Appeals court to revisit Arizona ballot-collection law - Albuquerque Journal

Appeals court to revisit Arizona ballot-collection law

PHOENIX — A dramatically divided federal appeals court voted Wednesday to reconsider a ruling where a panel of its judges refused to block a new Arizona law making it a felony to collect early ballots from voters.

The order from the full 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals assigns an 11-judge panel to reconsider the case just six days before the election. The panel plans an expedited hearing, a court spokesman said.

A three-judge panel on Friday rejected an effort by the state and national Democratic parties and some voters to block the law. They allege it violates the Constitution and the Voting Rights Act because it hurts minorities’ ability to cast ballots.

Twenty-five of the 27 active 9th Circuit judges participated in the vote to rehear the case before what’s known as an “en banc” panel.

The law bars get-out-the vote groups from collecting ballots from voters and then delivering them to election offices. It’s a tactic especially effective in minority communities.

Two appeals court judges wrote opposing opinions about rehearing the case, laying bare deep divisions within the 9th Circuit.

Circuit Judge Stephen Reinhardt called the issue “an urgent case of extraordinary importance involving the suppression of minority voters on the eve of a presidential election.”

He said it is “indeed no secret that many states have recently enacted legislation making it more difficult for members of minority groups to vote in presidential elections,” under the guise of preventing voting fraud. “And not one case of voter fraud has been cited to the district court or this court by Arizona when seeking to defend its indefensible and race-based statute.”

Reinhardt appeared doubtful that the randomly chosen 11-judge en banc panel would block the law, writing that it was weighted in favor of judges who voted against reconsidering the case.

“In my own view, regardless of the decision of the en banc court, I am confident that the court as a whole would have rejected the panel majority’s conclusion and enjoined the enforcement of the Arizona statute, although we will probably never know if I am correct,” Reinhardt wrote “Whether I am or not, I should emphasize that whatever decision the en banc court reaches will be legitimate and will properly be binding on our court and in our Circuit.”

Circuit Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain wrote that the 9th Circuit was making a “serious mistake” by voting to rehear the case.

“Our court risks present chaos and future confusion in pursuit of an outcome the Supreme Court has explicitly told us to avoid,” O’Scannlain wrote. “There are no good reasons_and many bad ones_to take this case en banc six days before the election on such a compressed schedule.”

Four other 9th Circuit judges signed on to O’Scannlain comments.

The legislation, House Bill 2023, was enacted by the Republican-dominated Arizona Legislature early this year and signed by GOP Gov. Doug Ducey. He called it a common-sense effort to protect the integrity of elections and eliminate voter fraud.

Both parties have used ballot collection to boost turnout during elections by going door-to-door and asking voters if they have completed their mail-in ballots. Voters who have not are urged to do so, and the volunteers offer to take the ballots to election offices. Democrats, however, use it more effectively.

A U.S. District Court judge rejected the Democrats’ effort to block the law, saying that limiting one of several ways voters can return completed ballots didn’t significantly increase the burdens of voting. The three-judge appeals court panel split 2-1 in favor of upholding that ruling.

The same three judges on Wednesday rejected a request by Democrats to order that ballots cast by voters in the wrong precinct be counted. A U.S. District Court judge is considering another effort by Democrats that challenges Arizona Secretary of State Michele Reagan’s decision not to extend voter registration by a day even though it fell on Columbus Day.

Home » Around the Region » Appeals court to revisit Arizona ballot-collection law


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
School kicks off year with restorative practices
ABQnews Seeker
While the rest of Garfield STEM ... While the rest of Garfield STEM Magnet and Community School was busy settling back int ...
2
Council OKs safe outdoor space moratorium
ABQnews Seeker
Not clear how action will affect ... Not clear how action will affect applications already in the pipeline
3
US: Drought-stricken states to get less from Colorado River
Around the Region
For the second year in a ... For the second year in a row, Arizona and Nevada will face cuts in the amount of water they can draw from the Colorado ...
4
Council leaves Planned Parenthood funding intact
ABQnews Seeker
Planned Parenthood is still in line ... Planned Parenthood is still in line to get $250,000 from the city of Albuquerque this year. The City Council voted Monday to keep the ...
5
Federal judge orders Shaheen Syed jailed pending trial
ABQnews Seeker
A judge ordered the son of ... A judge ordered the son of a man charged in the shootings of Muslim men in Albuquerque ...
6
Corrales fire truck stolen and recovered
ABQnews Seeker
A fire truck was stolen from ... A fire truck was stolen from the Corrales Fire Department Tuesday morning, according to a Rio Rancho Police Department Facebook post. After multiple agencies ...
7
What's in big Biden bill? Health, climate goals become ...
Nation
President Joe Biden arrived at the ... President Joe Biden arrived at the White House promising to 'build back' America, and legislation he's signing Tuesday delivers a slimmer, though not insignificant, ...
8
Trial begins in effort to remove Couy Griffin from ...
ABQnews Seeker
Otero County Commissioner Couy Griffin admitted ... Otero County Commissioner Couy Griffin admitted a couple of times Monday that he wasn't ready for trial. 'I'm not as prepared as I should ...
9
NM investment funds hit slowdown after rapid growth
From the newspaper
Land Grant Permanent Fund distributions to ... Land Grant Permanent Fund distributions to continue at high level
10
Man faces charges in Coronado Park death
ABQnews Seeker
Joseph Garcia, 28, accused in shooting Joseph Garcia, 28, accused in shooting