Editorial: Archdiocese bankruptcy shouldn't be kept in secret - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Archdiocese bankruptcy shouldn’t be kept in secret

It’s time for something to give on the legal logjam holding up payouts from the Archdiocese of Santa Fe to nearly 400 sexual abuse survivors.

The Archdiocese filed for bankruptcy protection in 2018 in part so it didn’t have to face exposure from individual state lawsuits alleging clergy sexual abuse.

The claimants are already being denied what many of them seek — publicly exposing the church for its misdeeds. To keep the victims in financial limbo adds insult to injury.

When a diocese files for bankruptcy, lawsuits by alleged abuse survivors are suspended while a bankruptcy judge oversees the process as to how creditors will be paid so as to leave enough for the diocese to operate. These bankruptcy proceedings remain hung up on a question of who will pay the sexual abuse claims and how much. The Archdiocese indicated it would file legal action this week to get a judge to settle undisclosed questions about its relationship with its insurance carriers. The Archdiocese and claimants came to a tentative agreement last year on what the Archdiocese would pay, but insurance companies’ contributions remain an issue. As reported in the Journal last week, there has been no disclosure of what the Archdiocese is willing to contribute or what insurance companies are offering. According to The Associated Press, the Archdiocese and its various insurers have so far paid out $52 million to settle about 300 cases out of court, which averages about $175,000 per victim.

Four years into the bankruptcy filing, attorneys for the claimants are preparing to ask U.S. Bankruptcy Judge David Thuma to let state lawsuits/claims that had been put on hold to go forward. The move should prompt the Archdiocese and its insurance carriers to reach an agreement — they’ll likely face greater liability if Thuma lifts the suspension. Lawsuits would also air Archdiocese dirty laundry, detailing how it’s dealt with sexual abuse claims.

On top of everything else, Thuma will decide whether to keep the Archdiocese’s negotiations with the insurance companies under seal. Prior court filings, orders and hearings have been sealed at the Archdiocese’s request. It is heartening Thuma said last week that, “My prejudice is to not seal things, especially in a case like this where there’s public interest and the public has a right to know.”

The church has a history of private settlements and confidentiality agreements to conceal abuse by priests. If lawsuits aren’t permitted to proceed through public channels, then the public’s right to know the details of how these payouts are structured is only amplified.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Archdiocese bankruptcy shouldn’t be kept in secret


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: Pretrial release decisions must hinge on good police ...
Editorials
During election season in New Mexico, ... During election season in New Mexico, promises to crack down on crime are ubiquitous — on both ...
2
Editorial: Journal concludes primary endorsements for NM House
Editorials
Today, the Journal continues endorsements for ... Today, the Journal continues endorsements for contested primary legislative races in the metro area. ...
3
Editorial: Journal begins ’22 endorsements with NM House of ...
Editorials
For ongoing coverage that will include ... For ongoing coverage that will include candidate profiles, Q&As and endorsements as they are published, go to www.abqjournal.com/2498103/2022-primary-election.html.
4
Editorial: Recent cases prove NM must do better job ...
Editorials
New Mexico can be a very ... New Mexico can be a very dangerous place to be a child.    We had the sixth-highest r ...
5
Editorial: 'Living lots' may be worth considering, but details ...
Editorials
We started with unsanctioned, unsanitary and ... We started with unsanctioned, unsanitary and unsafe camping across the metro area.     ...
6
Editorial: Free parking could pay off in Old Town
Editorials
Why does the city charge for ... Why does the city charge for parking in Old Town?    "Because it can" isn ...
7
Editorial: When it comes to raises, NM educators not ...
Editorials
Was it a legislative oversight, a ... Was it a legislative oversight, a slight or is there a reasonable rationale? No matter how you cut i ...
8
Editorial: Requiring party affiliation to vote is anti-democratic
Editorials
It seems like they're hoping we'll ... It seems like they're hoping we'll forget, like forgetting to disenroll after a free tri ...
9
Editorial: State must keep the heat on shoplifters
Editorials
Two recent incidents illustrate the disturbing ... Two recent incidents illustrate the disturbing lengths shoplifters will go to to secure a haul of st ...