'Uncounseled' convictions a threat to Indians - Albuquerque Journal

‘Uncounseled’ convictions a threat to Indians

The fairness of federal sentencing is an issue dividing many who care about justice in Indian country, not just my University of New Mexico law faculty colleagues Barbara Creel and Kevin Washburn (“Are feds too tough? Or is New Mexico too soft?” — Jan. 24).

The Supreme Court is now poised to address a key issue in the debate: whether a tribal court conviction that did not give the Indian defendant representation by a lawyer can be used to increase the sentence when the Indian is later prosecuted on a federal domestic assault charge.

The issue arises because as “domestic dependent nations,” tribes are free from the constraints of the Constitution unless Congress provides otherwise. Congress did so in 1968, passing the Indian Civil Rights Act.

Yet despite later reforms, ICRA still does not require that tribal-court defendants be given government-paid lawyers, a disparity that raises constitutional concerns when federal prosecutors argue these “uncounseled” convictions should be used against Indians later charged with other crimes.

Of course, Congress could fix this problem by funding tribal programs giving defendants adequate legal representation. Such support is part of Congress’s historic “trust responsibility” to Indian tribes.

But until Congress acts, tribal sovereignty and Indian rights remain at stake.

In the past, tribes have fought against legal theories and policy maneuvers that threatened to condemn a disproportionate number of Indians to long sentences in federal prison, or even the death penalty.

The 1883 Ex parte Crow Dog decision, for example, is praised by Indian rights advocates as a victory for tribal sovereignty, precisely because the Supreme Court refused to impose federal jurisdiction on a tribal member accused of crime on a reservation.

Likewise, imposition of the Major Crimes Act two years later, in defiance of the court’s decision, is widely denounced as a defeat for Indian rights and an attack on tribal sovereignty.

Today, the issue is clouded by arguments about the need for aggressive law enforcement to deal with domestic violence in Indian country. It’s unclear, therefore, whether the call for tough federal sentences for Indians accused of domestic assault will again spawn a decision harming tribal sovereignty and rationalizing discrimination in the name of protecting Indians from themselves.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » ‘Uncounseled’ convictions a threat to Indians

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories




Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages

 

Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
1
Editorial: Remember there are 2 sides to increases in ...
Editorials
From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers and ... From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers and the governor should seriously consider the impact of bills that would raise the minimum wage.
2
New Mexico congressional reps assigned spots on high-profile committees
ABQnews Seeker
State's 'unique and vital role' in ... State's 'unique and vital role' in national security noted
3
Citizen committee deciding what Albuquerque mayor, councilors should earn
ABQnews Seeker
The Citizens' Independent Salary Commission has ... The Citizens' Independent Salary Commission has begun its biennial process to set pay for the Albuquerque mayor and city councilors. Here's how the commission ...
4
Who are the city of Albuquerque's highest-paid employees?
ABQnews Seeker
When it comes to Albuquerque city ... When it comes to Albuquerque city worker paychecks, nobody tops first responders.
5
Documentary looks at connections between women and Route 66
ABQnews Seeker
'Route 66: The Untold Story of ... 'Route 66: The Untold Story of Women on the Mother Road' will be shown in Gallup on Thursday, Feb. 2, and in Albuquerque on ...
6
Editorial: NM can’t afford to go backward on government ...
Editorials
From the Editorial Board: The Inspection ... From the Editorial Board: The Inspection of Public Records Act has a presumption that citizens are entitled to the greatest possible amount of information ...
7
We need to enact omnibus crime and gun law ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs ... OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs the 1-2 punch of an omnibus bill focused on harsher penalties and gun-control measures.
8
Tribal Remedy Framework addresses systemic inequities
From the newspaper
OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach ... OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach to improve educational outcomes for Native youth.
9
Dollars alone won't solve New Mexico's problems
From the newspaper
OPINION: The current system of distributing ... OPINION: The current system of distributing capital outlay funds needs an overhaul if we want those dollars to do the most good.