Pair shot to death in Fort Sumner - Albuquerque Journal

Pair shot to death in Fort Sumner

An Arizona man and his wife were shot to death Sunday at the Fort Sumner home where they’d been visiting, officials said.

The victims were identified as Brian Beaver, 48, and Rachelle Beaver, 38, according to DeBaca County Sheriff Robert Roybal.

Roybal said Kelby Randolph, 53, of Fort Sumner, is in the DeBaca County jail, being held without bail and charged with two counts of murder in the first degree.

Roybal said Randolph called the county dispatch center on the non-emergency number around 5:40 p.m. Sunday.

According to court documents, dispatch spoke with Deputy Paul Nunez, telling him that Randolph was requesting a deputy at his home in the 100 block of East Main Avenue in Fort Sumner. Randolph would not say why he needed a deputy.

Nunez arrived at Randolph’s house and Randolph came out to speak with the deputy.

Nunez walked in the living room and “noticed two bodies that had been shot, one male sitting on the recliner and one female laying on the floor in front of the male …”

Nunez noticed a black semi-automatic pistol on the floor next to the female.

Nunez and Randolph went back outside and, while there, a car pulled up. Nunez and Randolph walked outside the home’s fence and spoke with the driver who Randolph identified as Bill Hancock.

Nunez said Randolph told Hancock he was going to jail for murder.

Hancock asked Randolph who he killed and Randolph said, “Free loaders,” and pointed to his house. Randolph also told Hancock he needed his lawyer present.

Nunez said Randolph would not give any indication what happened inside the house.

Tenth Judicial District Attorney investigator Shank Cribbs interviewed Gary Wilson, an acquaintance of Randolph, court records show.

Wilson said around 3:55 p.m. Sunday he got a phone call from Randolph asking him to come to Randolph’s home.

Once there, Randolph gave Wilson a handwritten will leaving everything to Randolph’s brother. Wilson said he saw that Randolph was holding a black handgun.

Wilson said Randolph said he was “planning to off himself or go out in a blaze of glory.”

Brian and Rachelle Beaver were from Mesa, Ariz. Brian’s teenage daughter, Brianna, said her dad left her in August in the care of his mother, Yvette Owens and Brianna’s mother.

“He went to Fort Sumner to help a friend with his business,” Brianna said.

Brianna said that friend was Randolph.

“My dad was a good man,” Brianna said in a telephone interview on Tuesday. “He was always trying to help people out.”

She remembers her father loved to fish, and when he had a tow truck, he would take her along on tow calls.

“He would take me on his dirt bike,” Brianna said, adding it was one of her favorite memories of her dad. “Through the neighborhood, the alleyways, by the canals up and down. Riding fast. He was a great family man.”

Home » Around the Region » Pair shot to death in Fort Sumner

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

Woman dies on hike in Utah's Zion Park, husband ...
Around the Region
A woman died and a man ... A woman died and a man was rescued and treated for hypothermia after they were caught in extreme cold weather while hiking in Utah's ...
Colorado Springs reckons with past after gay club shooting
Around the Region
When officials unfurled a 25-foot rainbow ... When officials unfurled a 25-foot rainbow flag in front of Colorado Springs City Hall this week, people gathered to mourn the victims of a ...
Police: Ex-spouse fatally shoots 2, hurts 2 in Houston ...
Around the Region
A man believed to be a ... A man believed to be a former spouse entered a Houston-area home and shot four people who were celebrating Thanksgiving, killing two and wounding ...
Wife of Texas man killed by police in Arizona ...
Around the Region
The widow of an unarmed Texas ... The widow of an unarmed Texas man fatally shot by police outside his suburban Phoenix hotel room in 2016 has agreed to settle her ...
Grand Canyon park changes campground name that haunted tribe
Around the Region
For years, the Indian Garden name ... For years, the Indian Garden name assigned to a popular Grand Canyon campground has been a painful reminder for a Native American tribe that ...
Official says vape sensor project a success
Around the Region
Vape sensors installed in the high ... Vape sensors installed in the high school and middle schools are doing their job, Clovis Municipal Schools board members were told at Tuesday's November ...
'Master of Silly Business' among 5 dead in Colorado ...
Around the Region
On a typical night at Club ... On a typical night at Club Q, a bastion for LGBTQ people in the largely conservative city of Colorado Springs, Daniel Aston could be ...
Chandler police: Man wounds his 2 kids, fatally shoots ...
Around the Region
Two children are hospitalized after being ... Two children are hospitalized after being shot by their father, who then killed himself, Chandler police said Sunday. Police didn't immediately release the name ...
Bison spread as Native American tribes reclaim stewardship
Around the Region
Perched atop a fence at Badlands ... Perched atop a fence at Badlands National Park, Troy Heinert peered from beneath his wide-brimmed hat into a corral where 100 wild bison awaited ...