Lack of funds hits Public Defender Department hard - Albuquerque Journal

Lack of funds hits Public Defender Department hard

Copyright © 2016 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – In the four years since New Mexico voters approved making the state Public Defender Department a stand-alone agency, independence has not meant prosperity.

Chronic funding problems for the agency, which provides legal defense for those who can’t afford their own attorneys, reached a critical level last month when a Lea County district judge found the state’s chief public defender in contempt for his department’s “failure and refusal to represent” defendants in several criminal cases.

Ben Baur, the state’s chief public defender, warned lawmakers in September that the office would have to start declining cases in certain parts of the state due to a lack of funding, despite a constitutional requirement that representation be provided to all eligible defendants.

He also said the Public Defender Department would be seeking a 10 percent increase in funding in the coming year, which would allow it to hire 25 additional attorneys.

The Office of the Public Defender in Hobbs, which is in Lea County, announced in October that it could not take on any new cases in the adult courts for 90 days.

Baur wrote in court documents that felony cases in Lea County have more than doubled in just five years. Meanwhile, the Hobbs office had two vacancies this fall, leaving just four attorneys struggling to balance more than 1,000 cases. Two contract attorneys together handle an additional 300 to 400 cases at a time.

But even when the office is fully staffed, Baur said, the number of cases has spiked to an unmanageable level.

“What we’ve told the courts, and what I believe,” Baur said, “is that it is not possible, with those caseloads, to give every client effective representation.”

Still, the courts continue to appoint public defenders to new cases and defenders respond with motions explaining that they are unavailable. Every one of those motions, Baur said, has been denied.

Fifth Judicial District Attorney Dianna Luce said in court documents that the unavailability of public defenders has affected more than 200 cases, resulting in a “breakdown of judicial process.” She filed an emergency petition Dec. 1 asking the Supreme Court to require public defenders to represent indigent defendants.

The Supreme Court denied the petition last week. Luce could not be reached for comment.

Margaret Strickland, president-elect of the New Mexico Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, wrote in an op-ed early this month that a judicial system “tilted against the defense” can turn into wrongful convictions and unnecessarily long prison sentences.

“When a lawyer cannot give a case the time it needs, including time for reasonable preparation, he or she is ethically required to decline the case,” Strickland said. “If that lawyer does not decline the case, they could be in jeopardy of disciplinary sanction, including possible loss of license, by the New Mexico bar that licenses lawyers.”

Baur said there are two solutions to the overload.

“It could be more resources,” he said, “or it could be fewer cases.”

But the state is facing a persistent revenue downturn – lawmakers are grappling with a $69 million projected budget deficit for the current fiscal year – and getting a funding boost could be unlikely in the short term.

“We were working with the Legislature to try to phase in budget increases over time,” Baur said. “In the current atmosphere, unfortunately, that doesn’t look like it’s going to happen.”

Rep. Antonio “Moe” Maestas, D-Albuquerque, who pushed the 2012 constitutional amendment that led to the Public Defender Department being made into an independent agency, said the situation with the department has reached a tipping point.

“It’s still far and away underfunded,” Maestas told the Journal . “We get the criminal justice system we pay for.”

He also said public defenders have no control over their caseloads. Charging decisions are made by prosecutors, and the U.S. Constitution guarantees an attorney for all indigent defendants.

Those factors can create a clash for lawyers who, under state judicial standards, are bound to provide competent legal counsel.

“You have an ethical duty to the profession and your clients, but you have a statutory duty to represent clients,” Maestas said. “They’re stressed (to resolve that dilemma) throughout the system, no doubt about it.”

Other states have experienced similar funding challenges.

In Missouri, the state’s frustrated lead public defender in August ordered the governor, Democrat Jay Nixon, to represent a man accused of assault, but the governor fought the order and claimed it was not legal.

Officials with the Public Defender Department have expressed concerns for years about underfunding and its impact on the state’s judicial system.

Last year, the agency requested an eye-opening budget increase of more than 100 percent, which it claimed was necessary to provide adequate representation. It ended up getting an increase of less than 10 percent.

Over the past four years, funding for the Public Defender Department has grown by roughly 18 percent – from $40.2 million in the 2013 budget year to $47.4 million in the current year. That’s more than twice as fast as overall state budget growth during that same time period.

But lawmakers cut the agency’s funding by 3 percent – or nearly $1.5 million – in a special session held this fall. The budgets of other state agencies also were cut during the special session.

New Mexico lawmakers recently barred the Public Defender Department from paying hourly rates to outside contract attorneys.

Home » Journal North » Journal North Recent News » Lack of funds hits Public Defender Department hard

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

We need a DA who will reduce incarceration
From the newspaper
The recent election of 2nd Judicial ... The recent election of 2nd Judicial District Attorney Raúl Torrez to the state attorney generalR ...
Albuquerque Little Theatre brings 'A Tuna Christmas' to stage
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Little Theatre gets in the ... Albuquerque Little Theatre gets in the holiday spirit with "A Tuna Christmas."The prod ...
Editorial: Why would CYFD return girl again and again ...
On Monday night, Nicholas Clinton was ... On Monday night, Nicholas Clinton was so inebriated that he and his 5-year-old daughter were denied ...
Lawmakers discuss new oversight for NM prisons
ABQnews Seeker
Hefty legal settlements over past year ... Hefty legal settlements over past year draw attention, calls for action
'Our new Santa': Good Samaritan gifts bike after clothing ...
ABQnews Seeker
Crime occurred Tuesday night at Northeast ... Crime occurred Tuesday night at Northeast Albuquerque nonprofit
Fishing Line for Dec. 8, 2022
Fishing Line
New Mexico offers many options to hit the cross ...
From the newspaper
Enchanted Forest Cross Country Ski Area ... Enchanted Forest Cross Country Ski Area set among 600 acres of the Carson National Forest has nearly 19 miles of trails and another 11 ...
Fifth-year senior 'Uncle Mo' Udeze mentors his Lobo freshman ...
ABQnews Seeker
'He’s definitely the big dog in ... 'He’s definitely the big dog in the house,' says one roomie Donovan Dent
Lobo football: Freshman All-American enters transfer portal
UNM freshman A.J. Haulcy (24) reacts ... UNM freshman A.J. Haulcy (24) reacts with teammates after a play during the Lobos' Sept. 17 home win over UTEP. (Chancey Bush/Journal)A.J. Haulcy, who ...