Legislator seeks new way to evaluate students - Albuquerque Journal

Legislator seeks new way to evaluate students

A Democratic state senator says New Mexico needs to take a fresh look at the way it measures student achievement – a key component of teacher evaluations, as well as school and district grades.

Sen. Michael Padilla of Albuquerque has introduced a joint memorial asking the Public Education Department and Legislative Education Study Committee to convene a working group to develop an “alternative assessment model” that goes beyond standardized test scores.

Currently, the PED mandates several exams statewide, including the controversial Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers, which tracks progress in math and English.

In most cases, PED weighs improvement on standardized tests like PARCC as half of a teacher’s evaluation, with measures like student surveys and attendance making up the other half. Test scores also affect school and district letter grades, which PED calculates each year.

Padilla argues that those calculations should consider other measures of student success.

“I think just filling in a bubble on a test, there is so much more to that young person’s life,” he said. “They may be skilled in art; they may be a musician.”

Standardized tests can’t capture diverse abilities, Padilla said, so school grades are presenting only part of the picture.

Statewide, nearly as many schools earned F’s as A’s – 13 percent versus 14 percent – in the latest round of grading. The most common grade was a C.

The school grades consider a variety of factors besides test scores, including attendance, graduation rates and parent surveys.

“If you take a look at the current assessment model that Gov. (Susana) Martinez and Secretary (Hanna) Skandera have implemented, it is essentially devastating entire communities,” Padilla said. “When you think about the elementary school in our neighborhood, that is the anchor in our communities. When you label an entire school an F, as an example, every student goes to school every morning, wakes up every morning, puts their clothes on and does homework at night and says, ‘My goodness, I go to an F school.’ ”

Members of the proposed working group – community leaders, teachers, school administrators, researchers and higher-education representatives – would meet through fall 2017 to come up with a new approach. For instance, students could receive a cumulative score that combines traditional exam results with other measures, such as final presentations or portfolios.

Those cumulative scores would be weighed in teacher evaluations, as well as school and district grades, to assess “the full body of student work, rather than just one or two tests,” Padilla said.

“You have bipartisan across-the-state and across-the-aisle support for an alternative system,” he said. “This is actually going to be a solution that is derived from the community rather than just forced on the community.”

In an emailed statement, PED spokesman Robert McEntyre said PARCC is one of the best assessments in the country and it is delivering results for thousands of kids.

New Mexico PARCC results went up in 2016, the second year the state administered the exam: 57 out of 89 districts improved in English; 77 improved in math.

According to PED, roughly 12,000 more students are on grade level in reading or math compared with last year.

Still, on the latest round of PARCC testing, only 19.9 percent of students met or exceeded expectations in math and 27.7 percent in English.

Tony Monfiletto, New Mexico Center for School Leadership director and a supporter of the joint memorial, said standardized test results are valuable but limited.

The center’s four charter schools – ACE Leadership High, Tech Leadership High, Health Leadership High and Siembra Leadership High – already look beyond scores, requiring a capstone project that demonstrates students’ ability to solve a real-world problem in their chosen field.

The Leadership high schools, which attract kids who struggle in traditional classrooms, have not fared well in PED’s grading system, earning D’s and an F.

Their school reports show that few students are on grade level and test scores did not improve markedly. But the Leadership network got high marks for student attendance, as well as parent and student surveys that rate the schools as “good places to learn.”

Monfiletto said his curriculum stresses “applied learning” – skills such as teamwork and ingenuity that are valuable to employers but difficult to measure on a bubble sheet.

“There has been a ton of work done around the country in rethinking what assessment would look like to match the future economy and the future needs of states and communities,” Monfiletto said. “Standardized tests are part of that, but not the full picture.”

He argued that the PED should take advantage of a recent federal law, the Every Student Succeeds Act, that gives states more freedom to craft their own education policies. ESSA replaced No Child Left Behind in December 2015 with strong bipartisan support.

Under ESSA, seven states will receive funding to pilot assessment systems that use “multiple measures of student academic achievement from multiple sources.”

“ESSA is very ambitious about moving control and innovation back to the states and hoping states come forward with new ideas around assessment,” Monfiletto said. “We want to be part of that conversation.”

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Legislator seeks new way to evaluate students

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Fine with Fido: 7 Albuquerque-area establishments that welcome dogs
ABQnews Seeker
Coffee houses, food halls and breweries ... Coffee houses, food halls and breweries all appear on our round-up of of dog-loving businesses.
Grammer: When it comes to fans, the obnoxious few ...
ABQnews Seeker
Utah State guard Max Shulga showed ... Utah State guard Max Shulga showed class in his response to unacceptable taunts from a few Colorado State students.
Man critically injured in Santa Fe shooting
ABQnews Seeker
A man was critically injured after ... A man was critically injured after being shot in a Santa Fe apartment complex on Saturday night.
Three teenagers found dead in garage in Edgewood
ABQnews Seeker
Police said in a news release ... Police said in a news release there is no indication of foul play and it appears to have been carbon monoxide poisoning.
Man, woman killed in Hobbs hit-and-run crash
ABQnews Seeker
A man and a woman were ... A man and a woman were killed in Hobbs on Friday night after being struck by a vehicle while walking their dog, according to ...
Child, 10, allegedly sexually assaulted by foster teen at ...
ABQnews Seeker
The offices of the state child ... The offices of the state child welfare agency are used to house foster children despite New Mexico’s promise to provide them with appropriate homes.
Civilians fill in for sworn officers at Albuquerque Police ...
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Police Chief Harold Medina said ... Albuquerque Police Chief Harold Medina said he sees hiring civilians as "the forefront of the wave of the future." He added: "The civilians are ...
How close did Albuquerque come to a record-high temperature?
ABQnews Seeker
Temperatures in the Duke City reached ... Temperatures in the Duke City reached 63 degrees, said Jennifer Shoemake, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service in Albuquerque. That was the warmest ...
Study says New Mexico turning blind eye to several ...
ABQnews Seeker
A UNM study argues that the ... A UNM study argues that the state government, in its efforts to meet climate goals, stops short of requiring cuts to greenhouse gas emissions ...