APS board tables controversial parent rights proposal - Albuquerque Journal

APS board tables controversial parent rights proposal

Community members hold up brightly-colored posters voicing their opposition to a controversial proposed policy at an Albuquerque Public Schools board meeting on Thursday, July 7, 2022. Quiet applause and grumblings occasionally rumbled through the audience as board members discussed the proposal. (Esteban Candelaria/Albuquerque Journal)

Where do parent rights end, and their students’ rights begin?

Albuquerque Public Schools board members took up that issue at a contentious Thursday evening policy meeting, as they discussed a new proposed policy that would lay out the rights parents have when it comes to their kids’ education.

One of the issues opponents took up was whether parents should have the right to access all of their students’ educational records with the district, including things they tell school counselors and others in confidence. The proposal would be particularly devastating to some LGBTQ+ students, according to many of its opponents.

In the end, the board voted 6-1 to table the proposal, noting they’d received a flood of related public outcry over the measure and saying they need more time. Only board member Courtney Jackson voted against tabling the proposal, but had earlier recommended striking some of the controversial language.

“We came out of this one a little too quick,” Board President Yolanda Montoya-Cordova said. “We didn’t do our homework.”

The proposed policy was introduced June 6, one board member noted. APS Policy Analyst and Legislative Liaison Heather Bassett said the policy was intended to go into this year’s student handbook, but said that may be a conversation for next year. In that case, she recommended the policy be ready for a vote sometime in November or December.

A lack of a public comment section — committee meetings don’t have them — didn’t stop upward of 30 community members from cramming into the boardroom to express their concerns over the policy. In lieu of public comments, people quietly held up brightly-colored posters with messages such as “we stand with LGBTQ+ students.”

The proposed policy’s language states that parents “have the right … to have access to all educational records of a school district concerning their child” including “educational and/or social support plans, school counseling records, and school health records.”

The proposal also states that parents have the right to “be included in any educational and/or social support plans.”

Community members sounded the alarm over the proposal ahead of Thursday’s meeting.

Groups like GLSEN Albuquerque, a local chapter of a teacher-founded national LGBTQ+ advocacy network, said that while parents have a right to know what’s going on with their children, students also have a right to privacy.

“It would be outing students,” GLSEN Albuquerque Co-Chair and Policy Coordinator Damon Carbajal said of the proposal. “If they didn’t tell their parents or guardians for some reason or the other, it’s probably not in their best interest or their safety.”

Records that were under threat, he said, included gender support plans, which were being lumped in with social support plans, Carbajal said.

Those plans come in two forms, Carbajal said — official and unofficial. The latter is more of a concern with respect to the proposal, because he said unofficial plans allow students who may be transgender, non-binary, or another identity to use their pronouns and their names in school.

Parents and guardians don’t necessarily have access to the unofficial plans, he said.

“Even though they’re youth and students, they should have some anonymity in certain things to ensure that they’re being safe,” Carbajal said.

The policy’s language also sparked concern from the school employees entrusted with helping students with their private affairs.

“APS counselors said that they were very concerned that this puts kids at risk, because kids really trust counselors,” ATF President Ellen Bernstein said.

Though the proposal was ultimately tabled, that doesn’t mean its opponents’ work is done.

“I think there’s still going to be a fight,” Carbajal said.

Home » ABQnews Seeker » APS board tables controversial parent rights proposal
Los Ranchos approves short-term freeze on developments
ABQnews Seeker
Move will not affect projects that ... Move will not affect projects that stirred residents to protest in recent weeks
New rotisserie restaurant setting up shop on the West ...
ABQnews Seeker
At Fuego 505, Chef Raul Maestas ... At Fuego 505, Chef Raul Maestas is bringing the fire. Literally. The new restaurant, which is openin ...
Third New Mexico film partner to be based in ...
ABQnews Seeker
California-based 828 Productions will relocate its ... California-based 828 Productions will relocate its headquarters to Las Cruces.
Water release temporarily closes Santa Rosa Lake boat ramp
ABQnews Seeker
The boat ramp at Santa Rosa ... The boat ramp at Santa Rosa Lake State Park will be closed temporarily due to a significant water release by the U.S. Army Corps ...
Pedestrian in critical condition after crash
ABQnews Seeker
A pedestrian was transported to University ... A pedestrian was transported to University of New Mexico Hospital with severe head trauma after he was struck by a vehicle Tuesday, Albuquerque police ...
NM revenue explosion continues, as lawmakers weigh next steps
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's revenue jackpot shows no ... New Mexico's revenue jackpot shows no signs of slowing down, with inflation-related consumer spending, strong wage growth and increased oil production propelling the state's ...
Medical investigator rules Baldwin set shooting an accident
ABQnews Seeker
Report notes 'absence of obvious intent ... Report notes 'absence of obvious intent to cause harm or death'
Bernalillo County Commission approves Santolina requests
ABQnews Seeker
Second-level plan calls for certain industrial ... Second-level plan calls for certain industrial uses on 630-acre portion of site west of ABQ
Two brothers charged in deadly smuggling crash
ABQnews Seeker
Border Patrol says it disrupted 20 ... Border Patrol says it disrupted 20 similar schemes before the wreck