Editorial: Ditching arbitration clause won't benefit consumers - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Ditching arbitration clause won’t benefit consumers

Sounds like a good idea, but not so much when you dig deeper.

People who have complaints with banks that issue credit cards would be able to sue over disputes instead of going to arbitration under a proposed rule issued by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Consumers who didn’t read the fine print when they signed up for a card might think that being able to take the bank to court will benefit them. Probably not. The real beneficiaries would be trial lawyers who will aggressively recruit people to join class action lawsuits that typically don’t do much for members of the class but result in huge attorney fees for the lawyers. Ka-ching!

Most of you probably have received some kind of class action settlement proposal where you really don’t get anything but eye strain from reading print that’s even smaller than the fonts on your credit card statement.

And guess who will foot the bill for big awards against the banks over what most people would regard as minor transgressions – like not being clear enough that paying over time will result in higher interest charges? The consumers. Banks would simply pass along settlement costs and legal fees to fight the lawsuits to credit card holders and bank account owners.

The proposed rule change, which is in a 90-day public comment period, would cover new agreements for credit cards, auto loans, credit reports and even mobile phone services that provide third-party billing. Companies could still include arbitration clauses in contracts, but they would have to state they cannot be used to stop consumers from joining a class-action case. Not surprisingly, the banking industry is opposed to the rule, saying it could produce frivolous lawsuits and cost consumers in the long run. Banks and credit unions are expected to challenge it.

While the rule may be well-intentioned – it sounds democratic that people can take grievances to court – this would be a bad move for consumers and bankers.

And it’s not like there is no course of redress for consumers. They do have arbitration available, already can file complaints with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and state attorney general’s offices have consumer protection divisions.

Of course, a simpler solution would be to just say no to credit cards and running up debt. What a novel idea.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Election Guide

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Ditching arbitration clause won’t benefit consumers


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: Do you know what your kids are watching?
Editorials
A New Mexico lawsuit is one ... A New Mexico lawsuit is one of six in the country targeting TikTok as a result of "blackout ch ...
2
Editorial: Young Shiprock poet shines in D.C. spotlight
Editorials
It's a long way from Shiprock ... It's a long way from Shiprock to Washington, D.C.    Jesse Begay got there on t ...
3
Editorial: Want better educational outcomes? Start with getting students ...
Editorials
Woody Allen once said 80% of ... Woody Allen once said 80% of success in life is just showing up. In no setting is this durable conce ...
4
Editorial: NM GOP needs to explain doctored mailer
Editorials
An altered stock image of darkened ... An altered stock image of darkened hands cutting a white child's hair sure does appear to play ...
5
Editorial: Navajo project brings clean water for all a ...
Editorials
Imagine having to rely on hand-pumped ... Imagine having to rely on hand-pumped wells, windmills, earth dams and snowdrifts to gather enough w ...
6
Editorial: Enough disinformation; our elections are secure
Editorials
With the fall general election just ... With the fall general election just over a month away, it bears repeating New Mexico elections are a ...
7
Editorial: Best fiesta commute? Let the pros drive
Editorials
Two things happen in Albuquerque every ... Two things happen in Albuquerque every October: The balloon fiesta delivers fantasy. And the traffic ...
8
Editorial: NM needs leaders who will tackle real water ...
Editorials
Bankruptcy, Ernest Hemingway famously wrote, comes ... Bankruptcy, Ernest Hemingway famously wrote, comes "gradually, then suddenly."  &nb ...
9
Editorial: Crime's unrelenting hold
Editorials
... ...