Supreme Court case threatens balance of power - Albuquerque Journal

Supreme Court case threatens balance of power

A little-known redistricting case with huge consequences for democracy is coming to the U.S. Supreme Court for oral argument Dec. 7 and Common Cause is in the thick of it.

Moore v. Harper is an appeal of a North Carolina case brought by Common Cause and the Southern Coalition for Social Justice after redistricting in the Tar Heels state. The N.C. Supreme Court ruled in our favor and threw out the legislature’s map as a partisan gerrymander that violated the N.C. Constitution. The N.C. legislature then appealed the case to the Supreme Court, basing its case on an obscure phrase in the U.S. Constitution, which it says gives state legislatures absolute authority over federal elections.

The case has implications for New Mexico, where the New Mexico Supreme Court is poised to hear a suit brought by the Republican Party challenging the congressional map adopted by the legislature in 2021. In other states, both Democrats and Republicans have taken maps and voting rights issues to state court. But if SCOTUS rules for North Carolina, state courts could not block legislative maps or restrict the legislature’s ability to set voting qualifications and procedures in federal races. In some states, this could open the door for discriminatory barriers to voting access, baseless challenges to election results, and rigged voting maps. The result would reduce the power of voters in favor of power-hungry politicians who would have carte blanche to sabotage an election, or a redistricting process.

Former judge and conservative legal scholar, J. Michael Luttig, calls Moore “the single most important case on and for American democracy since the nation’s founding.”

On Dec. 7, Common Cause will be arguing for the essential elements of democracy: checks and balances for each branch of government, the authority of state constitutions, judicial review of legislative and executive decisions. Moore erodes these fundamental elements and the rule of law to no more than the will of state legislatures.

This is why 48 “friends of the court” briefs have been filed by judges, secretaries of state, the American Bar Association, and good government groups to reject this desperate attempt to destroy these well-established principles. One of these, the Conference of Chief Justices, composed of 50 current and former justices from across 50 states, takes aim at its underlying “independent state legislator theory,” which ignores precedent, overturns centuries of checks and balances, and usurps the role of the courts and state constitutions. In addition, 12 secretaries of state, including New Mexico’s, contend that an adverse ruling would upend election administration, causing dual systems for federal and state elections.

For years, Common Cause has worked to amplify the voices of voters, not politicians who want to control the whole show without any kind of accountability. We see Moore v. Harper not just as a redistricting case, but a major attempt to usurp power and allow lawmakers to undermine ordinary voters who want a say in the future of our families and neighborhoods. In New Mexico we have been fortunate. But if SCOTUS rules in favor of North Carolina, every citizen’s vote is subject to a veto from their state legislature, which will control elections and make it even easier to draw rigged maps, erect barriers, or do whatever the politicians then in power want – without judicial or executive restraint. That’s not the democracy we know and love.

No matter your political party, we urge you to pay attention to this case and support those who are working to stop this power grab. Add your name to our petition ( to urge the Supreme Court to reject this lawless legislature theory.

Common Cause is a nonpartisan grassroots organization dedicated to upholding the core values of American democracy. We work to create open, honest, and accountable government that serves the public interest; promote equal rights, opportunity, and representation for all; and empower all people to make their voices heard as equals in the political process.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Supreme Court case threatens balance of power

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Editorial: NM can’t afford to go backward on government ...
From the Editorial Board: The Inspection ... From the Editorial Board: The Inspection of Public Records Act has a presumption that citizens are entitled to the greatest possible amount of information ...
We need to enact omnibus crime and gun law ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs ... OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs the 1-2 punch of an omnibus bill focused on harsher penalties and gun-control measures.
Tribal Remedy Framework addresses systemic inequities
From the newspaper
OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach ... OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach to improve educational outcomes for Native youth.
Dollars alone won't solve New Mexico's problems
From the newspaper
OPINION: The current system of distributing ... OPINION: The current system of distributing capital outlay funds needs an overhaul if we want those dollars to do the most good.
Medicaid provider procurement process canceled
From the newspaper
HSD says decision made after departures ... HSD says decision made after departures of Secretary Scrase and Medicaid Director Nicole Comeaux
'It's been a great ride': Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive ...
ABQnews Seeker
Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is ... Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is retiring
Prep football: Lee to take over at Albuquerque Academy
Featured Sports
The architect of Hope Christian's state ... The architect of Hope Christian's state championship defense in 2019, and the man who put together Albuquerque Academy's stellar defense the last two years, ...
Prep notes: Gary Bradley to continue family tradition at ...
Featured Sports
From father to son to brother, ... From father to son to brother, the Bradley family football tradition will continue at Mayfield High ...
It's a slow(er) week, but there's no resting for ...
The calendar would tell you the ... The calendar would tell you the workload for the UNM basketball team this week is a light one. ...