NM Chief Justice Daniels backs bail reform amendment - Albuquerque Journal

NM Chief Justice Daniels backs bail reform amendment

RUIDOSO – New Mexico’s top judge hopes voters notice a proposed constitutional amendment on the November ballot that offers them a better chance to strike a blow for liberty and justice than any other vote they may cast.

The amendment would let criminal court judges order dangerous defendants held without bond before trial, and make it less likely that low-risk defendants are forced to wait in jail for their trials only because they’re too poor to bond out.

“There is nothing I’ve done or will do on the court that is going to be a more important improvement of justice than getting this amendment passed,” said New Mexico Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles W. Daniels in an interview here Saturday.

Daniels said he is speaking to as many groups as he can around the state to urge support for the amendment. He plans a major address on the subject next month to the New Mexico Bar Association. He spoke to the News while relaxing Saturday at his second home here.

“The unthinking reaction that putting a pricetag on getting out of jail protects somebody is wrong,” Daniels said. “It’s wrong in theory, and it’s wrong in reality.”

The New Mexico Constitution currently requires that nearly every non-capital defendant be granted bail, even those who pose a known threat to witnesses, family members or potential victims of fresh crimes.

Daniels said many judges facing a clearly dangerous defendant but forbidden to deny bail outright will set extremely high bail in hopes the defendant won’t be able to post it. But some do “scrape up the fee,” Daniels said, and in any event the same constitution that requires that bail be set also requires that it not be “excessive.”

“So judges either protect the community or they follow the law,” Daniels said. “They should never have to make that choice.”

The other side of the issue, Daniels said, is that courts have been setting high bail amounts based on the severity of the crime charged, even when the defendant isn’t dangerous and poses little risk of failing to show up for trial.

“Neither the Constitution nor our rules of criminal procedure permit a judge to base a pretrial release decision solely on the severity of the charged offense,” Daniels wrote in a 2014 court opinion. “Bail is not pretrial punishment and is not to be set solely on the basis of an accusation of a serious crime”

That case, New Mexico v. Brown, was what first drew Daniels’s attention to the need for bail reform in state courts, a national movement which has been gathering momentum for more than half a century.

It was a murder case in which lawyers for the defendant were appealing a $250,000 bond that the district court had refused to reduce, even though the judge accepted the convincing evidence that the defendant posed no threat or flight risk.

The state Supreme Court ordered the district court to set “appropriate nonmonetary conditions” of release, and Daniels took the opportunity in his 21-page opinion to trace the origins of New Mexico’s constitutional bail provisions and point out their drawbacks.

The proposed amendment would allow a judge to deny bail to a felony defendant on “clear and convincing evidence that no release conditions will reasonably protect the safety of any other person or the community.”

It would also require that a defendant who is neither dangerous nor a flight risk “shall not be detained solely because of financial inability to post a money or property bond.”

Daniels said the amendment hasn’t drawn much vocal opposition yet, but he expects there will be some from the bail bond industry, which has fought bail reform in other states and tried to bottle up the New Mexico ballot proposal in the legislature earlier this year.

The new president of Professional Bail Agents of the United States, former reality television star Beth Chapman of “Dog and Beth: On the Hunt,” recently declared war on bail reform.

“Any reform in any of the states is a threat to them nationally,” Daniels said.

——

©2016 the Ruidoso News (Ruidoso, N.M.)

Visit the Ruidoso News (Ruidoso, N.M.) at www.ruidosonews.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

_____


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Finding redemption in prison
ABQnews Seeker
Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope ... Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope to peers
2
Investigation into officer's death a 'slap in the face,' ...
ABQnews Seeker
NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted ... NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted suspect during traffic stop on Feb. 4
3
'Honest' Martínez rises in ranks to House leadership
ABQnews Seeker
Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, ... Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, cannabis and tax rates
4
New approach to teaching race in school divides NM
ABQnews Seeker
Students would learn about social identity ... Students would learn about social identity under new plan
5
Lawsuit says Belen firefighter fired for reporting COVID-19 case
ABQnews Seeker
Man believes he was terminated for ... Man believes he was terminated for notifying human resources of sick co-worker
6
GOP leader has 'no regrets' for Trump certificate
ABQnews Seeker
Law enforcement is looking into an ... Law enforcement is looking into an election-related document
7
Attorneys say jail could not find inmates for hearings
ABQnews Seeker
Bernalillo County: No one has gotten ... Bernalillo County: No one has gotten lost in the detention system
8
NM's GOP files lawsuit over new congressional map
ABQnews Seeker
Suit asks judge to replace new ... Suit asks judge to replace new boundaries with a map proposed by the Citizen Redistricting Commit
9
APD investigates 2 homicides over several hours
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Police Department's Homicide Unit is ... Albuquerque Police Department's Homicide Unit is investigating after a dead body was discovere ...
10
COVID tests out there ... somewhere
ABQnews Seeker
Testing shortages are unnerving the public Testing shortages are unnerving the public