Work rate for U.S. men a catastrophe - Albuquerque Journal

Work rate for U.S. men a catastrophe

WASHINGTON – The “quiet catastrophe” is particularly dismaying because it is so quiet, without social turmoil or even debate.

It is this: After 88 consecutive months of the economic expansion that began in June 2009, a smaller percentage of American males in the prime working years (ages 25 to 54) are working than were working near the end of the Great Depression in 1940, when the unemployment rate was above 14 percent.

If the labor force participation rate were as high today as it was as recently as 2000, nearly 10 million more Americans would have jobs.

The work rate for adult men has plunged 13 percentage points in a half-century. This “work deficit” of “Great Depression-scale underutilization” of male potential workers is the subject of Nicholas Eberstadt’s new monograph “Men Without Work: America’s Invisible Crisis,” which explores the economic and moral causes and consequences of this.

Since 1948, the proportion of men 20 and older without paid work has more than doubled, to almost 32 percent. This “eerie and radical transformation” – men creating an “alternative lifestyle to the age-old male quest for a paying job” – is largely voluntary. Men who have chosen to not seek work are two and a half times more numerous than those men that government statistics count as unemployed because they are seeking jobs.

What Eberstadt calls a “normative sea change” has made it a “viable option” for “sturdy men,” who are neither working nor looking for work, to choose “to sit on the economic sidelines, living off the toil or bounty of others.” Only about 15 percent of men 25 to 54 who worked not at all in 2014 said they were unemployed because they could not find work.

For 50 years, the number of men in that age cohort who are neither working nor looking for work has grown nearly four times faster than the number who are working or seeking work.

And the pace of this has been “almost totally uninfluenced by the business cycle.” The “economically inactive” have eclipsed the unemployed, as government statistics measure them, as “the main category of men without jobs.” Those statistics were created before government policy and social attitudes made it possible to be economically inactive.

In a 2012 monograph, Eberstadt noted that in 1960 there were 134 workers for every one officially certified as disabled; by 2010 there were just over 16. Between January 2010 and December 2011, while the economy produced 1.73 million nonfarm jobs, almost half as many workers became disability recipients. This, even though work is less stressful and the workplace is safer than ever.

Largely because of government benefits and support by other family members, nonworking men 25 to 54 have household expenditures a third higher than the average of those in the bottom income quintile. Eberstadt says, they “appear to be better off than tens of millions of other Americans today, including the millions of single mothers who are either working or seeking work.”

America’s economy is not less robust, and its welfare provisions not more generous, than those of the 22 other affluent nations of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.

In 1965, even high school dropouts were more likely to be in the workforce than is the 25 to 54 male today. And, Eberstadt notes, “the collapse of work for modern America’s men happened despite considerable upgrades in educational attainment.”

The collapse has coincided with a retreat from marriage, which suggests a broader infantilization. As does the use to which the voluntarily idle put their time – for example, watching TV and movies 5.5 hours daily, two hours more than men who are counted as unemployed because they are seeking work.

Copyright, Washington Post Writers Group


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
What to do when their time's up
Columnists
Unused or expired prescription medications and ... Unused or expired prescription medications and some over-the-counter medications are a public safety ...
2
Televised murder - reprised and, once again, revolting
Columnists
He's baaaack and on a TV ... He's baaaack and on a TV screen near you! Dexter, that wacky, seemingly affable character who ...
3
Is blue hydrogen the bridge to a greener future?
Columnists
If we want to quickly decarbonize ... If we want to quickly decarbonize shipping, semi-trucks, planes, steel, cement and other high-emissi ...
4
Shop early, local and skip supply-chain nightmares while supporting ...
Columnists
Shop early and local, and skip ... Shop early and local, and skip supply chain nightmares while supporting NM businesses
5
Online deals: If it's too good to be true ...
Columnists
Check for customer complaints and see ... Check for customer complaints and see if the customer service line is a working number
6
Lessons to be learned from Gabby, Britney media circuses
Columnists
I've been thinking a lot about ... I've been thinking a lot about the phrase "media circus" lately. I've heard ...
7
Voters have spoken; it's time to stop 'defund police' ...
Columnists
The voters have spoken. So now ... The voters have spoken. So now can we finally bury the insidiously foolish demand to "defund t ...
8
What kind of people do you want prison system ...
Columnists
Show of hands - how many ... Show of hands - how many readers believe the U.S. prison system truly works to rehabilitate con ...
9
Opportunities to adopt, foster and volunteer to help animals ...
Columnists
The animal shelters in the greater ... The animal shelters in the greater Albuquerque area are over capacity and seeking volunteers to help ...