Snapchat app causes racial offense, again - Albuquerque Journal

Snapchat app causes racial offense, again

Last week, Snapchat lost face.

The company, whose messaging app is hugely popular among young smartphone users, introduced a face-warping filter that transformed users into slant-eyed, buck-toothed, East Asian caricatures. The feature was meant to be “playful,” not offensive, the company said, in a statement. But after vocal protests by Asian-Americans and others on social media, the filter, having been up for only one day, was swiftly disabled.

Snapchat claimed the lens was intended as an homage to anime. But to true anime fans, that explanation rung hollow. Anime characters traditionally have round, oversized eyes like those of the early Disney cartoons that inspired them. The Snapchat caricatures did not.

A previous Snapchat “homage” to Bob Marley was criticized as digital blackface. How odd that the company would move on to “yellowface”, in effect making the same mistake twice.

Racial caricature is a visual stereotype, an exaggeration often invoked in the service of satire. Aristotle noted that comedy “is an imitation of inferior things and people.” Ethnic Halloween costumes and American Indian mascots like the Cleveland Indians’ Chief Wahoo distort iconic physical features or other visual markers of difference for comic effect.

Snapchat’s lens was, no doubt, a visual joke made at the expense of Asian-Americans. A specific type of humor, its pleasure lies in producing feelings of dominance or superiority. As Freud notes in “Jokes and their Relation to the Unconscious,” enjoyment is derived from “making our enemy small, inferior, despicable or comic.”

As psychologists have documented, repeated exposure to racial stereotypes also impacts the mental health of people of color.

Snapchat took quick action. But that does not explain its faux pas. Multiple media outlets pointed to the tech industry’s lack of diversity, suggesting that if people of color were better represented, there would be greater awareness of offensive imagery.

This is a fair assumption. But greater representation is only part of the fix.

We need to get to the heart of why caricatures and stereotypes keep coming up. Before young children understand the racial-ethnic categories invoked by adults, they are most likely to classify people first by racial features, second by gender and third by clothing.

Differences seen on the body are thus “psychologically privileged” as a means of sorting people. But how do we come to affix positive or negative associations to those classifications? Simply, we are more likely to invoke group categories when individual behaviors converge with existing social biases.

In this moment of highly publicized racial violence and talk of building a wall, a Snapchat protest may seem trivial. But it’s not. Racial caricatures share the same root as racial profiling. They both reduce individuals to types that serve as sources of pleasure or fear.

As a culture, we can and are evolving. Can Snapchat users recall Chinese Cherry or Injun Orange drink mixes? The Frito Bandito? They are relics of the past. In this new digital age of bodily flexibility and playful self-imagining, let’s keep them there.

Leslie Bow is a professor of English and Asian-American Studies at the University of Wisconsin at Madison. She wrote this for Progressive Media Project, a source of liberal commentary affiliated with The Progressive magazine. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Snapchat app causes racial offense, again


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Caja del Rio is teeming with wide open spaces ...
Arts
Covering more than 104,000 acres, Caja ... Covering more than 104,000 acres, Caja del Rio is rife with history.
2
Man Ray muse takes center stage in biography
Arts
Her name was Alice Prin, but ... Her name was Alice Prin, but she was better known in the bohemian world of 1920s Paris as Kiki de Montparnasse
3
Exhibition looks at works inspired by the vistas of ...
Arts
'New Beginnings: An American Story of ... 'New Beginnings: An American Story of Romantics and Modernists in the West' showcases 127 works created from the late 1800-1900s at the Harwood Museum ...
4
The Complete Works of Shakespeare (Abrig'd) hits Albuquerque Little ...
Arts
'The Complete Works of William Shakespeare ... 'The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abrig'd)' returns to the Albuquerque Little Theatre at 224 San Pasquale Ave. SW.
5
Taos Abstract Artist Collective debuts inaugural exhibition
Arts
The group will show its first ... The group will show its first exhibition from Sept. 2-10 at the Stables Gallery at the Taos Center for the Arts.
6
Guild Cinema screening short film inspired by '90s horror ...
Arts
'Quiet Hours' will screen at the ... 'Quiet Hours' will screen at the Guild Cinema at 1 p.m. Sunday, Aug. 21.
7
Pulling out weeds by the root key to keeping ...
Arts
Bindweed and common purslane spotting in ... Bindweed and common purslane spotting in ABQ backyard
8
Visit Las Cruces puts out a call for artist(s) ...
Arts
Visit Las Cruces is looking for ... Visit Las Cruces is looking for an artist or artist group to submit proposals for the design and installation of a permanent exterior mural.
9
'Eyeshine' showing at Harwood with 'Holy Land' through Sept. ...
Arts
Adrian Pijoan will show his work ... Adrian Pijoan will show his work at the Harwood Art Center through Sept. 15. Organizers paired his work with 'Holy Land' by Diego Medina.