Facing deadline pressure, NM court weighs redistricting clash - Albuquerque Journal

Facing deadline pressure, NM court weighs redistricting clash

Copyright © 2022 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – Attorneys for the state Republican Party asked a judge Monday to bar New Mexico from conducting this year’s congressional elections under the new map adopted in last year’s special session, describing it as an illegal partisan gerrymander.

Lawyers for the Legislature and Democratic Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham, by contrast, urged the judge to dismiss the lawsuit altogether, contending the map complies with every requirement in the state Constitution.

The clash played out before Clovis-based District Judge Fred Van Soelen, who said he will issue a ruling by 4 p.m. Tuesday.

The timing is critical. The first ballots for the primary election must go in the mail to military and overseas voters by Saturday.

Dylan Lange, an attorney for Democratic Secretary of State Maggie Toulouse Oliver, said it’s already too late – that changing the map now would cause “mass chaos.”

“Five days before an election is just too much for us to handle,” Lange told the judge. “It’s not feasible.”

Van Soelen didn’t say how he intends to rule, but he asked a number of questions centering on the potential disruption of overturning the map approved by the Legislature.

Chris Murray, an attorney for the state GOP and other plaintiffs, said federal law allows for an exemption to the deadline for military and overseas ballots when there’s a legal dispute.

Furthermore, he said, allowing the election to go forward under the new map would violate the constitutional rights of the plaintiffs by diluting the voting strength of Republicans in southeastern New Mexico. He cited a provision in the Constitution guaranteeing people “equal protection” of the law.

Murray cited comments by Democratic legislative leaders that he said showed their goal was to damage the reelection chances of U.S. Rep. Yvette Herrell of Alamogordo – the only Republican in the state delegation – and analysis by the Princeton Gerrymandering Project, the nonpartisan Cook Political Report and others.

“It’s a clear partisan gerrymander,” Murray said.

Attorneys for Democratic legislative leaders and the governor said the state Constitution assigns the task of redistricting to political officeholders in the legislative and executive branches of government. There’s no clear standard, the defendants said, for what would constitute an illegal partisan gerrymander.

“The process worked just like the Constitution envisions,” Richard Olson, an attorney for legislative leaders, said of the new map. “There’s no reason for judicial involvement.”

Lujan Grisham attorney Holly Agajanian said the Constitution doesn’t require lawmakers to adopt maps “with the blessing” of the minority party.

Lawmakers in December adopted the new congressional map, substantially reshaping all three districts. The map, for example, splits Albuquerque into two districts with ripple effects that make Herrell’s seat more friendly to Democrats.

Home » 2022 election » Facing deadline pressure, NM court weighs redistricting clash


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Pearce wins reelection as NM GOP chairman through 2024
2022 election
Fends off 4 challengers with 55% ... Fends off 4 challengers with 55% of votes cast
2
NM election results certified by board
2022 election
Supreme Court sets oral arguments on ... Supreme Court sets oral arguments on redistricting challenge for Jan. 9
3
Bernalillo County certifies midterm election results
2022 election
All counties have now sent totals ... All counties have now sent totals for Nov. 29 canvass
4
NM voters had their say. Now the education amendment ...
2022 election
Measure to boost annual withdrawals backed ... Measure to boost annual withdrawals backed by 70% of voters statewide
5
NM ethics agency sues advocacy group
2022 election
Lawsuit accuses group of violating state ... Lawsuit accuses group of violating state campaign law
6
New Mexico begins certification process for midterm elections
2022 election
Process has become a focal point ... Process has become a focal point for those voicing distrust in voting systems
7
NM GOP officials face intraparty strife after latest election ...
2022 election
Some Republicans have called on state ... Some Republicans have called on state chairman Steve Pearce to resign
8
Martínez nominated to serve as House speaker
2022 election
Democrats also name majority floor leader, ... Democrats also name majority floor leader, whip and caucus chair
9
Redrawn CD2 riles Republicans after defeat
2022 election
Rep. Herrell said Dems engineered her ... Rep. Herrell said Dems engineered her ouster