Yazzie/Martinez action plan has zero accountability - Albuquerque Journal

Yazzie/Martinez action plan has zero accountability

Having done some target practice, I found it’s best to ensure one can see the correct target first, then take aim.

The “new” “Action Plan” for addressing the Yazzi/Martinez v. State of New Mexico judgement is not at the same range, much less a useful target for improving education.

Focused, allegedly, on “at risk” students, the authors don’t understand most students in public education in New Mexico are at risk, not select groups because of race.

It is difficult to hit the target when those aiming can’t see the target for the trees, pardon the mixed metaphor. As many who are not N.M. educators know, New Mexico falls at the bottom of so many lists because it first fails at providing an excellent education for its public students. By all appearances, many schools and their teachers don’t even strive for mediocrity. Listening to the noise coming from union leaders and politicians subservient to them, they strive for more pay and benefits – results be damned.

Accounting for cost of living, N.M. “educators” are paid near the median of their cohorts across the United States. How many of those NM “educators,” much less their students, even know what median means? They have proven over and over again that more funding does not increase results.

To further obfuscate the problem – or hide the target – the state cannot or will not stand firm on standardized testing. Its new “Action Plan” admits there is no way to compare students’ achievement because “baselines are unavailable.” That lack of availability is obviously intentional. Nobody is held responsible when standards aren’t met because there are no standards.

The recent Journal article “NM sees delay in student assessment data” is another example of how the educational system refuses to be open about schools’ and teachers’ performance. I would not be surprised if Cognia Inc.’s poor performance provides an excuse to find yet another vendor. That will move useful assessment data further out in time, continuing the obfuscation and adding to the excuses. The little data available indicates miserably low performance for NM education.

E.F. Deming, founder of the Total Quality Management concept, pointed out “If it’s worth doing, it’s worth measuring.” The lack of effective measurement in N.M.’s public educational system demonstrates its lack of excellence, making me wonder if those in the system believe education is worth doing.

The crux of the issue is avoiding responsibility at all levels: school boards, superintendents, administrators down to and including teachers. Too few are willing to accept responsibility for poor performance. Parents, taxpayers and even politicians must demand accountability for responsibility not taken. Without accountability, responsibility is meaningless. The new “plan” won’t help.

After retiring from the U.S. Air Force, Bill Mader was a college instructor in Clovis and Traverse City, Michigan, in the field of vocational education.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Yazzie/Martinez action plan has zero accountability


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
‘Bodies Bodies Bodies’ delivers razor-sharp satire
Entertainment
"Bodies Bodies Bodies " might just ... "Bodies Bodies Bodies " might just be the first great Gen Z thriller. In director Halina Reijn's fil ...
2
Cody Canada and The Departed coming to Red River ...
Entertainment
Cody Canada and The Departed are ... Cody Canada and The Departed are taking part in the 8750' BBQ and Music Festival in Red River.
3
In an effort to raise awareness of Native language ...
Entertainment
'A Fistful of Dollars' will be ... 'A Fistful of Dollars' will be a special premiere screening at 7 p.m. Aug. 16, at the KiMo Theatre, 423 Central NW.
4
With a wildly-diverse menu, Luminaria is a shining star
Dining Reviews
Luminaria Restaurant features classic Italian staples ... Luminaria Restaurant features classic Italian staples made special with a New Mexico twist.
5
Happy Accidents named Best New U.S. Cocktail Bar
Blogs
The 2022 Spirited Awards are presented ... The 2022 Spirited Awards are presented by the Tales of the Cocktail Foundation.
6
Florist coming to Meow Wolf for first NM performance
Entertainment
It takes time to create a ... It takes time to create a body of work in music.For the members of Florist, they weren ...
7
Artist finds inspiration in fantasy, mythology and steampunk
Entertainment
George Hayes III is currently showing ... George Hayes III is currently showing at The Gallery ABQ and East Mountain Public Library
8
Phantoms to make tour stop at Salt Yard West
Entertainment
Phantoms will make a stop in ... Phantoms will make a stop in Albuquerque at Salt Yard West on Friday, Aug. 12.
9
Santa Fe-based Theater Grottesco explores the world through 'Survey'
Entertainment
Theater Grottesco will perform 'Survey' at ... Theater Grottesco will perform 'Survey' at the Outpost Performance Space, 210 Yale Blvd. SE at 7:30 p.m. Saturday, Aug. 13.