Spaceport subsidies and corporate welfare's black hole - Albuquerque Journal

Spaceport subsidies and corporate welfare’s black hole

Earlier this year, Virgin Galactic announced it would begin manufacturing spaceships in Arizona, “hiring hundreds.” The new Delta Class facility is expected to be operational by the end of 2023.

Swami Iyer, Virgin Galactic’s president of aerospace systems, said, “this will allow us to accelerate progress from conceptual design to production to final assembly at scale as we capitalize on the many advantages Mesa and the greater Phoenix area offer.”

As the crow flies, the new manufacturing facility in Mesa, Arizona, is more than 200 miles from the launch facility in Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. You might think manufacturing spaceplanes closer to the launch facility would be advantageous to the company. But as former governor of the New Mexico Territory Lew Wallace once said, “All calculations based on our experiences elsewhere fail in New Mexico.”

The announcement comes one year after Sir Richard Branson’s historic spaceflight that departed from Spaceport America. Whereas it is worth congratulating Sir Richard for his accomplishment, it is also worth looking further into the lavish taxpayer-funded subsidies that backed the project. The exorbitant cost of $275 million is corporate welfare, plain and simple. Virgin Galactic did not incur any of the construction costs.

It is a known problem. Billionaires like Branson flaunt projects like Spaceport America in front of politicians, dangling the potential new jobs, promises of infrastructure development and future tax revenues as a way to encourage political types to “invest” in the future. In exchange for these promises, the government offers special, favorable treatment for corporations. It’s worth admitting that the prospective benefits are enticing: what elected person would not want to deliver economic development to their districts with flashy headlines?

Last year, Branson was able to prove he could launch spacecraft from any airport that had a sufficiently long runway. There was little evidence New Mexicans would see a worthwhile return on the state’s $275 million investment. Increasingly so, it appears that they will not. Branson received a $275 million gift while New Mexicans were left holding the bag.

However, Branson has no reason to invest in spaceship manufacturing in the “Land of Enchantment.” With New Mexico’s high crime, some of the nation’s worst public education, and a broken sales tax that makes the state unappealing to new businesses, Branson’s decision to construct his spaceships in Arizona is a smart one.

In New Mexico, politicians have been desperately scrambling for an easy way out. Rather than invest in the serious tax reform and the education reform New Mexico needs, they continue throwing cash at the elites in the hope someday the “investment” will pay off.

Spaceport America’s return on investment is less than stellar, especially considering that space tickets are not taxable. As of 2020, revenues were reported at only $54.3 million for the state. I’m not an accountant, but that’s a net loss of $220.7 million. And that’s not including the additional $1.5 million in advertising expenses related to last summer’s Virgin Galactic flight.

This ought to be a lesson to the entire country. Taxpayer subsidies earn no loyalty from corporations. They just provide another way for billionaires to pad their bottom line. In reality, corporate welfare is a gangrenous limb that should be severed before it’s too late.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Spaceport subsidies and corporate welfare’s black hole


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
NM expands help with filling court forms
ABQnews Seeker
Court-scribe program helps people understand and ... Court-scribe program helps people understand and complete documents
2
Motown Bound: Aggies to face Bowling Green in Dec. ...
College
New Mexico State football is heading ... New Mexico State football is heading for Detroit to play in the Dec. 26 Quick Lane Bowl vs. Bowling Green in a matchup of ...
3
BYU, SMU set to meet in Dec. 17 New ...
College
Journal Staff Report BYU and SMU ... Journal Staff Report BYU and SMU have been selected to participate in the 17th annual New Mexico Bowl set for Saturday, Dec. 17, at ...
4
So far, soooooo good for Pitino and the Lobo ...
College
It's been a unique first month ... It's been a unique first month of the season for the Lobo men's basketball team. We check in with UNM coach Richard Pitino about ...
5
No. 14 Arizona presents these challenges for Lobo women
College
Wildcats have size, speed and talent Wildcats have size, speed and talent
6
Supreme Court case threatens balance of power
From the newspaper
State courts must have oversight authority ... State courts must have oversight authority in federal elections
7
Keep your spending close to home
From the newspaper
Shop locally to keep small, independent ... Shop locally to keep small, independent businesses afloat
8
Los Ranchos controversy knits village closer
From the newspaper
Many have worked to get justice; ... Many have worked to get justice; their efforts will pay off
9
Editorial: Mastery over memory worth trying to help tackle ...
Editorials
The initial reaction by many Journal ... The initial reaction by many Journal readers to exploring equitable grading at Albuquerque Public Sc ...