As prices recover, oil companies say they're not likely to go back to old ways - Albuquerque Journal

As prices recover, oil companies say they’re not likely to go back to old ways

A Patterson-UTI drilling rigs that uses hydraulic feet to “walk” from one drill site to another. This one operates in West Texas. (Patterson-UTI Drilling Company)

DALLAS — The oil industry’s history is punctuated with boom-and-busts cycles that create and erase fortunes and drive economies.

That sector is tentatively emerging from the worst downturn since at least the 1980s. Oil prices hovered around $100 per barrel in 2014 before dropping by half just months later, a level where they remain. A year ago, prices dipped below $30 for the first time since 2003, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

Much like the recovery from the Great Recession a decade ago, oil’s bounce back has been hesitant. Experts say technology, slower demand and a more cautious approach by oil patch executives and bankers could — at least in the near term — give the industry a leaner look.

Companies are automating jobs once held by traditional oilfield workers and focusing on projects that can succeed with today’s modest and uncertain oil prices.

Jim Kiser, lead client service partner in Deloitte’s energy industry practice, said this wasn’t an ordinary cycle.

“What’s different about this is the pace of the price decline and the depth,” he said. “Most didn’t believe it would go that low, and most didn’t believe it would stay that low.”

That bust was felt strongly in oil field employment.

Last March, Texas saw an overall job loss for the first time in 11 months because of oil’s price slump. Worldwide, an estimated 440,000 plus oil industry jobs were lost, according the consulting firm Graves & Co.

That’s slowly improving now. There were job gains late last year. And the January monthly jobs report for Texas estimated that about 1,900 new jobs were created in the energy sector.

Michael Walls, a Colorado School of Mines professor who has written about corporate risk-taking in the oil and gas industry, said there is always restructuring when a downturn is this severe. Following all the consolidations and bankruptcies, the industry is likely to keep job growth in check.

“You’re going to see companies trying to operate even leaner, although they’re pretty lean right now based on the numbers of layoffs the industry has experienced,” he said.

Even with fewer jobs, there could also be a supply problem too. Kiser said his company’s clients are concerned about attracting new employees as the business starts growing again.

“There are a lot of people who left the industry as a result of the contraction that took place in a short amount of time,” he said. “And some of those (people) are going to be hesitant to come back.”

Computer scientists, engineers and business analysts have other options, ones with less risk of severe boom-and-bust cycles, Kiser said. Skilled field staff, including electricians, welders and pipefitters, could also be in demand and scarce.

Chris Cheatwood, executive vice president of business development and geoscience at Pioneer Natural Resources, said geography could also be a hindrance. The Permian Basin in West Texas and New Mexico is one of the hottest fields now since it’s economic to drill even in the $30 to $35 range.

“It’s very difficult to get that many people, one, to move there, and two, to sustain that number people in what’s frankly a pretty remote part of the country,” he said.

But it’s also likely that fewer workers would be needed as more drilling work is automated and companies operate more efficiently.

Cheatwood said Pioneer’s cost to drill has dropped by at least 35 percent in recent years and continues to go down. That has been driven, in part, by the shale revolution. He said new drilling techniques and technology showed that shale provides the industry with a “newfound bounty of oil” in the United States.

And without high oil prices, efficiency is crucial to shale oil.

“We have a reason to push that competitive edge,” Cheatwood said. “We have proven that we have a huge resource base here in the United States that can compete on a global scale.”

Pioneer has started drilling in more repetitive patterns in the Permian and using “walking” rigs that use hydraulic feet to walk from site to site without a complete tear down and reassembly. That’s cut transportation time between drill sites by half.

“We were drilling the same zone over and over, so sort of drilling the same well over and over,” he said. “So we began to drill them faster.”

They now drill wells in about 15 days rather than 30 or 45 days.

Even the financiers may soon show a new willingness to lend, said Bernard “Buddy” Clark, co-chairman of the Energy Practice Group at Haynes and Boone. Since the downturn, banks have been more restrictive with the independent producers.

“If the industry learns a lesson from the downturn from a financial perspective, it’s less debt and more equity,” he said.

Mike Holcomb, president of Patterson-UTI Drilling Company, which operates in the U.S., Canada and Dubai, said the market was forgiving at $100 a barrel. But drilling inevitably became more efficient as the industry contracted when prices dropped. Eventually, the best crews and best rigs were drilling in the best locations.

A new boom would cut some of that efficiency, he said.

“The industry tends to get a little sloppier naturally.”


©2017 The Dallas Morning News

Visit The Dallas Morning News at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


State, labs seek zero-carbon hydrogen economy
ABQnews Seeker
Agencies hope to 'reach net zero ... Agencies hope to 'reach net zero emissions by 2050'
New Mexico front and center in nationwide debate over ...
ABQnews Seeker
Taken together, two forthcoming bills would ... Taken together, two forthcoming bills would create a suite of government-funded incentives to help companies construct everything from hydrogen production and hydrogen-based electric generation ...
Relief funds to 'supersize' NM well plugging
ABQnews Seeker
$25 million allocated to state to ... $25 million allocated to state to clean up abandoned wells
Company fails to deliver fuel, prompting suit from state ...
ABQnews Seeker
Bob's Gas says it can't hire ... Bob's Gas says it can't hire the required staff to get the propane out
Lawmakers seek more research on public power
Formal analysis would study cost and ... Formal analysis would study cost and benefits
PRC denies PNM Four Corners coal plant exit
ABQnews Seeker
Commission asks the utility for more ... Commission asks the utility for more information on replacement resources
New Mexico AG launches propane shortage inquiry
ABQnews Seeker
Suppliers point to labor problems Suppliers point to labor problems
ABQ solar industry firm to be acquired in $80M ...
ABQnews Seeker
SolAero, which makes cells, panels for ... SolAero, which makes cells, panels for spacecraft, will remain in Albuquerque
PRC to vote on PNM exit from Four Corners ...
ABQnews Seeker
State regulators are expected to vote ... State regulators are expected to vote Wednesday on Public Service Company of New Mexico's plan ...