PNM skewers hearing examiner in rate case filing - Albuquerque Journal

PNM skewers hearing examiner in rate case filing

Public Service Company of New Mexico has filed a formal objection to a state hearing examiner’s recommendation in an increasingly contentious utility rate case.

PNM declined to comment for this story. But in a document filed with the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission Wednesday, PNM said hearing examiner Carolyn Glick ignored “facts, law, and commission precedent” in her decision to exclude several nuclear power transactions from PNM’s rate base, as well as an investment in air pollution controls at the coal-powered San Juan Generating Station that some called excessive.

“Adopting these unsupported findings, along with the recommendation that PNM ‘try again’ in its next proceeding, would be unlawful, arbitrary, and financially destructive,” PNM said in the filing.

The exclusions accounted for the majority of the difference between Glick’s $41.3 million recommended annual revenue increase and PNM’s $123.5 requested increase. PNM customers would on average see their bills increase by 14.4 percent under the utility’s proposal instead of 6.4 percent under Glick’s.

Glick has said it is not appropriate for her to comment in the middle of a rate case. In her recommended decision, she said PNM had acted “imprudently” by purchasing 64.1 megawatts of nuclear power from the Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station and extending several leases there without conducting an appropriate cost-benefit analysis. PNM maintains their analysis was sufficient.

The Palo Verde transactions were made in part to replace power lost from a partial closure of San Juan. The closure was part of an agreement between PNM and the Environmental Protection Agency aimed at reducing air pollution in the Four Corners area.

In their most recent filing, PNM railed against what they perceived to be Glick’s “legally and factually unsupported conclusions” and “punitive tone.” PNM argued there is a legal precedent for the commission to allow for cost recovery in the absence of “serious doubt” about a transaction’s reasonableness, which PNM claims is the case for the costs Glick excluded from the rate base.

PNM took particular issue with Glick’s exclusion of the Palo Verde transactions, which it called “so obviously reasonable,” arguing at length that it was not required to consider alternatives to replacing the lost San Juan energy with nuclear power under current statute. The utility also said a PRC adoption of Glick’s recommendation would have serious repurcussions for similar businesses throughout the state.

“If allowed to stand, the (recommended decision) sends a troubling message, not only to PNM, but to all of the utilities in New Mexico, that the Commission need not, and will not, consider whether its decisions cause financial harm to the utility,” PNM wrote in the filing.

The Rio Grande Foundation, a free market think tank, and the New Mexico Business Coalition, a pro-business advocacy organization, echoed PNM’s sentiment in a recent email warning of the potential impact of “radical environmentalists” on the PRC. The email asked recipients to sign a petition to the PRC in support of nuclear power.

Two of the nine intervening parties in the case that filed supplemental briefs on the Palo Verde transactions recommended complete exclusion of these events from the rate base: New Energy Economy, an environmental advocacy organization, and the Albuquerque Bernalillo County Water Utility Authority. Both said PNM had not provided sufficient financial analysis to show the purchase was reasonable.

In a PRC meeting Wednesday, several individuals, including PRC commissioner Pat Lyons, publicly accused Glick of being biased against nuclear power, an accusation Glick denied. The encounter became heated enough that PRC Chairwoman Valerie Espinoza intervened several times on Glick’s behalf.

PNM has said if the commission adopts Glick’s proposal unchanged, it will sell off its interests in Palo Verde, leading to more reliance on coal- and gas-powered energy sources. The company has also said it will immediately appeal the decision to the state Supreme Court, and likely lay off up to 300 employees if the decision remains unchanged.

The PRC is expected to make their decision in the rate case by Aug. 31.

Home » Business » Energy » PNM skewers hearing examiner in rate case filing

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
It's here: Tesla opens second New Mexico location
ABQnews Seeker
The Tesla facility, which sits just ... The Tesla facility, which sits just northwest of the Santa Ana Star Casino, is the second in New Mexico. In 2021, the electric vehicle ...
Circle K offering gas discount today in Albuquerque: 40 ...
ABQnews Seeker
Today only: Circle K has announced ... Today only: Circle K has announced that it will offer 40 cents off per gallon of fuel between 4 and 7 p.m. at Albuquerque ...
As India's electrical grid strains, rural hospitals and clinics ...
RAICHUR, India (AP) -- In the ... RAICHUR, India (AP) -- In the searing heat that often envelops Raichur, an ancient town in southern India, a ceiling fan that spins without ...
Some companies unhappy with RFP process for New Mexico’s ...
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's community solar program attracted ... New Mexico's community solar program attracted hundreds of bids from local and out-of-state companies, but some firms say bidding irregularities may have stacked the ...
Thousands of New Mexicans one step closer to having ...
ABQnews Seeker
State regulators greenlighted the first 200 ... State regulators greenlighted the first 200 megawatts of community solar generation this week, kicking off development of 45 projects that could include tens of ...
GOS Capital reports more 'PropTech' investment
ABQnews Seeker
When Goodman Realty Group's new 207-unit ... When Goodman Realty Group's new 207-unit apartment complex at Winrock Town Center in Uptown opens in early 2026, it will sport new technology to ...
New tech finding orphaned wells leaking methane in New ...
ABQnews Seeker
Across New Mexico and the entire ... Across New Mexico and the entire United States, hundreds of thousands of undocumented, orphaned oil-and-gas wells have the potential to pollute water and leak ...
ABQ Journal Biz Bits: Sandia Laboratory Federal Credit Union ...
ABQnews Seeker
Credit Union accepting scholarship applications    Sandia ... Credit Union accepting scholarship applications    Sandia Laboratory Federal Credit U ...
Pattern Energy signs up first SunZia customers
ABQnews Seeker
The University of California and Shell ... The University of California and Shell Energy signed agreements this month to purchase electricity from Pattern Energy’s massive SunZia transmission and wind-generation project when ...