To work, assisted dying needs clear limits - Albuquerque Journal

To work, assisted dying needs clear limits

Early this year, different end of life options are being debated in the New Mexico Legislature, including assisted dying. I am myself a citizen of the first country that permitted assisted dying.

As a professor of ethics, I served on a committee overseeing the practice in the Netherlands for nine years.

Allowing aid in dying in the Netherlands dates back to 1985, when it was recommended that physician-assisted dying would no longer be punishable under a set of conditions, most importantly a well-informed patient request and the presence of unbearable suffering without prospect of improvement.

In 1994, physician-assisted dying was made legal in the form of a special clause in an existing law, followed by a separate law in 2001. Five regional committees (consisting of a lawyer, a physician and an ethicist) assess each case of physician-assisted dying and see whether it has fulfilled the criteria.

During my years on one of these committees (2005 to 2014), I personally reviewed 4,000 cases. Given the widespread support for physician-assisted dying in my country, I was convinced that legalization was the wisest, most respectful and most compassionate route.

However, it is not without concern that I have seen physician-assisted dying develop in the Netherlands.

In the first two decades, the numbers remained stable but, starting in 2007, the numbers headed up from 1,800 to more than 5,500 per year in 2015.

One in 25 deaths is now the result of physician-assisted dying.

From being a last resort, physician-assisted dying is on the road to becoming a preferred, if not the only, acceptable mode of dying in the case of cancer.

“Assisted dying” and “dying with dignity” have become virtual synonyms, with public opinion shifting toward considering it a patient’s right and a physician’s duty. Pressure on doctors can be intense.

Other developments include the formation of a network of traveling euthanizing doctors (the “End of Life Clinic”), providing physician-assisted dying to patients without a prior doctor-patient relationship.

From 29 cases in 2012, the clinic helped 365 people in 2015.

And whereas, in the pioneering years, virtually no patients with psychiatric illnesses or dementia were euthanized, we counted 160 such cases in 2015 alone.

The developments continue to unfold.

There is a strong public advocacy for legalizing child euthanasia. On Oct. 12, the Dutch Minister of Health announced state-organized physician-assisted dying for any elderly person who asks for it and who suffers from age, loneliness, meaninglessness or bereavement.

In the pioneering years in the Netherlands, terminal cancer was the most common reason for assisted dying. In hindsight, one of our biggest mistakes may have been that we did not include terminal illness as a condition. But even if we had done so, could we have contained the practice?

In the Netherlands, patient organizations have effectively campaigned for broader access to physician-assisted dying: Why only those with a terminal disease? Why only those with physical disease? Why only adults? Why only competent patients?

Indeed, why only those with a disease? To be honest, the cases that broke my heart the most during my time on the committee were people who were not even facing death: cases of sexual abuse, war traumas, a serious work-related setback with which a person is psychologically unable to cope.

In many markets, supply creates demand. My experience is that assisted dying is no exception.

Although I can very well sympathize with the suffering of so many, a physician-assisted dying law may have paradoxical effects.

Speaking for the Netherlands: In three decades, physician-assisted dying has not only relieved much suffering, but it has also changed our whole view on suffering, coping, aging and dying.

Other states may want to take that into account when they consider the options at the end of life.

Theo Boer is a professor of Ethics at the Universities of Kampen and Groningen, the Netherlands. He recently was visiting in Rio Rancho.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » To work, assisted dying needs clear limits

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
New Mexico Finance Authority launches program to rehabilitate homes
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico Finance Authority launches ... New Mexico Finance Authority launches program to rehabilitate homes.
Vara bringing a taste of Spain with its Tinto ...
ABQnews Seeker
The 2020 vintage of Tinto Especial ... The 2020 vintage of Tinto Especial focuses on Spanish influences from the Catalonia region.
Singer-songwriter Logan Ledger to open for Vincent Neil Emerson
ABQnews Seeker
Logan Ledger's upcoming album, "Golden State" ... Logan Ledger's upcoming album, "Golden State" is due out on Sept. 8, but he's hitting the road opening for Vincent Neil Emerson.
Documentary looks at the crucial role libraries play in ...
ABQnews Seeker
"Library Stories: Books on the Backroads" ... "Library Stories: Books on the Backroads" will air at 7 p.m. Thursday, June 15, on New Mexico PBS.
Lobo Mazza-Downie runs to All-America status at NCAA Championship ...
ABQnews Seeker
University of New Mexico runner Amelia ... University of New Mexico runner Amelia Mazza-Downie finished fourth on Thursday night in the women's 10,000-meter final at the NCAA Outdoor Track and Field ...
Do-it-all Montes reaching a new level as Isotope hitter
ABQnews Seeker
Loosely translated, "Coco" means coconut in ... Loosely translated, "Coco" means coconut in Spanish. In 2023 minor league baseball terms, with Isotope Coco Montes it's synonymous with raking.
Socorro businesses, locals brace for Bandidos funeral
From the newspaper
Town's liquor establishments are expected to ... Town's liquor establishments are expected to be closed and law enforcement is on heightened alert ahead of weekend funeral for biker who died in ...
Editorial: CYFD must learn from tragic failures, re-evaluate policies
From the Editorial Board: The governor ... From the Editorial Board: The governor and CYFD need to examine the child welfare agency's policies regarding drug use in the home, tracking abuse, ...
Albuquerque Regional Economic Alliance, CBRE highlight metro area’s diverse ...
ABQnews Seeker
"This report, updated annually, has become ... "This report, updated annually, has become one of our top economic development publications used to articulate our value proposition and market the region to ...