New Mexico faces a budget abyss if oil and gas goes bust - Albuquerque Journal

New Mexico faces a budget abyss if oil and gas goes bust

With peak oil and gas production lurking on the horizon, New Mexico could face up to a $36 billion accumulated budget deficit by the mid-2030s, making tax and revenue-management reforms urgent, according to a new report by PFM Group Consulting.

The Pennsylvania-based financial consultant released its latest analysis about New Mexico’s over-dependence on oil and gas revenue Monday morning, following a previous study it published in 2020 about the issue. The new report warned of a potential budget catastrophe over the next 15 years unless lawmakers take aggressive action to diversify the state’s economy and broaden the tax base.

With nearly $3.6 billion in “new money” projected for the fiscal year that starts in July, today’s revenue windfall from oil and gas provides a unique opportunity to prepare for an inevitable decline in fossil fuel production in coming years, said PFM Director Ryan McNeely.

But lawmakers need to seize the moment.

“New Mexico policymakers have been riding the oil and gas revenue roller-coaster for decades, and this year are experiencing the highest up-slope, and subsequent excess revenue, in state history,” McNeely said an a statement. “Our report is not warning of doom and gloom, but rather urging policymakers to strike while the iron is hot and to prepare for the downturn while excess state revenue and federal opportunity allows for decisive and impactful action toward revenue diversification.”

PFM scrutinized tax and revenue data from the Legislative Finance Committee to compare LFC projections on future income with industry expectations about oil and gas production over the next 15 years. It concluded that long-term LFC calculations on revenue flow may significantly overestimate realistic assumptions, potentially creating a $26 billion to $36 billion accumulated budget deficit by the mid-2030s if current tax structure and revenue-management strategies are left unchecked, McNeely told reporters in an online presentation Monday morning.

That’s because the LFC’s long-term analysis relies heavily on currently elevated oil prices and unprecedented growth in production, rather than calculations based on historical trends of boom and bust and future headwinds facing the industry.

Today’s boom reflects “once-in-a-generation” circumstances — including the pandemic and the war in Ukraine — which have distorted global supply and demand and kept fuel prices at sustained highs. But those unique conditions will disappear as the market recovers, and when the next industry bust comes, it could mark the start of a permanent decline in oil and gas production as the world moves away from fossil fuels, McNeely said.

Predicting when that happens is difficult.

“There is no crystal ball,” McNeely said. “But at some point, oil and gas revenue will decline permanently, and that could begin sooner than folks project with little time for the state to respond.”

If New Mexico focused solely on tax reform to make up for lost revenue, it would need to raise gross receipts income 60%, or double personal income taxes, according to PFM.

Rather, the report recommends comprehensive reforms to both broaden the tax base and better target incentives to stimulate key industries and diversify the economy.

Lawmakers are already considering many mitigation measures, such as channeling more general fund revenue into new and existing permanent accounts, including the severance tax permanent fund and the early childhood trust fund that was created in 2021, said LFC Chief Economist Ismael Torres.

“Those mechanisms can build up state reserves and turn today’s surplus money into future money,” Torres told the Journal. “Shoring up the permanent funds will help offset oil and gas revenue losses in the future.”

But getting bipartisan legislative backing could be challenging, depending on what measures are pursued. In fact, even generating a sense of “urgency” may be difficult, since some legislators reject the premise of peak oil.

Republican Rep. Larry Scott, a longtime oilman from Hobbs, said modern drilling technologies have opened up a virtually inexhaustible supply of oil and gas in southeast New Mexico that could continue to generate abundant state revenue if state and federal regulations don’t cripple the industry.

“I have nothing against diversification — it’s an admirable goal — but given the economic conditions in this state, there is simply no substitute for the petroleum business,” Scott told the Journal. “There is no diversification effort I see now or on the horizon to supplant oil and gas money coming into state coffers. It’s foolish to think it’s even possible.”

New Mexico State University economics professor emeritus Jim Peach said such disagreements have blocked economic reform in the past and may well do so again.

“I’m not optimistic that the Legislature will respond very well to this report, because they’ve been told this story time and time again,” Peach told the Journal. “The idea that this oil boom will go on for a long time is just false. Many legislators know that, but it doesn’t translate into the kind of fiscal reforms we need to do.”

More from Kevin Robinson-Avila

Home » ABQnews Seeker » New Mexico faces a budget abyss if oil and gas goes bust

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Mexico: Migrants lit mattresses in fire that killed 39
ABQnews Seeker
MEXICO CITY (AP) -- Migrants fearing ... MEXICO CITY (AP) -- Migrants fearing deportation set mattresses ablaze at an immigration detention center in northern Mexico, starting a fire that left 39 ...
WaFd's Lonnie Corral promoted to senior VP
ABQnews Seeker
BRIEFCASE: Corral will continue to lead ... BRIEFCASE: Corral will continue to lead the nine branches he oversees in southern New Mexico.
La Luz Elementary School students were originally expected to ...
ABQnews Seeker
Originally, the district's plans were to ... Originally, the district's plans were to move students out in 2025. Now, APS wants to do it this fall.
Authorities say a man brought a gun into Flix ...
ABQnews Seeker
If not for the theater's beer ... If not for the theater's beer taps or the man's suspected use of cocaine, the gun-wielding patron who sent Flix Brewhouse employees into a ...
Lobo hoops notebook: Seck to transfer, House returns, Udeze ...
ABQnews Seeker
News and notes around Lobo basketball, ... News and notes around Lobo basketball, including another transferring scholarship player and updates on Morris Udeze and Jaelen House.
Judge: District attorney can't be co-counsel in Baldwin case
ABQnews Seeker
SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) -- A ... SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) -- A New Mexico judge said Santa Fe's district attorney shouldn't serve as co-counsel in the manslaughter case against actor ...
What do PNM-Avangrid merger opponents really want?
ABQnews Seeker
Here's what merger supporters and opponents ... Here's what merger supporters and opponents have to say about the public-power movement’s influence on the Avangrid-PNM deal.
How a Maine power struggle made its way into ...
ABQnews Seeker
A closer look at how Avangrid's ... A closer look at how Avangrid's problems in Maine played a role in the PRC's deliberations.
More parties weigh in on request before Supreme Court ...
ABQnews Seeker
At least five intervening parties have ... At least five intervening parties have now filed responses.