High court to hear case on election law amendments - Albuquerque Journal

High court to hear case on election law amendments

SANTA FE – The state Supreme Court is taking another look at whether constitutional changes that got the OK from a majority of voters in previous years – but failed to reach the required 75 percent threshold – may actually be in effect.

The League of Women Voters first raised the question a year ago, but the court rejected its lawsuit.

Now the justices have decided to rehear the League’s challenge, which this time around has the backing of counties, disability rights advocates, Common Cause New Mexico and drug reform activists.

Arguments are scheduled before the court on Wednesday.

At issue are identical constitutional amendments from 2008 and 2014 that allowed school elections to be held in conjunction with other nonpartisan elections, and a 2010 amendment that removed the language prohibiting “idiots” and “insane persons” from voting.

The changes affect sections of the state Constitution that deal with voting and education and that require the approval of not just a majority, but three-fourths of those voting, to alter them.

The League argues that a separate provision of the Constitution makes it clear that the 75 percent rule was intended to protect rights. Because the constitutional changes not only protect rights, but enlarge them, only a majority vote is needed to change them, the League says.

“If we’re not restricting people’s voting rights, it seems to me a majority of the people ought to be able to expand the rights and modernize the language,” said state Sen. Daniel Ivey-Soto, D-Albuquerque, a lawyer and former state elections director who is representing the League.

The restriction in the 1910 Constitution that keeps school elections separate from other elections is rooted in the fact that, at the time, women were not allowed to vote except in school elections.

Meredith Machen, president of the League of Women Voters of New Mexico, says allowing school elections at the same time as other nonpartisan elections would save money and bolster turnout.

“Right now, the turnout for school board elections is a tiny percentage of the electorate,” she said.

The New Mexico Association of Counties said in a brief filed with the court that the current setup – a hodgepodge of local nonpartisan elections that are run or supported by county clerks – is chaotic and costly.

“Because consolidating nonpartisan elections as allowed by the amendment will improve efficiency and voter participation, it is strongly supported by the clerks,” the association said in its filing.

The 2010 amendment would have gotten rid of residency and age requirements for voting that have already been wiped out by other laws. And it would have removed the prohibition on voting by “idiots” and “insane persons.”

“The terms ‘idiots’ and ‘insane persons’ are offensive, stigmatizing and archaic,” the organization Disability Rights New Mexico argues in its brief. Removing that language from the Constitution “would be a significant step for New Mexico toward protecting individuals with mental disabilities from societal discrimination,” the organization said.

Under the 2010 amendment, the original language would have been replaced by a reference to “mental incapacity,” defined as being concurrently unable to mark a ballot and communicate a voting preference.

The same amendment also has the support of the Drug Policy Alliance, because it updates the language related to felons and voting, acknowledging that the Legislature – not just the governor – has the discretion to re-enfranchise those convicted of felonies.

The Legislature passed laws in 2001 and 2007 authorizing the restoration of voting rights to felons under certain conditions.

The lawsuit was filed against the Advisory Committee to the New Mexico Compilation Commission. The commission is in charge of compiling the state’s laws, and the League contends the advisory committee acts as its gatekeeper in that process.

But the Advisory Committee told the court that while the League’s lawsuit raises “important issues” for the court’s consideration, the League should instead have sued the State Canvassing Board – the governor, the Supreme Court chief justice and the secretary of state – because its job is to declare the results of state elections.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
APD: One dead in apparent homicide
2021 city election
Albuquerque police launched a homicide investigation ... Albuquerque police launched a homicide investigation early Monday morning after officers found a dead body. Officer Chase Jewell, a police spokesman, said that around ...
2
Former lobbyist finds new calling in cannabis
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque man gives up $90,000 salary ... Albuquerque man gives up $90,000 salary for local budding industry
3
18-year arrested in uncle's death
ABQnews Seeker
Copyright © 2022 Albuquerque Journal Albuquerque ... Copyright © 2022 Albuquerque Journal Albuquerque police detectives arrested Domenic Mora, 18, o ...
4
Two seriously injured in overnight car crashes
ABQnews Seeker
Two people received serious injuries in ... Two people received serious injuries in separate crashes in Albuquerque late Saturday and early Sunday morning, according to police. The first crash happened near ...
5
APD says man believed to have been struck by ...
ABQnews Seeker
The man shot near Montgomery and ... The man shot near Montgomery and Morningside around 2 a.m. Sunday morning was actually the same person believed to have been struck and killed ...
6
Downturn in blood donations concerns state hospitals
ABQnews Seeker
Shortages partly due to pandemic Shortages partly due to pandemic
7
Details emerge in wrongful arrest of teen for homicide
ABQnews Seeker
APD officer suspended after misidentifying murder ... APD officer suspended after misidentifying murder suspect
8
Council member states he, Keller discussed tax cuts
ABQnews Seeker
Mayor's office chides Lewis, but won't ... Mayor's office chides Lewis, but won't dispute claim
9
Man charged in fatal shooting of uncle
ABQnews Seeker
Court records say lack of internet ... Court records say lack of internet service sparked suspect's tantrum that led to shooting