Judge: GPS archives are not exempt from public record - Albuquerque Journal

Judge: GPS archives are not exempt from public record

Copyright © 2022 Albuquerque Journal

A state district judge ruled Monday that court administrators in Bernalillo County violated the state Inspection of Public Records Act when they withheld GPS data from prosecutors on two defendants arrested for new crimes while wearing court-ordered ankle monitors.

The ruling by state District Judge James A. Noel marked a victory for District Attorney Raúl Torrez, who sued the 2nd Judicial District Court’s records custodian last December contending the ankle monitoring data was a public record and a matter of public safety.

Torrez had no immediate comment Monday evening, but a press conference on the ruling is planned in the coming days.

“The ruling is good news for public safety,” said Albuquerque police spokesman Gilbert Gallegos, “because it gives law enforcement more tools to hold suspects accountable. We hope we can continue to improve communication with the judiciary so we don’t have to fight for information that will help us keep the community safe.”

Efforts to reach court administrators and their attorney weren’t successful.

The state Public Defender’s Office, which opposed release of the data, was still analyzing the ruling late Monday. “We are concerned about the implication for our clients’ privacy,” said agency general counsel Adrianne Turner.

The lawsuit maintained the data is a “matter of public safety for law enforcement and the public to know whether criminal defendants permitted to stay out of jail pending trial on certain conditions of release have committed new crimes.”

But the court administration last year denied Torrez’s office’s request under IPRA for GPS data on defendants Devin Munford and Jesse Mascareno-Haidle, stating the records were confidential based on the rights of defendants to a fair trial and the presumption of innocence, among other reasons.

Munford at the time was accused of killing a man while wearing an ankle monitor. He was on pretrial release for shooting a pistol from a car.

Mascareno-Haidle was an alleged serial burglar on pretrial release; the DA’s Office sought the GPS records to investigate whether he was linked to other crimes.

Noel found that the court’s GPS records are maintained in the ordinary course of business and such information relating to the location of private citizens isn’t “an exemption or exclusion” from what is considered a public record under state law.

Moreover, Noel rejected the argument made by defense attorneys and others that criminal defendants on pretrial supervision have a “reasonable expectation of privacy” in their GPS data.

“Individuals on pretrial release, conditioned upon wearing GPS (which could include curfew and exclusion zones), are unambiguously aware that they are being continuously monitored ’24/7′ for the specific purpose of ensuring they do not violate their conditions of release,” stated the ruling.

“In this context, such an individual does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy as to their location,” said Noel, a district judge in Sandoval County who was appointed to hear the case by the state Supreme Court.

Torrez maintained the GPS data also doesn’t constitute the type of confidential communication from a judge or between judges and their staff that is protected, which was another argument the custodian gave for withholding the records. Noel sided with Torrez’s argument.

Noel, who was previously the court clerk and court executive officer in the 2nd Judicial District before his judicial appointment, ordered that the GPS records requested by Torrez’s office last year be made available for inspection within 15 days.

After his release, Mascareno Haidle was arrested on new charges of burglarizing a car and is awaiting trial. Munford is also jailed on a no-bond hold; he is awaiting trial for charges in the homicide case.

Home » ABQnews Seeker » Judge: GPS archives are not exempt from public record


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
BCSO detains suspect in stabbing, fire in bosque south ...
ABQnews Seeker
Deputies have arrested a man accused ... Deputies have arrested a man accused of stabbing a person and starting a fire Friday morning in the bosque in Southwest Albuquerque. Bernalillo County ...
2
APD: Two dead in apparent murder-suicide in San Jose ...
ABQnews Seeker
A man and a woman were ... A man and a woman were found fatally shot Friday morning at a San Jose-area home in what police are calling a murder-suicide. Lt. ...
3
‘Just go for it’: New food truck dishing up ...
ABQnews Seeker
“Dude. You have to sell these.” ... “Dude. You have to sell these.” That’s what Laura Gonzalez’s friend and coworker at First Nations Community HealthSource always told her after eating her ...
4
Innovate ABQ still rebounding from pandemic
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque's innovation district is still navigating ... Albuquerque's innovation district is still navigating through the aftermath of the global pand ...
5
Tech-transfer slowly rebounding at Rainforest Innovations
ABQnews Seeker
Rainforest Innovations' fiscal year 2022 technology-transfer ... Rainforest Innovations' fiscal year 2022 technology-transfer achievements clearly reflect today's post-pandemic trends, with entrepreneurial interest by UNM faculty and investor pursuit of university inventions ...
6
Flooding possible across southern NM this weekend
ABQnews Seeker
The National Weather Service is warning ... The National Weather Service is warning that heavy monsoon rains across southern New Mexico could lead to widespread flooding this weekend. Scott Overpeck, a ...
7
Former congresswoman Gabby Giffords to campaign for Lujan Grisham
ABQnews Seeker
Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's reelection campaign ... Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's reelection campaign will get a boost this weekend from former Congresswoman Gabby Giffords. Giffords, who barely survived a 2011 assassination ...
8
Street Food Institute breaks ground on new 'home' in ...
ABQnews Seeker
Elizabeth Bibiano, owner of vegan New ... Elizabeth Bibiano, owner of vegan New Mexican restaurant Vegos can't say enough about her time ...
9
Game Commission officially repeals stream access rule
ABQnews Seeker
The New Mexico State Game Commission ... The New Mexico State Game Commission on Friday officially overturned a controversial rule that had allowed for private landowners to close off nonnavigable waterways ...