Recover password

Mortgage debt a financial drag on retirement

Thomas Greco and his wife, not pictured, are downsizing from an Irvine, Calif., house into a Lake Forest condo. Greco is retiring and needed to reduce his mortgage payment in order to do so. (Allen J. Schaben/Los Angeles Times/MCT)

Thomas Greco and his wife, not pictured, are downsizing from an Irvine, Calif., house into a Lake Forest condo. Greco is retiring and needed to reduce his mortgage payment in order to do so. (Allen J. Schaben/Los Angeles Times/MCT)

When Tom Greco bought his four-bedroom home three decades ago, he assumed he’d pay off the mortgage before retirement – just as his parents did.

Things didn’t work out that way.

Instead, his $4,500 monthly mortgage payments – a consequence of several equity withdrawals over the years – became a financial drag.

“It’s pretty hard to retire with that,” the 66-year-old attorney said.

More and more older homeowners are carrying mortgage debt, a burden that threatens to delay their retirement and curtail spending among the massive baby boomer population.

Nearly a third of homeowners 65 and older had a mortgage in 2011, up from 22 percent in 2001, according to an analysis from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, using the latest available data.

The debt burden also grew – with older homeowners owing a median of $79,000 in 2011, compared with an inflation-adjusted $43,400 a decade earlier. For decades, Americans strove hard to pay off their mortgages before retirement, an aspiration that when achieved was celebrated with mortgage-burning parties.

But for the latest retirees, reaching that goal, if they ever had it, is increasingly less likely.

Baby boomers bought homes later in life, and with smaller down payments, than previous generations, said Stacy Canan, deputy assistant director of the consumer bureau’s Office for Older Americans. Many also refinanced during the housing bubble and used cash from their equity withdrawals to pay off other debt, take vacations or put children through college.

real01_jd_02nov_mortgraphicSurging home prices and low interest rates made that possible.

Then the recession hit. Job losses delayed attempts to pay off mortgages. And many baby boomers took in their adult children after the collapse, refinancing to help their kids weather a brutal job market, said James Wells, counselor with ClearPoint Credit Counseling Solutions.

“Before, the children could take care of themselves,” he said. “Now, not so much.”

The number of mortgage-holding households headed by someone 65 or older rose from 3.8 million in 2001 to 6.1 million a decade later, the consumer bureau said.

Rising debt levels also reflect a psychological shift among Americans, financial advisers and economists say.

“People who lived through the Great Depression came out of that period with a great aversion to debt,” said Lori Trawinski, director of banking and finance with AARP’s Public Policy Institute. “As a culture, we have loosened our opinion of debt.”

As baby boomers enter retirement age – 10,000 per day, according to one estimate – the decisions that once supported an easier lifestyle could make later years tougher. Some may have to keep working to pay their mortgage, and others will have to cut back on other expenses to retire, the bureau’s Canan said.

“People will indeed have to do some juggling of their budgets,” she said.

Jacqueline Murphy is doing just that. The former clerical worker for the New York City Police Department retired in March, thinking her pension and Social Security, coupled with a part-time job, would allow her to live comfortably and cover mortgage payments on the Bronx townhome she bought for $375,000 during the housing bubble.

But the 63-year-old hasn’t yet found a part-time gig, and a large chunk of her income is going to the $2,200-a-month mortgage.

So she’s cutting back. She keeps the lights off as much as possible, has cut back on gardening to reduce the water bill and sometimes gets help from family to buy groceries.

“I thought retirement was going to be wonderful,” she said. “Now that I am retired, I am sorry that I did. I am focused on how I am going to make it to next week, how am I going to make it to the next mortgage payment, and I am constantly worried.”

Wells, the housing counselor, said those he counsels often didn’t budget for reduced retirement income when they refinanced to help their children, fix a car or take a vacation. They were working then, so the payments seemed reasonable.

“They are not really thinking long term at that point,” he said.

Greco, the attorney, said he took a “shortsighted view.” Enticed by dropping interest rates, he refinanced his Irvine home four times. He then used the money from the cash-out refinancings to pay down credit-card debt and finance home renovations, including a pool he designed.

“A foolish move,” he said of the refinancing, but one that many others, including friends, did as well.

A recent study from Harvard University’s Joint Center for Housing Studies showed that of mortgage holders ages 65 to 79, nearly half spent 30 percent or more of their income on housing costs. Of mortgage holders 80 or older, 61 percent pay that amount on housing.

And the debt carries further risks.

Sudden changes in expenses, such as those stemming from health problems, can expose seniors with mortgages to greater financial peril, the consumer bureau’s study said. And if another downturn comes, retirement savings and investments are likely to take a hit, raising the chance of foreclosure.

One option is to downsize.

That’s the choice Greco made. In August, he and his wife sold their house. Next month they plan to move into a condo, knocking down their mortgage payment by thousands of dollars. Even after downsizing, Greco said, he simply can’t retire as he wishes. There’s the condo mortgage and other debt he must pay.

So instead, he plans to gradually work less. A day after his 66th birthday he began working half-days on Fridays. In five years, he hopes to have paid down the condo loan enough to allow him to take only cases that interest him.

AlertMe

Suggested on ABQjournal

Advertisement

TOP |