit-seeking fall to governments – of wildly varying ideologies – to resolve.

Every sector is under increasing pressure from shareholders, insurers and the public to account for climate risk, but the oil and gas sector feels this pressure the most. A recent article described the massive, multitrillion-dollar problem the oil and gas industry has with stranded assets from the rapid transition to clean energy sources as one that will increase catastrophically if the industry does not plan adequately.

We are at the start of a transition the world has never seen before: the intentional, rapid shift from one energy source to another as the economic driver. It will be immensely difficult and it will not be smooth. But it is happening. The global energy transition needs everyone to get together to make it work for everyone.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


John Cena hits the small screen as a boneheaded, ...
We already know from last year's ... We already know from last year's "The Suicide Squad" movie that John Cena's Christopher Smith aka Pe ...
Patel returns to NM United staff
Featured Sports
Ron Patel, who was on the ... Ron Patel, who was on the founding business staff of New Mexico United, has circled back to the club as Chief Business Officer, United ...
Comic strip 'Macanudo' makes its Journal debut today
From the newspaper
Readers of the Journal who are ... Readers of the Journal who are fans of the funnies will find a new comic strip, "Macanudo," starting ...
Aztecs take final game of series
Saturday's storyline started two years ago ... Saturday's storyline started two years ago for the University of New Mexico baseball team. The Lobos couldn't get pitcher Garrett Hill in a recruiting ...
Rudolfo Anaya's impact on the arts was widespread
From the newspaper
Rudolfo Anaya's death means that artists, ... Rudolfo Anaya's death means that artists, intellectuals and ordinary folks will be flooded with memo ...
Indigenous NM woman to lead Smithsonian American Indian museum
ABQnews Seeker
Her ancestry includes Hopi, Tewa and ... Her ancestry includes Hopi, Tewa and Navajo
Cole becomes one of 10 2021 Lobos to hit ...
Three more University of New Mexico ... Three more University of New Mexico football players – running back Bobby Cole ...
Struggling Lobo men have rough road ahead on Front ...
The Lobos could use a breather. ... The Lobos could use a breather. It ain't coming this week. ...
Debate could reignite on small loans
Budget / Taxes
SANTA FE – Attempts ... SANTA FE – Attempts to lower New Mexico's annual interest rate cap on small lo ...