We shamefully abandoned science for political gain - Albuquerque Journal

We shamefully abandoned science for political gain

The coronavirus pandemic is an event unlike any in living memory. A new pathogen swept the globe, causing widespread death and disability. Scientists were unsure where it came from, how it spread, or what measures the public should be taking to protect themselves. Historically trusted institutions like the World Health Organization, U.S. Centers for Disease Control, and state departments of health published guidance, some of which carried significant impacts on the public’s daily life.

Then, instead of coming together to leverage the best of the American people, as witnessed after 9/11 or Hurricane Katrina, we embraced our parochial partisan positions. What should have been a matter of public health became the venue for political sparring and one-upmanship.

The result? A reckless disregard for the public’s health. Regarding vaccines, masks and lockdowns, opponents asked “Why do you want to destroy small businesses and drive entrepreneurs to poverty?”

Both Republicans and Democrats readily leapt to the contemporary pastime of identity politics. Rather than the pandemic unifying us in spirit and effort to preserve public’s well-being and halt the spread of a common scourge, we ignored the big picture and continued to bicker.

Vaccines, masks, isolation and physical separation ceased to be the tools of public health practitioners and became either totems of salvation or icons of oppression and injustice.

Along the way there were tragic casualties. One million Americans have died from COVID-19, and hundreds of thousands face continued economic hardships. The institutions responsible for medical and epidemiological research and policy, whose sole reason for being is the protection of the public’s health, were drawn into the mud-slinging.

Rather than being allowed to conduct their business impartially, with the single-minded goal of defeating disease, the Centers for Disease Control, the Food and Drug Administration and the National Institutes for Health were misused. Politicians on all sides cherry-picked and mischaracterized the agencies’ products and recommendations. Scientific efforts were conflated with political personalities, and idea originators came to be politically tainted by the association. Scientists were perceived as being guided by political affiliations and consequentially lost the public’s confidence.

The scientific method, that iterative process of observation, hypothesis, prediction, experimentation, analysis, and drawing data-based conclusions, ceased to be recognized as a proven path to knowledge accumulation. Adapting to new knowedge was seen as proof that science is consistently wrong and best taken with a large grain of salt. Tragically, Americans came to distrust medical science in general.

Americans should be shamefaced and mourning how readily we abandoned science to support our parties.

Home » From the newspaper » We shamefully abandoned science for political gain


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Can state parks be climate resilient?
From the newspaper
One of the hats I wear ... One of the hats I wear is State Parks Advisory Board (PAB) member and the chair of PAB's clima ...
2
Legislators should focus on real solutions to confront crime
From the newspaper
NM can't keep throwing time, money ... NM can't keep throwing time, money on jailing as many as possible
3
Sandia Labs offers free online cybersecurity boot camp
From the newspaper
Businesses, groups can get help to ... Businesses, groups can get help to beef up their online protections
4
NM department heads, others didn't disclose financial info
ABQnews Seeker
Elected officials, the leaders of state ... Elected officials, the leaders of state agencies and certain other appointees are required to file annual disclosures
5
Biden urges Western unity on Ukraine
From the newspaper
British PM Johnson warns against allowing ... British PM Johnson warns against allowing war 'fatigue' to take hold
6
New Mexico paid sick leave law set to take ...
ABQnews Seeker
The Healthy Workplaces Act applies to ... The Healthy Workplaces Act applies to all private businesses
7
How does New Mexico's paid sick leave law work?
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A about the new law Q&A about the new law
8
APD: 2 shot to death in west Albuquerque
ABQnews Seeker
Officials says victims 'appear to be ... Officials says victims 'appear to be related'
9
Albuquerque local to compete on 'American Ninja Warrior'
ABQnews Seeker
Katie Bone, 16, also has chance ... Katie Bone, 16, also has chance to raise awareness for Type 1 diabetes on show