Evaluations give teachers more data - Albuquerque Journal

Evaluations give teachers more data

When New Mexico teachers receive their state-issued evaluations in the coming days, they’ll notice much more detail than last year, when they were rolled out in what turned to be a rocky debut.

The Public Education Department made the evaluations available to principals on Monday and school districts can decide when to distribute them to teachers.

In Albuquerque Public Schools, teachers are expected to receive their evaluations today, spokesman Rigo Chavez said.

New Mexico overhauled its teacher evaluation system last year and, for the first time, issued teacher evaluations based in part on student test scores, a policy that many teachers and some local school officials opposed. They have argued the evaluations don’t accurately measure teacher performance and rely too much on tests.

The PED this year, in response to complaints that teachers didn’t fully understand how ratings were generated, beefed up the evaluation reports with more information.

While teachers previously received a one-page evaluation report, this year the report will be five pages and show how teachers were rated in each of the evaluation categories, including student test scores, principal observations, teacher attendance and student surveys.

“We’ve never had details like this before,” Education Secretary Hanna Skandera said. “It should be a driver for instruction and getting effective teachers in the right places and for supporting those who are struggling.”

It remains to be seen, however, whether the more detailed evaluations will make them more popular among teachers or succeed in helping teachers better understand how they work.

Wilson Middle School Principal Ann Piper hasn’t given her teachers their evaluations yet but said she believes many will remain skeptical.

“My hunch is that it makes the teachers feel like there is more smoke and mirrors,” Piper said.

The PED has provided principals with webinars to instruct them on how to explain evaluations to teachers, Skandera said, adding that she hopes principals walk teachers through the findings and explain how they can be used.

Of the 20,500 teachers rated statewide this year, 73.8 percent rated effective or better on their evaluations, according to Public Education Department data.

That’s down 4.4 percentage points compared with last year, when 78.2 percent of teachers rated effective or better.

At APS, 72.14 percent of the district’s faculty scored effective or better this year, compared with 82.3 percent last year.

Under New Mexico’s teacher evaluation system, test scores carry the most weight, accounting for 50 percent of a teacher’s rating.

The PED uses three years of test scores and calculations, called value-added models, to measure student progress and gauge how much teachers are contributing to student learning.

Value-added models can tease out demographic factors, like poverty, and assess the impact a teacher is having on his or her students, PED officials say.

Critics of the evaluations argue the value-added models don’t in fact accurately measure a teacher’s impact on classroom learning.

The second-biggest category is observation by principals, which in most cases makes up 40 percent of teachers’ scores. The other 10 percent is based on measures that vary by school district but often include teacher attendance or student surveys.

Teachers who are found to be “ineffective” or “minimally effective” are put on performance growth plans under the state’s evaluation system.

Skandera announced in 2012 that the Public Education Department would overhaul New Mexico’s teacher evaluation system by administrative rule, and that the evaluations would rely heavily on student test scores.

Previously, attempts by Gov. Susana Martinez and state Republican lawmakers to pass a law overhauling the evaluation system failed.

Teacher unions in New Mexico have strongly criticized the evaluations and have filed lawsuits to overturn the system. Some local school officials have also been highly critical of the evaluations.

Compounding teacher confusion over the new evaluations last year was that many teachers found errors in their ratings.

Skandera has said the errors were caused by bad data submitted to the state by local school districts. The PED and local districts worked throughout the year to correct the errors, and the department has put in place new safeguards this year to make sure the data used in the evaluations are sound, Skandera has said.

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Evaluations give teachers more data


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Teachers union declares impasse after divided APS board puts ...
ABQnews Seeker
Despite five months of negotiations, the ... Despite five months of negotiations, the Albuquerque Public Schools board tabled changes to the district's negotiated agreement with the local teachers union in an ...
2
NM judge orders Eastman to appear before Georgia grand ...
ABQnews Seeker
A state judge has ordered Santa ... A state judge has ordered Santa Fe attorney John Eastman to appear before a special grand jury in Georgia this month as part of ...
3
Massachusetts-based foam fabricator expanding into ABQ
ABQnews Seeker
A Massachusetts-based foam fabricator is bringing ... A Massachusetts-based foam fabricator is bringing jobs to Albuquerque in an expansion announced on T ...
4
Gallup couple awarded more than $116,000 in back wages
ABQnews Seeker
A Gallup couple claimed a major ... A Gallup couple claimed a major legal victory this month after a judge ordered their former employer ...
5
Forest Service reseeding wildfire burn scar
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's fire season has been ... New Mexico's fire season has been particularly destructive this year. Now, help is on the way from above. The U.S. Forest Service is using ...
6
BlueHalo opens new facility near Kirtland
ABQnews Seeker
the latest addition to the local ... the latest addition to the local space industry. Virginia-based engineering firm BlueHalo LLC opened a 73,000 research and development, manufacturing and office space within ...
7
Former nonprofit treasurer pleads guilty to embezzlement
ABQnews Seeker
A former treasurer of the West ... A former treasurer of the West Central Community Development Group pleaded guilty Wednesday to embezzlement for stealing nearly $49,000 from the nonprofit over a ...
8
NM lawmakers turn budget focus to preventing child abuse
ABQnews Seeker
Far fewer children in New Mexico's ... Far fewer children in New Mexico's child protection system receive services intended to prevent maltreatment from their families than the national average — a ...
9
Woman dead, men critically injured in NE ABQ crash
ABQnews Seeker
A woman is dead and two ... A woman is dead and two men are in critical condition following a two-vehicle crash early Thursday morning in Northeast Albuquerque. Albuquerque police spokeswoman ...