Dispute over New Mexico Hatch chile labeling heats up - Albuquerque Journal

Dispute over New Mexico Hatch chile labeling heats up

SANTA FE, N.M. — A federal appeals court has sided with a green chile growers group in southern New Mexico’s Hatch Valley in a dispute over what food can be labeled with the renowned Hatch name.

The U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday ruled in favor of the Hatch Chile Association and allied Albuquerque food distributor El Encanto in their efforts to subpoena records that may indicate whether a rival’s products contain purely Hatch-grown chile as marketing suggests.

The subpoenas could influence the outcome of a related dispute before a federal trademark board over efforts by the Hatch Chile Co. to trademark the term “Hatch” for its exclusive use.

The written court decision pays tribute to the winding desert Hatch Valley for “producing some of the world’s finest chile peppers,” venturing that the area “may be to chiles what Napa is to grapes.”

Reversing a district court ruling, a three-judge panel noted Hatch Chile Co. initially said it did not know where its chiles came from, and directed questions to supplier Mizkan Americas, the owner of Border Foods and its southern New Mexico chile processing plants.

When a subpoena was issued to Mizkan asking about the provenance of its green chile, both Hatch Chile Co. and Mizkan filed successful motions to block the request in federal court.

“This seemingly mild dispute turned hot during discovery,” the judges wrote. “After seeming to encourage El Encanto to ask its suppliers for just this information, Hatch Chile filed a motion seeking a protective order.”

El Encanto does business under the Bueno Foods label.

Ross Perkal, an attorney for Hatch Chile Co., declined to comment on the ruling, citing pending litigation.

Hatch Chile Association board member Preston Mitchell applauded the ruling as a possible step toward reserving the Hatch name for chiles that can be traced to the Hatch Valley through a shared certification process. The association is seeking a certification mark for Hatch chile to help consumers verify the source.

Home » Business » Most Recent Biz News » Dispute over New Mexico Hatch chile labeling heats up


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
NM expands help with filling court forms
ABQnews Seeker
Court-scribe program helps people understand and ... Court-scribe program helps people understand and complete documents
2
The PED is asking for feedback on its new ...
ABQnews Seeker
Proposed are several rule changes to ... Proposed are several rule changes to implement the system, known as micro-credentials
3
A DEADLY YEAR
ABQnews Seeker
Montaño shooting marks record 115th homicide ... Montaño shooting marks record 115th homicide in city
4
Spelling bee competitors master craft one word at a ...
ABQnews Seeker
Favorite books help bee competitors get ... Favorite books help bee competitors get ready
5
PNM struggles with rising fuel cost issues
ABQnews Seeker
But customer fuel prices are expected ... But customer fuel prices are expected to decrease significantly in January
6
Santa Fe Opera wins international recognition as 'Festival of ...
ABQnews Seeker
The International Opera Awards named the ... The International Opera Awards named the artistic nucleus just north of Santa Fe 'Festival of the Year' at a ceremony in Madrid, Spain.
7
Talking Grammer, Ep. 55: UNM Lobo coach Richard Pitino
ABQnews Seeker
In episode 55 of the podcast, ... In episode 55 of the podcast, we catch up with UNM Lobo basketball coach Richard Pitino on what has been a unique first month ...
8
Pearce wins reelection as NM GOP chairman through 2024
2022 election
Fends off 4 challengers with 55% ... Fends off 4 challengers with 55% of votes cast
9
Rain can't stop the twinkling lights
ABQnews Seeker
ABQ's annual Twinkle Light Parade puts ... ABQ's annual Twinkle Light Parade puts a shine on Central Avenue, Nob Hill