Editorial: U.S. must defend itself, but torture is not the way - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: U.S. must defend itself, but torture is not the way

“That’s not who we are.”

– President Barack Obama

The Senate Intelligence Committee’s torture report released Tuesday details the depths to which the Central Intelligence Agency reached in its efforts to coerce terror suspects to reveal secrets and potential plots against the United States in the wake of the 911 attacks.

And Obama is correct: That’s not what America is.

Indeed, the shocking report discloses what will certainly go down as a dark and hidden period in U.S. history. It gives the U.S. a black eye in the world community and our enemies ammunition for retaliation – not that they ever seem to need any reasons.

Interrogation tactics such as waterboarding, sleep deprivation and tight confinement were authorized by the Justice Department in 2002. But, the report says, CIA tactics went beyond what was approved by former President George W. Bush. It says the CIA misled top U.S. officials and Congress about the full extent of its treatment of detainees and the effectiveness of the program. The CIA did not brief Bush with details until 2006, the report says.

Some Republicans and current and former CIA directors say the tactics did help stop attacks here and abroad, capture terrorists and save American lives.

But that raises the troubling question posed by the debate: Does success derived from immoral acts make those acts moral? The answer is no, which is why Americans should find them revolting. Which is why they are not who we are. Or at least not who we aspire to be.

Still, at its core, the 525-page summary of a classified, 6,700-page investigation raises questions of how a society that functions under rules and laws can protect itself from ideological groups that have none and are bent on our destruction. Militants operating under a perverted view of Islam – al-Qaida then and Islamic State now – openly torture, behead and commit suicide in acts of mass murder.

The report shows that Americans are due for honest, thoughtful, nonpartisan discussion on modern warfare. This should not only cover enhanced interrogation (torture), but also targeted killings (assassination) and new technologies such as drones and robots that often kill and maim “innocents” in the area of the target. While Obama and many supporters say they abhor the former, they embrace the latter.

As a nation we must reach some consensus on the moral issues surrounding the War on Terror, and that’s what it is, separate from the heat of battle or the emotions that naturally follow an unprovoked attack.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Editorial: MLK was more than his famous 'Dream' speech
Editorials
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was ... Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was a master of the soaring rhetoric of the conscience. His most thought- ...
2
Editorial: Governor, lawmakers have opportunity to join forces and ...
Editorials
There's not a lot of talk ... There's not a lot of talk in Santa Fe these days about expunging criminal records. Or legalizi ...
3
Editorial: Election changes not ready for prime time
Editorials
Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham and Secretary ... Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham and Secretary of State Maggie Toulouse Oliver are using this upcoming le ...
4
Editorial: ABQ's taxpayers need accountability for homeless dollars
Editorials
HopeWorks owes it to its current ... HopeWorks owes it to its current and prospective clients, as well as city taxpayers, to get its paperwork in order and justify specific program ...
5
Editorial: Proposed discipline seems severe for lawyer's comments
Editorials
The state Supreme Court is set ... The state Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments today, Wednesday, as to whether a high-profile ...
6
Editorial: Work out the details on COVID tests, masks
Editorials
"My body my choice" does not ... "My body my choice" does not work with a highly infectious disease. Ditching masks, tests and vaccines is petulant at best, deadly at worst.
7
Editorial: Legislators should focus windfall on making our state's ...
Editorials
Last week the Legislative Finance Committee ... Last week the Legislative Finance Committee and the Governor's Office released dueling spendin ...
8
Editorial: As in mosque fires, public can help get ...
Editorials
Before his 7-year-old son, Pronoy Bhattacharya, ... Before his 7-year-old son, Pronoy Bhattacharya, was killed by a hit-and-run ATV outside the River of ...
9
Editorial: We must learn from the facts of Jan. ...
Editorials
A year ago today, we witnessed ... A year ago today, we witnessed what many historians and political scientists regard as the biggest t ...