It's time for school choice for students, parents, educators - Albuquerque Journal

It’s time for school choice for students, parents, educators

Rebecca Dow

In 2018, a state district judge issued an historic decision identifying the long-time shortcomings and faults of New Mexico’s public education system. Judge Sarah Singleton described in great detail how our Native American, English learner, disabled and economically disadvantaged students were not receiving the education promised by our state constitution. In turn, she demanded state policymakers fix the problem.

Since then, we have seen the governor declare an educational “moonshot,” a billion-dollar increase in K-12 education spending, and implementation of progressive theology of equity, inclusion and diversity to help these at-risk students.

Our governor then shut down our public schools for more than a year and mandated remote learning for which these same at-risk students would likely have less access to computers and internet service than other students.

What results has this education “Hail Mary” created? Students across all grades and backgrounds are falling further behind their peers in other states; schools are seeing more students with behavioral health problems and higher rates of absenteeism; and N.M.’s schools are still ranked 50th in the nation. There is also growing recognition among parents that the Department of Public Education (PED) is more concerned with promoting political agendas than ensuring kids can read, write and do math – a travesty by any measure.

PED recently released a draft 55-page action plan designed to fulfill the judge’s ruling that state policymakers must provide at-risk students with the education they deserve. Sadly, the draft proposal was nothing more than the same education “solutions” of the past – spending more money, creating new programs directed by the Santa Fe bureaucracy, and restating educational goals that have never been met. In short, it was a typical top-down approach, along with a refusal to critically examine how N.M.’s public schools operate and are financed. To say students, parents and taxpayers are becoming more frustrated is a gross understatement.

Why not try something new? The ways of the past have failed and now is the time to institute fundamental change – school choice. This approach would allow families to take their children’s education dollars to an approved education provider of their choosing, whether a traditional public school, a public charter school, a private school, virtual learning or home schooling. School choice ensures education dollars are used to educate children, not to protect a particular educational institution or politically influential group. We could start school choice by modifying our patchwork extended learning program, which has left half of the state’s students with unequal opportunity simply because many districts don’t want to extend the school year. Let’s give those students options!

Educational savings accounts, scholarship tax credits, individual tuition tax credits and, yes, even the “dreaded” voucher, are proven ways of increasing access to better educational experiences. Contrary to the myths created by naysayers, school choice has shown to improve academic performance, reduce racial disparities and save taxpayers’ money.

The educational deficiency N.M.’s at-risk students experience is due primarily to being forced to attend schools that will not or cannot meet their needs. By providing the financial resources to offer school choice, these students and their families can discover new learning opportunities that offer hope for the future. Equally important, school choice will instill a creative environment among educators to develop learning centers better prepared to educate our state’s diverse student population.

We need to transform public education to help at-risk communities and the best way is to give students, parents and educators choice when it comes to deciding the best learning opportunity.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » It’s time for school choice for students, parents, educators


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
New immersive experience lets eventgoers interact with the legendary ...
Arts
The Georgia O'Keeffe Museum saw an ... The Georgia O'Keeffe Museum saw an opportunity to work with Albuquerque-based Electric Playhouse to create 'Music For The Eyes: A New Georgia O'Keeffe Experience
2
Historic locomotive Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe 2926 almost ...
Arts
The AT&SF 2926 was built in ... The AT&SF 2926 was built in 1944 and ran a million miles in the American Southwest before being retired to an Albuquerque park in ...
3
New Mexico town fiercely protective of its land and ...
Arts
Chilili's name is not to be ... Chilili's name is not to be confused with another small town in northern New Mexico called Chili, or the delicious condiment we put on ...
4
Eliminating mimosa seed pods can help larvae in check
Arts
Earlier this year you had some ... Earlier this year you had some sort of adult insects lay eggs throughout the mimosa, probably just at the spot where the flowers extended ...
5
'Grounded' explores the struggle between war and family
Arts
Fusion Theatre Company is staging 'Grounded' ... Fusion Theatre Company is staging 'Grounded' beginning on Friday, Oct. 7, at The Cell Theatre. The play runs on weekends through Oct. 16. 'Grounded' ...
6
'When the Dogs Stop Barking' explores the humanitarian crisis ...
Arts
Open at 516 ARTS through Dec. ... Open at 516 ARTS through Dec. 31, 'When the Dogs Stop Barking' exhibits the work of five artists exploring this humanitarian crisis spanning 1,954 ...
7
'Migratory' pairs the migration of plants and animals with ...
Arts
'Migratory,' developed by Mexico City artist ... 'Migratory,' developed by Mexico City artist Minerva Cuevas, will run at 516 ARTS through Dec. 31.
8
The third Fixed and Free Quarterly features a collection ...
Arts
Fifty-nine poets – the ... Fifty-nine poets – the majority from New Mexico – contributed the 112 poems that spice up the third and most ...
9
Via Ferrata, like the one in Telluride, are a ...
Arts
Via ferratas started in Italy during ... Via ferratas started in Italy during World War I to allow troops to pass through rugged alpine areas, the idea spread across Europe and ...