An infatuation with foster care won't save kids - Albuquerque Journal

An infatuation with foster care won’t save kids

Decades ago it would happen all the time: After the tragic death of a child “known to the system,” advocates would rush to blame a supposed fanatical desire to put “parents’ rights” ahead of “child safety.” After all, the case file had more red flags than a Soviet May Day Parade, so what else could explain it?

Understandably, people would buy it. That would cause a foster-care panic – a sharp, sudden increase in the number of children torn from their families and consigned to the chaos of foster care. That would further overwhelm caseworkers, so they’d have even less time to investigate any case with care. So it’s no wonder, in state after state, child abuse deaths didn’t stop – often they increased.

That’s because the real explanation for these tragedies almost always involves caseworkers overloaded with cases that are nothing like the horror stories.

In New Mexico, nearly two-thirds of all entries into foster care don’t involve so much as an allegation of abuse. Nearly two-thirds do not allege drug use of any kind. But 78% allege neglect. Sometimes, neglect can be extremely serious, but more often it means the family is poor. In fully 20% of New Mexico cases, children are taken because the family lacks adequate housing – and since you’re never supposed to admit that, the real figure probably is far higher.

The problem with all this is not that it hurts parents, though of course, it does. The problem is the enormous harm to children. Study after study finds that in typical cases children left in their own homes fare better even than comparably-maltreated children placed in foster care. Still more independent research shows appalling rates of abuse in foster care, far higher than what agencies such as the New Mexico Children Youth and Families Department admit. Meanwhile, the deluge of false allegations and trivial cases so overloads workers that, when New Mexico opened its statewide child abuse hotline, its director had to beg people to stop calling in so many obviously false reports.

That deluge is the real reason children in real danger are missed.

For all these reasons, in much of the country the child welfare debate has matured. But, not, it seems in New Mexico where Deborah Gray blames “reunification romanticization” and a “blinding infatuation” with keeping families together.

Given the horrible record of child removal, and the enormous harm of needless foster care, one has to ask: Who’s really infatuated here?

Gray is right on two points. First, the system does indeed hide behind confidentiality laws that protect that system, not children. Forty percent of foster children live in states where court hearings in these cases are open. New Mexico should join them, and create a rebuttable presumption of openness for most records. Then people can see all those typical cases that are nothing like the horror stories.

Gray also is right when she says “the safety and well-being of the child should override all other considerations.” But the only way to do that is to get over our blinding infatuation with tearing apart families and stop romanticizing foster care.

Learn more about the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform, “The Prius of Child Advocacy,” by visiting www.nccpr.org

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » An infatuation with foster care won’t save kids

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories




Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages

 

Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
1
Santa Fe student selected to magazine's Junior Council
Arts
Viviana Garcia-Vélez, 11, chosen out of ... Viviana Garcia-Vélez, 11, chosen out of hundreds of applicants by weekly youth news publication The Week Junior.
2
Xeric Garden Club to host lecture
Arts
The Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque ... The Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque will hosting Laurel Ladwig as she speaks on the topic 'Share Space with Wildlife with a Backyard Refuge.'
3
SITE Santa Fe awarded National Endowment for the Arts ...
Arts
The grant will support the upcoming ... The grant will support the upcoming exhibition, 'Going With the Flow: Art, Actions and Western Waters,' opening on April 14.
4
PBS KIDS series 'Work It Out Wombats!' encourages viewers ...
Arts
The animated series premieres at 9:30 ... The animated series premieres at 9:30 a.m. Monday, Feb. 6, on PBS KIDS, channel 5.2. It will then rebroadcast at 11:30 a.m. on New ...
5
Lobo basketball signee Toppin expected to make UNM fans ...
ABQnews Seeker
Jadyn 'J.T.' Toppin has enjoyed a ... Jadyn 'J.T.' Toppin has enjoyed a strong senior season in Texas and can't wait to get to UNM and join the Lobos.
6
'Blossoming' consists of work by artists enrolled in Albuquerque ...
Arts
Some artists chose self-portraits to express ... Some artists chose self-portraits to express their changes through time and the pandemic.
7
Founding member of the Taos Society of Artists, W. ...
Arts
The Harwood Museum of Art will ... The Harwood Museum of Art will host 'William Herbert 'Buck' Dunton: A Mainer Goes West' through May 21.
8
Answers from the Roundhouse: What's being done to lighten ...
Answers from the Roundhouse
One bill would more than double ... One bill would more than double the minimum annual salary for education assistants
9
Prep basketball: Albuquerque Academy boys throw 'first punch' in ...
Boys' Basketball
Albuquerque Academy used a big third ... Albuquerque Academy used a big third quarter to pull away for a 72-60 boys basketball victory over Valley on the Vikings' home court on ...