Proposed tenant injury ordinance will make things worse - Albuquerque Journal

Proposed tenant injury ordinance will make things worse

Proposed renter protection legislation by Albuquerque City Councilor Tammy Fiebelkorn would do the opposite of what she thinks it will do. Her proposal represents a fundamental misunderstanding of the industry.

Application fees: They really do cost landlords money, between $35 and $50 per person, to do a background check and a credit check. Of course, that is only the cost paid to the reporting agency, it doesn’t include any of the landlord’s time assessing the reports and the prospective tenant. Often, landlords charge prospective tenants for this as a defensive measure. When landlords pay the charges themselves, many will apply to multiple places, driving up costs for those landlords who pay it themselves. It is normal then for the landlord to pay for the checks, then approve applicants who then say they are not interested, wasting time and money. In addition, many applicants lie on their applications. They are less likely to lie if they themselves are paying for the verification that will contradict the information they provide.

Pet charges: Despite the fact that virtually every pet owner insists his/her pet is the perfect animal, never soiling the floor, never damaging anything, that just is not true. Not only do pets often damage things, damage that reaches into the thousands of dollars at times, but also they significantly increase “normal wear.” The soiled carpet may not need immediate replacement, but will have a shorter lifetime. The torn-up landscaping, even after repair, will never be the same. So, we charge pet rent to cover some of those costs. Although that additional rent is, in some cases, more than the wear, more often than not, the wear exceeds the pet rent charges. In almost every case, the unit will require more cleaning work when the former tenant had a pet.

Fees: Those fees are often not at all about making money or covering costs; they are about discouraging specific behaviors. We charge $1 per cigarette butt for picking them out of the gravel. We much prefer there be none to pick up. We have a separate fee for having a pet without a prior pet agreement. We would much rather deal with the animal up front, ensuring the safety and tranquility of the neighborhood from vicious or loud animals. How could we possibly prove those costs as Fiebelkorn demands?

Income and credit score: Nothing is fixed in stone, yet Fiebelkorn demands it be so. Sometimes, we will approve a lower credit score when there is a reasonable explanation and evidence that the prospective tenant has dealt with the issues. Sometimes, a parent will guarantee a payment, or even make the payment, even though the parent is not a tenant. This proposal will injure those she would want to help.

Fiebelkorn’s proposal does not do what she seems to think it will do. It will not help at all; it will make things worse. The real issue is Fiebelkorn just doesn’t know. She knows what tenants tell her, but she has failed to put in the work required to determine why landlords do what they do.

In conclusion, money goes where it is treated best. Fiebelkorn would chase more landlords away, decreasing the already short supply of rentals, driving up rents further.

Thom Wright manages nine rental properties in Albuquerque.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Proposed tenant injury ordinance will make things worse

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Students need financial literacy as a graduation requirement
From the newspaper
OPINION: Without basic personal finance education, ... OPINION: Without basic personal finance education, far too many employees turn to check-cashing outlets and get charged unnecessary fees, take out high-interest loans, or ...
NM needs to act quick to attract and keep ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: The average age of physicians ... OPINION: The average age of physicians in New Mexico is 53, so we can predict increasing shortages as retirements occur.
Editorial: NM lands need a state 'legacy fund,' true ...
From the Editorial Board: A healthy ... From the Editorial Board: A healthy outdoors is a healthy part of New Mexico's fiscal landscape, so the chance to unlock federal matching funds ...
Largest police cadet class in years seated in Santa ...
ABQnews Seeker
The 205th New Mexico Law Enforcement ... The 205th New Mexico Law Enforcement Academy class has 64 prospective officers. The class is shaping up to be the largest in years.
New Mexico seems determined to extend class time. What ...
ABQnews Seeker
Three competing proposals are on the ... Three competing proposals are on the table
Bill would allow New Mexico cities, counties, tribes to ...
ABQnews Seeker
The proposed legislation would allow local ... The proposed legislation would allow local governments to take over electric generation from privately run utilities.
Bernalillo County sheriff calls current body camera tech 'trash,' ...
ABQnews Seeker
The sheriff's statement on body cameras ... The sheriff's statement on body cameras was in response to a recommendation from the Sheriff's Office Advisory and Review Board. The board gave BCSO ...
Meet Harry Montoya, who reads New Mexico Senate documents ...
ABQnews Seeker
“One of my friends, he said, ... “One of my friends, he said, ‘Oh, you’re God’s voice in the Capitol,'” Harry Montoya said, laughing.
Best sites for Albuquerque building and road construction information
ABQnews Seeker
WHAT'S UP WITH THAT CONSTRUCTION? Michael ... WHAT'S UP WITH THAT CONSTRUCTION? Michael A. Blackledge asks "does the city of Albuquerq ...