Alternative schools graded improperly - Albuquerque Journal

Alternative schools graded improperly

Each summer educators across the state anxiously await the release of school report card grades. Most leaders of traditional schools are relieved that their grades have improved or maintained.

Leaders of nontraditional schools, however, are more likely disheartened by grades that remain stubbornly low year after year.

Nontraditional schools, such as district alternative schools and many charter schools, are designed to serve students who have failed and/or dropped out of traditional systems. These students bring with them the same skills deficits, addictions, health issues, learning disorders and difficult life experiences that caused their failure in the first place.

They find the courage and motivation to return only because schools like Gordon Bernell Charter School, Cesar Chavez Community School, Nuestros Valores, Freedom High School and so many others throughout the state exist.

The common mission these schools share is to transform failing students into successful students.

By definition an “alternative” school needs to be different. It starts with a fundamental belief that students cannot learn if the barriers that derailed them in the past are not addressed.

Schools do this by creating small learning communities rich with support services, and designed to meet their individual needs. The instructional staff develops curriculum that integrates life skills and employment applications into all content areas. They are trained to understand the populations with which they have chosen to work.

Student progress is measured with short cycle assessment instruments that track growth in academic skills areas. Equally important is improvement in attendance and attitude: healthy habits and lifestyle changes.

None of these success indicators is reflected in the A-F grading system.

Transforming lives does not happen on a predictable school schedule. Hence students may not graduate “on time” or be proficient by the March testing window.

But alternative schools are penalized for not graduating students with their four-, five- or six-year cohort groups. They should be rewarded for reclaiming and graduating dropouts, no matter how long it takes.

They are penalized on student achievement for not having enough students score in the proficiency range on the SBA, yet significant academic growth measured by short cycle assessment data goes unrecognized.

Alternative school leaders know the only way to increase their grade is to whittle away at the square peg, which is their school, to fit into the round hole, which is the accountability system by recreating who they are, what they do and whom they serve. It is a demoralizing annual event for alternative school communities that deserve to celebrate their achievements.

Ultimately, a school that “fails” in our one-size-fits-all grading system risks being closed. There are thousands of students in these schools around the state who would either join the dropout ranks again or be forced into traditional schools that are not equipped to support them.

If for no other reason, we should consider the economic impact.

According to a recent report by the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, each dropout imposes an economic burden of $258,240 and a social burden of $755,900 over the course of his/her lifetime. New Mexico cannot afford that.

Other states, including our neighbor to the north, have embraced robust alternative accountability systems that honor the heroic work of alternative schools. These systems recognize the appropriate indicators of alternative school success, which are different for each school depending on its unique mission.

School reform cannot happen without economic and social reform. Alternative schools are vital change agents in this state and deserve at the very least, a level playing field.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Alternative schools graded improperly

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
‘Second-chance’ bill based on faulty logic
From the newspaper
OPINION: "Second chance" concept is based ... OPINION: "Second chance" concept is based on false assumptions that young offenders don't understand the gravity of murder and that they're unlikely to commit ...
The time is now to diversify NM from fossil ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: State could be counting on ... OPINION: State could be counting on billions that won't be there.
Talk of the Town
From the newspaper
OPINION: State is facing a physician ... OPINION: State is facing a physician crisis.
Recent laws are driving health care providers out of ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: The state Legislature made changes ... OPINION: The state Legislature made changes in 2021 that make an already difficult health care environment even worse for providers.
Free charter schools give parents a choice
From the newspaper
OPINION: Charter schools offer choice to ... OPINION: Charter schools offer choice to families of all backgrounds and income levels.
Children should have hope to leave prison
From the newspaper
OPINION: Life without parole is a ... OPINION: Life without parole is a hidden death penalty.
My grandparents didn't get 'second chance' to live
From the newspaper
OPINION: 'Second chance' bill shouldn't be ... OPINION: 'Second chance' bill shouldn't be passed.
NM can turn the tide by increasing classroom time
From the newspaper
OPINION: Optimizing time for learning is ... OPINION: Optimizing time for learning is a proven education reform.
Foreclosure settlement program serves New Mexico
From the newspaper
OPINION: Court's foreclosure settlement program provides ... OPINION: Court's foreclosure settlement program provides early court intervention in residential mortgage foreclosure cases.