In fire's wake, NM examines its prescribed forest burns - Albuquerque Journal

In fire’s wake, NM examines its prescribed forest burns

A Santa Fe National Forest Service crew lights a pile burn in the Coyote Ranger District in January. Federal agencies and forest experts are examining how to make prescribed burns safer and more effective following the Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak disaster. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

Copyright © 2022 Albuquerque Journal

Prescribed burns are a forest management practice that dates back centuries.

But what role do controlled burns have in New Mexico if agencies and communities are to avoid another disaster like the Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire?

State and federal experts point to the need for more trained burn professionals and planning tools that account for a changing climate.

A U.S. Forest Service review of the burn that became the largest fire in New Mexico history notes that federal firefighting efforts often have a high “utilization of science and technology.”

But prescribed fire is “more or less a collateral effort.”

The Forest Service has paused all burns on forest lands while the agency reviews its policies.

Despite the pause, Forest Service Chief Randy Moore said that prescribed fire must remain a tool in the agency’s toolbox to combat destructive wildfires.

“Unfortunately, the effects of climate change are narrowing the windows where this tool can be used safely,” Moore said.

The federal review and state experts outline at least three suggestions for making prescribed burns a safer and more effective tool:

• Build a robust multi-agency burn workforce

• Use better planning and modeling tools

• Adapt projects for a changing climate

The ‘all hands, all lands’ approach

Thousands of federal firefighters battle blazes across the nation each year.

But the federal review recommends that the Forest Service build up a separate workforce whose “sole responsibility will be to plan and conduct prescribed fire.”

An “all hands, all lands approach” recognizes that no one agency can manage the forest alone, said Forest Stewards Guild deputy director Eytan Krasilovsky.

“It really is a community of practitioners,” he said. “I think the events of this year just really solidify that we need to be communicating and working together.”

The guild’s youth corps program trains 18- to 25-year-olds in wildland fire and forestry.

Each fall, the corps embeds with crews on the Cibola and Santa Fe National Forests and the Jemez Pueblo.

Members learn how to thin forests and restore watersheds.

They also assist with prescribed fire projects.

“As entry-level wildland firefighters there’s a lot to learn and a lot of experience to gain, and we try to do that in a slow, deliberate way to a high standard and also with a good foundation in ecology and forestry,” Krasilovsky said.

Members of the Santa Fe National Forest Service light a pile burn in January to help thin the forest. Pile burns are typically done with snow on the ground to prevent spread. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

Crews need modern fire tools

The federal review said prescribed fire training and education are often outdated and “do not incorporate the latest tools or the latest fire science.”

That gap can lead to subpar burn plans.

A plan for the Hermits Peak burn used models that underestimated the region’s dryness.

The plan also didn’t adequately consider how a fire would move through the forest if the burn escaped the project boundaries.

Most burn planning and modeling technology was developed under a wetter, cooler climate, said University of New Mexico biology professor and forest ecologist Matthew Hurteau.

“We’ve reached a point in the climate system, particularly in the Southwest, where vegetation is becoming much more reactive,” Hurteau said. “We have higher temperatures and less moisture, which makes fuels more flammable.”

Shifting burn windows

New Mexico crews will also likely need to reconsider when to burn.

Those project windows may shift from year to year.

Fall is now the most common time for prescribed burns in the state and the rest of the Southwest, with some spring projects if weather is favorable. “The fact is, with changing climatic conditions, we may need to look at moving around those windows, and the opportunity to do some burning in the winter months,” Hurteau said.

New Mexico in recent years has removed some legal barriers for burns.

The Prescribed Burning Act of 2021 protects private landowners from severe liability if their well-planned fire goes wrong. The law also created a training course through New Mexico State University for landowners and contractors.

At under $200 per acre, prescribed fire is the cheapest method for thinning overgrown forests, according to the State Forestry Division.

Tree cutting ranges from $500 to $2,000 per acre.

Still, the risks and extensive planning may dissuade groups from burning.

“Like we saw this year, you can have very big consequences when you put fire on the ground as a management tool,” Krasilovsky said. “We don’t take that lightly.”

Since the burns went bad this spring, state officials have warned of the risks of starting fires during New Mexico’s windy season.

State forester Laura McCarthy said that “there probably won’t be any more prescribed burning in the spring.”

Federal burn policies “do not match up with what we know about the climate crisis,” said Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham.

The governor said she thinks New Mexico still needs burns to manage forests and watersheds.

“But you better know where you are, you better know those fuel loads,” Lujan Grisham said. “You better … have access to water, you better have fire crews, and better consult states and local bodies of government.”

The Calf Canyon Fire also began as a Forest Service burn.

A January pile burn of thinned trees and brush caused that blaze. Embers smoldered for months – despite at least three snowstorms – and then resurfaced in April and merged with Hermits Peak.

The Calf Canyon Fire, Krasilovsky said, points to a need for “robust patrolling after a burn.”

“That way they can really monitor those things longer than we maybe thought we needed to, so we can account for the epic dryness we’re experiencing that allowed an event like that,” he said.

A nationwide burn pause

The Forest Service’s nationwide pause on controlled burns has prompted a wide spectrum of reactions.

Hurteau said the blanket action “is a terrible idea” for a country with diverse landscapes.

The forest ecologist recently did field research in California’s Sierra Nevada range.

Forest land burns were on hold. But the National Park Service proceeded with a large burn at Sequoia National Park.

“I think the Forest Service missed opportunities in other places that weren’t having these drought conditions,” Hurteau said.

Despite the backlash from Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak, federal agencies are still counting on controlled burns as a way to prevent more destructive wildfires.

The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act directs $3 billion to reducing wildfire risk.

Meeting that goal means the Forest Service will likely need to burn as much as 4 million acres every year.

The federal report notes that the agency’s commitment to prescribed burns needs to match the resources devoted to fighting fires. Experts are awaiting any conclusions that may follow the 90-day pause and policy review.

The reckoning may be an opportunity to craft prescribed fire policies that consider long-term drought and community involvement.

“This is a terrible tragedy, and we really need to focus on making people whole,” Krasilovsky said. “The steps forward I don’t think are entirely clear to all of us yet. But when we do move ahead with burns, it needs to be after we’ve done some deep work listening, thinking and communicating.”

Home » ABQnews Seeker » In fire’s wake, NM examines its prescribed forest burns

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Grammer: When it comes to fans, the obnoxious few ...
ABQnews Seeker
Utah State guard Max Shulga showed ... Utah State guard Max Shulga showed class in his response to unacceptable taunts from a few Colorado State students.
Man critically injured in Santa Fe shooting
ABQnews Seeker
A man was critically injured after ... A man was critically injured after being shot in a Santa Fe apartment complex on Saturday night.
Three teenagers found dead in garage in Edgewood
ABQnews Seeker
Police said in a news release ... Police said in a news release there is no indication of foul play and it appears to have been carbon monoxide poisoning.
Man, woman killed in Hobbs hit-and-run crash
ABQnews Seeker
A man and a woman were ... A man and a woman were killed in Hobbs on Friday night after being struck by a vehicle while walking their dog, according to ...
Child, 10, allegedly sexually assaulted by foster teen at ...
ABQnews Seeker
The offices of the state child ... The offices of the state child welfare agency are used to house foster children despite New Mexico’s promise to provide them with appropriate homes.
Civilians fill in for sworn officers at Albuquerque Police ...
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Police Chief Harold Medina said ... Albuquerque Police Chief Harold Medina said he sees hiring civilians as "the forefront of the wave of the future." He added: "The civilians are ...
How close did Albuquerque come to a record-high temperature?
ABQnews Seeker
Temperatures in the Duke City reached ... Temperatures in the Duke City reached 63 degrees, said Jennifer Shoemake, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service in Albuquerque. That was the warmest ...
Study says New Mexico turning blind eye to several ...
ABQnews Seeker
A UNM study argues that the ... A UNM study argues that the state government, in its efforts to meet climate goals, stops short of requiring cuts to greenhouse gas emissions ...
5 things going on in Albuquerque this week
ABQnews Seeker
From hoops to a mid-week show, ... From hoops to a mid-week show, here’s what’s happening in the Albuquerque next week.