Editorial: Mastery over memory worth trying to help tackle APS achievement gap - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Mastery over memory worth trying to help tackle APS achievement gap

The initial reaction by many Journal readers to exploring equitable grading at Albuquerque Public Schools has been somewhat skeptical — to put it mildly.

Letter writer Bob Christensen of Belen says the $687,500 pilot program recently approved by the school board by a 6-1 vote sends a message to some students that they “will never be able to succeed on their own.”

“Are life skills like behavior and discipline really not worth teaching?” asked Paul Malin of Albuquerque.

Dan Bright of Albuquerque asks why not simply give every student an A “and make it truly ‘equitable.'”

“Can we go any lower than 51st in the nation?” asked a SpeakUp! writer.

APS board member Peggy Muller Aragón, the lone board member to vote against the pilot program, argued the premise behind equitable grading is offensive because it assumes students of color or those who have fewer opportunities aren’t as capable as their peers.

“I take offense to that as a person of color,” Muller Aragón said.

While those concerns are legitimate, the goal of school is to educate students to face life’s challenges and become productive members of society, not to gauge how well they perform on standardized tests or how punctual a third-grader is in turning in homework.

Many APS schools now use a grading system in which a grade of 59% or less is considered failing. So a student could theoretically master nearly three-fifths of the subject material and still fail the course.

According to APS Chief of Schools Channell Segura, the pilot program will work this way: Rather than a 0 to 100 grading system, participating teachers will use a new grading scale. A “zero” would mean a student hasn’t submitted any evidence of mastering a subject. A “one” would demonstrate limited understanding. A “two” — the threshold for a grade that would be counted for credit — would indicate a student was partially proficient. A “three” means proficiency. A “four” means highly proficient.

Equitable grading also means shifting away from averaged final grades and focusing more on tests students can retake, an approach that more accurately shows a student’s actual proficiency.

“(I)t works to get away from averaging students’ grades over time and instead (looks) at that end result to see how much the student has grown in that specific skill or standard,” Segura told the school board. “Grading … it’s been very subjective over time on the 100-point scale. It’s not focused on student learning, and so it’s more compliance-based.”

Teachers also will move away from rejecting late assignments. The rationale is that meeting a deadline is not an actual measure of what a student has learned. Meeting deadlines is still an important skill, but it doesn’t measure a student’s mastery of a subject.

Joyce Gormley, executive director of Curriculum and Instruction at APS, contends equitable grading is still rigorous, and actually does a better job of providing grade-level content to students.

Segura told school board members she would have preferred to label the practices “standards-based or mastery-based” instead of “equitable.” Based on Segura’s description, either the mastery- or standards-based label seems a more apt description of this program.

The two-year pilot will provide training for up to 300 APS teachers and 40 administrators beginning in the fall, for teachers “who are excited about it.”

Speaking of teachers, one concern we did not see mentioned is the program’s impact on teachers. First, there is the additional work of regrading multiple tests because students choose to retake them. Second, how are teachers supposed to cope with receiving a semester’s worth of assignments in the final two weeks — a scenario that will surely happen without assignment deadlines?

The program needs to be designed to prevent these train wrecks.

Despite those concerns, it’s an idea worth exploring, particularly considering the landmark Yazzie-Martinez consolidated lawsuit of 2018 that found the state was not providing certain students — especially low-income, Native American, English language learner and students with disabilities — with the programs and services necessary for them to learn and thrive.

We’ve got to try something new. The aim of equitable grading is to counteract institutional biases by cutting out traditional methods of grading.

It’s crucial the pilot program — funded by federal pandemic relief funds — builds data about its effectiveness, which should then determine whether it is worth expanding.

That data should be transparent, honestly evaluated and rigorously studied. If concerns about lowered expectations for students prove true, the program should be scuttled.

“We’re going to see how effective this is before we make any sweeping policy decisions,” Segura says. Good. Dipping your toe in a cold lake is one thing, jumping in is another.

More mastery-based education and less emphasis on grading are trending. The panel of the American Bar Association that accredits U.S. law schools recently voted to eliminate the longstanding requirement that schools use the Law School Admission Test or other standardized test when admitting students. Some say the LSAT is a roadblock to building a diverse legal profession and law schools should have more flexibility in admissions.

Local school districts need flexibility, too.

A program at APS focusing more on student achievement than report cards could help eliminate institutional biases while also reducing the achievement gap.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Mastery over memory worth trying to help tackle APS achievement gap

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Editorial: NM can’t afford to go backward on government ...
From the Editorial Board: The Inspection ... From the Editorial Board: The Inspection of Public Records Act has a presumption that citizens are entitled to the greatest possible amount of information ...
Editorial: NM lands need a state 'legacy fund,' true ...
From the Editorial Board: A healthy ... From the Editorial Board: A healthy outdoors is a healthy part of New Mexico's fiscal landscape, so the chance to unlock federal matching funds ...
Editorial: Legislative package has sensible measures to address rampant ...
From the Editorial Board: When you ... From the Editorial Board: When you get a Democratic governor, Republican and Democratic lawmakers, the Albuquerque police chief, the district attorney and the attorney ...
Editorial: How useful is the Arnold tool?
From the Editorial Board: New Mexicans ... From the Editorial Board: New Mexicans still waiting for fair and uniform pretrial release determination system.
Editorial: More NM districts should follow APS, set student ...
From the Editorial Board: It's essential ... From the Editorial Board: It's essential for goals to last longer than board members or an administrator's tenure.
Editorial: Gun laws should enhance safety, target criminal acts
From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers should ... From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers should focus gun legislation on sensible steps that can make a difference without feeding the notion that the government ...
Editorial: ABQ needs to clean up its paths and ...
From the Editorial Board: Downtown, where ... From the Editorial Board: Downtown, where the city has invested money trying to make the area a liveable, attractive center of the city, the ...
Editorial: Better habits can help prevent traffic deaths
From the Editorial Board: While not ... From the Editorial Board: While not every crash is survivable, deadly accidents could be reduced by simple steps.
Editorial: AFR-APS teamwork could rescue NM workforce
From the Editorial Board: So here's ... From the Editorial Board: So here's to monitoring the AFR-APS ambassador program, and scaling it up to other careers and other districts — for ...