High court looks askance at primary vote fix - Albuquerque Journal

High court looks askance at primary vote fix

By Deborah Baker

SANTA FE – A lawsuit aimed at opening up the Democratic and Republican primaries to voters who aren’t affiliated with those parties got a frosty reception Monday from the state Supreme Court.

The court heard arguments in a case brought by lawyer David Crum of Albuquerque, who says the state law prohibiting unaffiliated voters from casting ballots in primaries violates the state Constitution’s mandate that elections be “free and open.”

Crum, who registered as “decline to state” – New Mexico’s version of unaffiliated – sued after he was turned away from voting in the 2014 primary election.

“Nowhere in the Constitution is membership in a political party a requirement for voters in the state of New Mexico,” Crum’s lawyer, J. Edward Hollington, told the court.

The Constitution’s protection of the right to vote doesn’t make a distinction between primary and general elections, he argued, but nearly 240,000 unaffiliated voters were denied that right in the 2014 primary.

According to the lawsuit, nearly 60 percent of legislative, county-level and judicial races were decided in that primary because there were no general election contests for those offices.

Because the parties’ nominees are chosen in publicly financed elections – instead of, for example, party conventions – qualified voters can’t be excluded, Hollington also said.

But the justices appeared skeptical, peppering him with questions about the potential impact of overturning the current law.

“How would that not encourage mischief?” Justice Barbara Vigil asked.

Chief Justice Charles Daniels suggested that a party’s primary results could be skewed by unaffiliated voters “in order to nominate an unelectable candidate.”

“Isn’t that a problem? … Isn’t that a rational possibility?” Daniels said.

John Anderson, a lawyer for the Republican Party of New Mexico, told the court that open primaries could erode the ideological underpinnings of the parties and make party labels less reliable.

“A political party has the right to have its standard-bearer selected by its members. … That is certainly a legitimate legislative objective,” Anderson said.

The Office of the Attorney General agreed with the Republican Party that the Legislature was within its authority to restrict primaries to party members, and that forcing political parties to open primaries would infringe on their associational rights under the First Amendment – an argument the GOP made in state District Court that led the court to dismiss Crum’s lawsuit.

The AG intervened in the case to defend the state law after the Secretary of State’s Office, which was sued, declined to take a position.

The Supreme Court did not make an immediate decision in the case.

Former state Rep. Bob Perls, founder of New Mexico Open Primaries and a supporter of Crum’s lawsuit, said his organization plans to propose at least two versions of open-primary bills during the 2017 legislative session.

One would allow decline-to-state voters to participate in major parties’ primaries, and the other would create a system of nonpartisan registration and voting in which the top two vote-getters would go to the general election.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Group urges revision to medical malpractice law
ABQnews Seeker
Providers say they may close over ... Providers say they may close over insurance issue
Avangrid and NY firm swap allegations in separate lawsuits
ABQnews Seeker
Connecticut-based energy company Avangrid and New ... Connecticut-based energy company Avangrid and New York-based Security Limits Inc. have each filed se ...
Legislature eyes stimulus package
ABQnews Seeker
NM lawmakers weigh $462 million plan ... NM lawmakers weigh $462 million plan to spend federal relief funds
Fiebelkorn, Grout win City Council runoffs
2021 city election
Democrats will maintain their majority on ... Democrats will maintain their majority on the Albuquerque City Council, but their edge will be slimmer come 2022. Democrat Tammy Fiebelkorn and Republican Renee ...
State accepting more types of cannabis license applications
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's Cannabis Control Division announced ... New Mexico's Cannabis Control Division announced Tuesday that it is now accepting license applications for all cannabis-business types, including manufacturing and retail.
APD: Recent shooting done in self-defense
ABQnews Seeker
Detectives say a Las Cruces man ... Detectives say a Las Cruces man acted in self-defense when he fatally shot another man Monday evening in an East Central neighborhood in Albuquerque. ...
Proposed congressional map would split ABQ
ABQnews Seeker
Two powerful committee leaders at the ... Two powerful committee leaders at the Capitol — Sen. Joseph Cervantes and Rep. Georgene Louis — proposed a map Tuesday that would give Democrats ...
BCSO offers video, details of shooting by deputy
ABQnews Seeker
An 18-year-old who was shot by ... An 18-year-old who was shot by a Bernalillo County Sheriff's deputy late last month was holding an AR-15 pistol while running toward other deputies, ...
NM reports 969 new cases, 11 deaths
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico reported 969 new COVID-19 ... New Mexico reported 969 new COVID-19 cases on Tuesday — an improvement from recent days — and 11 additional deaths. The state did see ...