Judge rejects challenge to initiative raising minimum wage

PHOENIX — A judge on Wednesday refused to block a new voter-approved law raising Arizona’s minimum wage, turning away a challenge from top business groups in the state.

Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley rejected arguments from the Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry, other chamber groups and a Phoenix-area restaurant operator that the law didn’t contain a source of revenue to handle increased state costs.

Kiley said the law exempts the state itself from having to pay the higher wages and there’s no mandate that it pay its contractors more for work they do on the state’s behalf, so the need for to a new revenue source isn’t triggered.

He also noted that though the state’s Medicaid program had decided to increase reimbursement rates on Jan. 1 for nursing homes, home health care aides and providers of care for developmentally disabled people, there’s no federal or state mandate that it do so.

Kiley accepted an argument by state Attorney General Mark Brnovich that the Legislature isn’t forced to fund the increases caused by the new law. Brnovich’s office defended the law along with proponents of Proposition 206, the measure that raises the minimum wage from $8.05 an hour to $10 on Jan. 1 and to $12 in 2020.

The judge also turned away an argument that the law illegally contained two separate subjects — a minimum wage increase and a mandate that employers give workers sick pay.

An estimated 700,000 Arizonans earn less than $10 an hour now, according to federal statistics cited by backers of the law.

The raises approved by the state Medicaid program are expected to cost $48 million for six months, although all but $11 million is federal money.

Kiley’s ruling turned away an effort to temporarily block the wage law pending a full trial. A trial could still be held, but it would likely be months away.

Chamber spokesman Garrick Taylor said the group’s leaders will consult with their attorneys and decide whether to appeal. If filed, an appeal would likely go directly to the Arizona Supreme Court.

“We have concerns regarding the constitutionality of the initiative and so we’ll determine whether that conversation continues,” Taylor said.

Tomas Robles, chairman of the group that backed the initiative, said the Chamber was claiming poverty for its members while spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on legal fees.

“I’m glad that the judge chose to be on the right side of history, and really protecting democracy more than anything,” Robles said. “The Chamber themselves are looking to completely disregard the will of the people, the will of the voters, because they want to keep their pockets fat.”

Share Your Story

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Judge rejects challenge to NM vaccine mandate
From the newspaper
Ruling marks the latest legal victory ... Ruling marks the latest legal victory for Gov. Lujan Grisham
2
Redistricting proposals show shifts in CD-1 map
ABQnews Seeker
ABQ and Santa Fe could join, ... ABQ and Santa Fe could join, as citizens group seeks input
3
A makeover for APS board: No incumbents running this ...
ABQnews Seeker
Influential local commercial real estate group ... Influential local commercial real estate group backing three candidates on the Nov. 2 ballot
4
Prison gang defendant convicted of murder
ABQnews Seeker
Long-running federal racketeering case ends for ... Long-running federal racketeering case ends for Syndicato de Nuevo Mexico
5
New Mexico reports 13 more COVID-19 deaths
ABQnews Seeker
There were 882 new cases and ... There were 882 new cases and 388 people are hospitalized
6
Direct ABQ-Hollywood flight to begin in January
ABQnews Seeker
A new daily direct flight between ... A new daily direct flight between Albuquerque and Hollywood Burbank Airport ...
7
Rio Rancho theater group finally premieres 'Our Town'
ABQnews Seeker
Pandemic interrupted debut of the new ... Pandemic interrupted debut of the new troupe
8
APD still looking for suspect in fatal bar shooting
ABQnews Seeker
The man accused in a quadruple ... The man accused in a quadruple shooting that left one man dead outside an Albuquerque sports bar is still on the loose. Gilbert Gallegos, ...
9
Deputies shoot, injure person in Santa Fe
ABQnews Seeker
State Police, on Twitter, said no ... State Police, on Twitter, said no deputies were injured in the incident
10
Atrisco Acequia event on Saturday offers education
ABQnews Seeker
Community can learn about urban irrigation ... Community can learn about urban irrigation canals and share ideas to improve outdoor amenities