Welcome to social justice in a 'man's world' - Albuquerque Journal

Welcome to social justice in a ‘man’s world’

It astounds me that the Supreme Court can’t see that the U.S. Constitution prohibits bans on abortion. To say nothing of the systemic patriarchal interests in this government that still consider women’s bodies to be a legal form of property. Either men’s personal property, as women were literally from the beginning, or still a form of “government” property, that enables any branch of it to declare women’s bodies do not belong to them and mandate they pay for being victimized by men. That’s social justice in a “man’s world,” right?

Sure, I know the Equal Rights Amendment giving women have equal rights with men under the Constitution hasn’t passed. The Supreme Court, however, should at least uphold its own precedents regarding women’s U.S. citizenship. But, apparently it’s not going to.

Here’s the rub.

When the 14th Amendment was ratified in 1868, it extended civil rights to all citizens, but it defined “citizens” as “male.” In fact, Section 2 of the Amendment was actually written as a penalty clause for states that still supported seditious slavery, as Section 3, which refers to the strengthened loyalty oath of Congress makes very clear.

However, even though this section of the amendment only included the word “male” in reference to national elections, the Supreme Court chose to uphold a prior Illinois Supreme Court case, in 1872, declaring “barring women from the bar” in that state didn’t violate the Constitution. In fact, in the opinion of one justice, “The paramount destiny and mission of women are to fulfill the noble and benign offices of wife and mother.”

Even though the Supreme Court overturned the Bradwell decision, ruling in 1976 that the 14th Amendment applied to both men and women, the Supreme Court has never ruled that women were “equal citizens” with men, under the law. So, accommodations here and there have been made, but when the U.S. turns 250 years old in 2026, will the Supreme Court be remembered for upholding the 50-year-old landmark decision that ruled discrimination against women was illegal in 1976, or is it going to reach back into its early “post-Civil War” decisions and rule that women’s bodies are still technically property of men’s patriarchal government and not their own?

Not that I am in favor of abortion, but to begin with, I don’t believe that any man’s government has the right to tell women what to do with their bodies. Nor do I think that the U.S. Constitution entitles the court to rule in favor of the rights of any unborn child, without recognizing the rights of its mother first, which it has yet to do.

Nor do I think any “citizen” of the United States, man or woman, is entitled to claim their religious rights should, and can, be enforced on every other citizen of the nation – especially when they’re not paying the bill or providing any reparation for the damages it causes when, in fact, the pregnancy and raising of any child for 20 years entails very high costs. What kind of justice does that position support? It sounds like the ultimate unfunded mandate to me.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Welcome to social justice in a ‘man’s world’


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
The Small Glories coming to NM for concerts, workshops
Entertainment
The Canadian duo will play in ... The Canadian duo will play in Albuquerque and Santa Fe.
2
What's happening in ABQ May 20-26: Blue corn pancakes, ...
Entertainment
Raindrop Albuquerque is hosting a fundraising ... Raindrop Albuquerque is hosting a fundraising event to assist the wildfire relief efforts through a brunch. What's happening in ABQ May 20-26
3
Editorial: Journal backs Garcia Holmes and Vasquez in CD1 ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements for contested primary races for the U.S. House of Repr ...
4
NM still suffering fallout of guv's COVID-19 response
From the newspaper
Lujan Grisham's heavy-handed approach should negate ... Lujan Grisham's heavy-handed approach should negate second term
5
Biden vows full support for NM fire recovery
ABQnews Seeker
Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire surpasses 300,000 ... Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire surpasses 300,000 acres
6
11-year-old joins fight to help the homeless
ABQnews Seeker
'I didn't know kids at my ... 'I didn't know kids at my school could be homeless,' Russell explains
7
BernCo Commission race attracts three Republicans
2022 election
Each is running for the first ... Each is running for the first time due to concern for their community
8
'Ice Age Footprints' features the monumental discovery at White ...
Entertainment
'Ice Age Footprints' will premiere at ... 'Ice Age Footprints' will premiere at 8 p.m. Wednesday, May 25, on New Mexico PBS and stream on the PBS Video app
9
Prep notes: Longtime Cibola softball coach Victor to retire
Featured Sports
After 37 seasons, and three state ... After 37 seasons, and three state championships, and having built Cibola High School into one of the ...