Fed up with tough talk, civic groups to grade crime bills - Albuquerque Journal

Fed up with tough talk, civic groups to grade crime bills

SANTA FE, N.M. — A coalition of civil liberties, human rights and faith-based groups in New Mexico has created a new litmus test for criminal justice legislation designed to encourage proposals based on evidence and question highly politicized calls for harsh penalties.

Members of the coalition, called New Mexico Safe, plan to assign letter grades to major criminal justice bills before the proposals reach initial committee hearings when the Legislature convenes in January.

The initiative responds to a sense of frustration over hard-line crime legislation, New Mexico ACLU Public Policy Director Steven Robert Allen said.

“We’ve experienced some horrible crimes in New Mexico in recent years, and I get the sort of reactive approach from an emotion standpoint,” said Allen, describing recent efforts to increase minimum sentences and reinstate the death penalty. “They don’t seem to be grounded in any targeted way in actually increasing public safety.”

Participants in the effort include the League of Women Voters, the Albuquerque NAACP, the Conference of Catholic Bishops, the National Association of Social Workers and many others. The coalition’s four-point evaluation system was designed to focus legislative conversations on crime-reducing strategies that have a proven track record for improving public safety and conserving public funds amid a state budget crisis.

To illustrate the approach, New Mexico Safe rated several recent criminal justice bills and resolutions, giving a “B” grade to a Republican-sponsored 2015 initiative that created a task force to study new housing options for mentally ill inmates who might otherwise linger in jail at the public’s expense. The coalition gave a “D” to a failed 2016 proposal that would have classified as a hate crime the targeted killing of a police officer or emergency first responder.

The co-sponsor of that legislation, Republican House floor leader Rep. Nate Gentry, defended the bill as an appropriate response to recent killings of police officers in New Mexico, while welcoming the new effort to provide broader research and information. He noted his own support for alternative sentencing that incorporates mental health and substance abuse treatment.

“If you talk to district attorneys and police and the people who are responsible for getting those violent , repeat offenders off the street, there is a need for increased penalties” to protect law enforcement officers, he said.

Gentry used a special legislative session in October to usher a trio of tougher sentencing laws for violent crimes through the House. The measures were never considered by the Democrat-led Senate, but they became fodder for political attack ads painting several lawmakers as soft on crime or dismissive of victims of violence.

In November elections, Democrats took back majority control of the House of Representatives and increased their majority advantage in the Senate. Incoming Democratic legislative leaders have openly criticized as electioneering recent efforts to reinstate the death penalty and expand mandatory three-strikes sentencing.

Come January, the Legislature also will be under pressure to shore up funding to the judiciary, where payments to juries and interpreters is expected to run out March 1, and to the Office of the Public Defender, where overwhelmed attorneys have turned down hundreds of cases for indigent defendants this year in response to budget constraints.

Chief Public Defender Bennett Baur said Tuesday that the Legislature is likely to hear proposals next year to reduce penalties for traffic penalties and low-level misdemeanors, freeing up resources to address more severe crimes.

Home » ABQnews Seeker » Fed up with tough talk, civic groups to grade crime bills


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
There's a new baby at the BioPark
ABQnews Seeker
Orangutan Sarah gives birth to a ... Orangutan Sarah gives birth to a male, her fifth offspring with partner Tonka
2
US House reps team up on bipartisan water, drought ...
ABQnews Seeker
Databases help groups weigh scarce water ... Databases help groups weigh scarce water conditions
3
Legislative leaders clash over Capitol firearms ban
ABQnews Seeker
Dispute is the latest round in ... Dispute is the latest round in a long-running fight over security at the Roundhouse
4
Documents detail rape allegations against shooter
ABQnews Seeker
Man who killed two teens and ... Man who killed two teens and himself was under investigation
5
APD: Man detained after lengthy standoff, shooting at police ...
ABQnews Seeker
A man is in custody hours ... A man is in custody hours after authorities say he fired at officers from a balcony Thursday evening in a Southeast Albuquerque neighborhood. Daren ...
6
False report of active gunman disrupts Santa Fe hospital
ABQnews Seeker
A bogus report of an active ... A bogus report of an active gunman at Christus St. Vincent Regional Medical Center in Santa Fe spawned a massive police presence at the ...
7
Dem state auditor hopefuls spar over ethics, experience
From the newspaper
Contrasts and conflicts may help voters ... Contrasts and conflicts may help voters to make up their minds
8
APD solving more homicides
ABQnews Seeker
Department touts 97% clearance rate with ... Department touts 97% clearance rate with 47 suspects arrested
9
Fire growth slows to 1,000 acres
ABQnews Seeker
Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire could rally ... Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire could rally with Friday winds
10
Incumbent BernCo commissioner faces challenger
ABQnews Seeker
District 5 rep touts record of ... District 5 rep touts record of service